Table 1.
Model | Scar Location | Advantages | Disadvantages |
---|---|---|---|
Rabbit ear HTS * model [124,125] | Ventral side of rabbit ear | Simple, reliable model Ease of handling Possibility of creating multiple wounds |
Skin of the ventral side is too difficult to handle because of low thickness Involvement of cells other than skin cells during healing, such as chondrocytes Risk of damaging the underlying cartilage |
Modified rabbit ear HTS model—use of cryosurgery [126] | Ventral side of rabbit ear | Low risk of damaging the cartilage | Skin of the ventral side is too difficult to handle because of low thickness Involvement of cells other than skin cells during healing, such as chondrocyte |
Modified Rabbit ear HTS model—application of thermal injury [127] | Ventral side of rabbit ear | Elevated scar within short duration compared to the typical rabbit ear HTS model | Skin of the ventral side is too difficult to handle because of low thickness Involvement of cells other than skin cells during healing, such as chondrocytes Uncontrolled thermal injury can cause variability in scarring effect |
HTS model on rabbit by injecting anhydrous alcohol [128] | Dorsal skin | HTS-like appearance comparable to the rabbit ear HTS model Low cost Ease of handling |
Absence of healing response |
Burn hypertrophic model on porcine skin [57] | Dorsal Skin | Elevated scar comparable to human scar | High cost Difficult to handle |
HTS model by splinting of rat wound [131] | Dorsal skin | HTS-like features by reducing the formation of neo-epithelium Low cost Ease of handling |
Splinting may create a higher and more persistent tensional state |
Scar on CXCR3 * deficient mouse [134] | Dorsal skin | Simple, reliable model Ease of handling |
The model requires further validation |
HTS model produced by grafting human xenografts on nude mice [139] | Dorsal skin | Establishment of human scar on an animal model | Difficulty in maintaining nude mice Absence of immune response in mice |
HTS model by resecting abdominal wall muscle on mice [137] | Ventral skin, abdominal region | Simple and reliable method Ease of handling |
Not comparable with general scar development after burn injury or trauma |
* Abbreviations: HTS (hypertrophic scar); CXCR3 (C–X–C motif chemokine receptor 3).