Skip to main content
. 2023 Mar 2;20(5):4466. doi: 10.3390/ijerph20054466

Table 2.

Study characteristics.

Study Sample Size Population Intervention Group Comparison Group Main outcomes and
Measurement Tools
Follow-Up Period
Castien et al. [83] 80 Men and women aged 20–63
diagnosed with chronic TTH
Manual therapy treatment: mobilizations of the cervical and thoracic spine, postural correction and cervical stabilization exercises. 2 sessions/week, 9 sessions, 30 min/session. No intervention Intensity of pain: Numeric Rating Scale
Headache frequency: personal diary
headache duration personal diary
8 weeks
26 weeks
Ajimsha [84] 56 Men and women aged 18–50 diagnosed with TTH TG1: Direct techniques for myofascial release in trapezius major, suboccipital, temporalis, neck flexors, mastoids muscles and Epicranial fascia. 2 sessions/week, 60 min/session. 12 weeks.
TG2: Indirect techniques for myofascial release in skull base, posterior cervical musculature, hair, ears and facial musculature. 2 sessions/week, 60 min/session. 12 weeks.
No intervention Headache frequency: personal diary 3 months
Da Silva et al. [85] 43 Pregnant women aged 18–39 diagnosed with TTH Conventional acupuncture and additional points (trigger or painful points of splenius capitis, masseters and temporalis muscles) leaving the needles for 25 min. 2 session/week. 4 weeks No intervention Pain intensity (morning and evening): Numerical Rating Scale 3 months
Berggreen et al. [86] 38 Women aged 18–65
diagnosed with chronic TTH
Trigger Points treatment with frictions across or circulating in muscle fibers, ischemic compression, held from 30 to 60 s. Included muscles: trapezius (upper part), sternocleidomastoid, masseter, temporalis, medial and lateral pterygoid, anterior neck, facial, occipitofrontalis, splenius capitis and splenius cervicis, posterior cervical, and suboccipital muscles. 1 session/week. 10 weeks No intervention Pain intensity: Visual Analogical Scale Pre-Post treatment
Espí-López et al. [87] 86 Men and women aged 18–65 diagnosed with TTH TG1: Suboccipital soft tissue inhibition. 4 session/week. 4 weeks
TG2: Occiput-atlas-axis manipulative treatment
4 session/week. 4 weeks
TG3: G1 + G2 treatments combined. 4 session/week. 4 weeks.
Intragroup comparison Pain Severity and
headache frequency: Headache Disability Inventory
Pre-Post treatment
Moraska et al. [88] 62 Men and women aged 18–59 diagnosed with TTH Massage: 15 min of myofascial of back, shoulders, chest, and neck; 20 min of trigger point release applied bilaterally to upper trapezius, suboccipital muscles, and both sternocleidomastoid; the final 10 min consisted of post-isometric relaxation directed at the right and left lateral cervical flexion, circular, or cross-fiber friction on the masseter, temporalis, and occipital-frontalis muscles, as well as gentle effleurage and petrissage on the neck and shoulders. 2 sessions/weeks. 6 weeks Intragroup comparison Pain intensity: Visual Analogical Scale.
Frequency (episodes/week)
Interview.
Duration (hour/episode): Interview.
Pre-Post treatment and 1 month
Chassot et al. [89] 34 Women Aged 18–60 diagnosed with chronic TTH Electroacupuncture: 16 acupuncture needles
connected to an electro-stimulator for 30 min. 10 sessions. Twice/week. 5 weeks
Placebo Pain intensity: visual analogical scale Post treatment
Espí-López et al. [90] 102 Men and women aged 18–65 diagnosed with TTH Occiput-atlas-axis manipulation (OAA) and soft tissue massage.1 session/week. 4 weeks Massage
1 session/week. 4 weeks
Pain Severity and headache frequency: Headache Disability Inventory Pre- Post treatment and 2 months
Ferragut-Garcías et al. [91] 97 Men and women aged 18–65 diagnosed with TTH TG1: Soft tissues techniques.1 session/week.4 weeks
TG2: Neural mobilization techniques 1 session/week.4 weeks
TG3: Combined treatment involving soft tissue and neural mobilization techniques
1 session/week. 4 weeks
Placebo Pain intensity: Visual analogical scale
Headache frequency: personal diary
Post treatment and 1 month
Georgoudis et al. [92] 44 Men and women aged 18–65 diagnosed with TTH Microwaves and myofascial release combined with acupuncture. 10 sessions. Acupuncture Pain intensity: Visual analogical scale Pre-Post treatment
Pérez-Llanes et al. [93] 25 Men and women diagnosed with chronic TTH Combined treatment with suboccipital muscle inhibition and interferential current. 2 sessions/week, 20 min/session. Standard routine care (no interventions) Intensity of pain: Numeric Rating Scale 4 weeks
Schiller et al. [94] 96 Men and women aged 18–65 diagnosed with chronic TTH TG1: Acupuncture
TG2: Medical training therapy (cardiovascular, strength-endurance, coordinative, proprioceptive, mobility and flexibility training), TG3: Combination of acupuncture and medical training.
6 weeks, 12 treatment units in decreasing frequency (3 sessions in weeks 1 and 2, 2 sessions in weeks 3 and 4, 1 session in weeks 5 and 6).
Standard routine care (no interventions) Pain intensity: Verbal Rating Scale
Frequency of headache: personal diary (days/month)
Duration of headache: personal diary (hours/month)
Frequency of headache medication intake: personal diary(days/month)
3 months
6 months
Corum et al. [95] 45 Men and women aged 19–48 diagnosed with TTH TG1: Manipulation group: High-velocity low-amplitude (HVLA) manipulation plus exercise. 2 sessions/week for 4 weeks.
TG2: Myofascial release group: suboccipital inhibition plus exercise. 2 sessions/week for 4 weeks.
Exercise intervention Headache frequency: personal diary (days/2-week)
Headache pain severity: Visual Analogical Scale
Pre-Post-
treatment and
3 months
Gopichandran et al. [96] 169 Adult men and women diagnosed with chronic TTH Progressive muscle relaxation (PMR) and deep breathing exercises. 12 weeks, 20 min,5 sessions/week, in the evening with an instruction booklet Standard routine care (no interventions) Pain intensity: Wong-Baker Faces Pain Scale 4 weeks
8 weeks
12 weeks
Runa et al. [97] 252 Men and women aged 18–75 diagnosed with anxiety and TTH Warming acupuncture and moxibustion at temples combined with Deanxit (drug to improve depression and anxiety) Warm acupuncture therapy (predominantly around the temple area) Pain intensity: Visual Analogue Score
Frequency of tension type headache: Interview
Duration of tension type headache: Interview
Pre-Post treatment

TTH = Tension Type Headache, TG = Treatment Group.