Table 2.
Study | Sample Size | Population | Intervention Group | Comparison Group | Main outcomes and Measurement Tools |
Follow-Up Period |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Castien et al. [83] | 80 | Men and women aged 20–63 diagnosed with chronic TTH |
Manual therapy treatment: mobilizations of the cervical and thoracic spine, postural correction and cervical stabilization exercises. 2 sessions/week, 9 sessions, 30 min/session. | No intervention | Intensity of pain: Numeric Rating Scale Headache frequency: personal diary headache duration personal diary |
8 weeks 26 weeks |
Ajimsha [84] | 56 | Men and women aged 18–50 diagnosed with TTH | TG1: Direct techniques for myofascial release in trapezius major, suboccipital, temporalis, neck flexors, mastoids muscles and Epicranial fascia. 2 sessions/week, 60 min/session. 12 weeks. TG2: Indirect techniques for myofascial release in skull base, posterior cervical musculature, hair, ears and facial musculature. 2 sessions/week, 60 min/session. 12 weeks. |
No intervention | Headache frequency: personal diary | 3 months |
Da Silva et al. [85] | 43 | Pregnant women aged 18–39 diagnosed with TTH | Conventional acupuncture and additional points (trigger or painful points of splenius capitis, masseters and temporalis muscles) leaving the needles for 25 min. 2 session/week. 4 weeks | No intervention | Pain intensity (morning and evening): Numerical Rating Scale | 3 months |
Berggreen et al. [86] | 38 | Women aged 18–65 diagnosed with chronic TTH |
Trigger Points treatment with frictions across or circulating in muscle fibers, ischemic compression, held from 30 to 60 s. Included muscles: trapezius (upper part), sternocleidomastoid, masseter, temporalis, medial and lateral pterygoid, anterior neck, facial, occipitofrontalis, splenius capitis and splenius cervicis, posterior cervical, and suboccipital muscles. 1 session/week. 10 weeks | No intervention | Pain intensity: Visual Analogical Scale | Pre-Post treatment |
Espí-López et al. [87] | 86 | Men and women aged 18–65 diagnosed with TTH | TG1: Suboccipital soft tissue inhibition. 4 session/week. 4 weeks TG2: Occiput-atlas-axis manipulative treatment 4 session/week. 4 weeks TG3: G1 + G2 treatments combined. 4 session/week. 4 weeks. |
Intragroup comparison | Pain Severity and headache frequency: Headache Disability Inventory |
Pre-Post treatment |
Moraska et al. [88] | 62 | Men and women aged 18–59 diagnosed with TTH | Massage: 15 min of myofascial of back, shoulders, chest, and neck; 20 min of trigger point release applied bilaterally to upper trapezius, suboccipital muscles, and both sternocleidomastoid; the final 10 min consisted of post-isometric relaxation directed at the right and left lateral cervical flexion, circular, or cross-fiber friction on the masseter, temporalis, and occipital-frontalis muscles, as well as gentle effleurage and petrissage on the neck and shoulders. 2 sessions/weeks. 6 weeks | Intragroup comparison | Pain intensity: Visual Analogical Scale. Frequency (episodes/week) Interview. Duration (hour/episode): Interview. |
Pre-Post treatment and 1 month |
Chassot et al. [89] | 34 | Women Aged 18–60 diagnosed with chronic TTH | Electroacupuncture: 16 acupuncture needles connected to an electro-stimulator for 30 min. 10 sessions. Twice/week. 5 weeks |
Placebo | Pain intensity: visual analogical scale | Post treatment |
Espí-López et al. [90] | 102 | Men and women aged 18–65 diagnosed with TTH | Occiput-atlas-axis manipulation (OAA) and soft tissue massage.1 session/week. 4 weeks | Massage 1 session/week. 4 weeks |
Pain Severity and headache frequency: Headache Disability Inventory | Pre- Post treatment and 2 months |
Ferragut-Garcías et al. [91] | 97 | Men and women aged 18–65 diagnosed with TTH | TG1: Soft tissues techniques.1 session/week.4 weeks TG2: Neural mobilization techniques 1 session/week.4 weeks TG3: Combined treatment involving soft tissue and neural mobilization techniques 1 session/week. 4 weeks |
Placebo | Pain intensity: Visual analogical scale Headache frequency: personal diary |
Post treatment and 1 month |
Georgoudis et al. [92] | 44 | Men and women aged 18–65 diagnosed with TTH | Microwaves and myofascial release combined with acupuncture. 10 sessions. | Acupuncture | Pain intensity: Visual analogical scale | Pre-Post treatment |
Pérez-Llanes et al. [93] | 25 | Men and women diagnosed with chronic TTH | Combined treatment with suboccipital muscle inhibition and interferential current. 2 sessions/week, 20 min/session. | Standard routine care (no interventions) | Intensity of pain: Numeric Rating Scale | 4 weeks |
Schiller et al. [94] | 96 | Men and women aged 18–65 diagnosed with chronic TTH | TG1: Acupuncture TG2: Medical training therapy (cardiovascular, strength-endurance, coordinative, proprioceptive, mobility and flexibility training), TG3: Combination of acupuncture and medical training. 6 weeks, 12 treatment units in decreasing frequency (3 sessions in weeks 1 and 2, 2 sessions in weeks 3 and 4, 1 session in weeks 5 and 6). |
Standard routine care (no interventions) | Pain intensity: Verbal Rating Scale Frequency of headache: personal diary (days/month) Duration of headache: personal diary (hours/month) Frequency of headache medication intake: personal diary(days/month) |
3 months 6 months |
Corum et al. [95] | 45 | Men and women aged 19–48 diagnosed with TTH | TG1: Manipulation group: High-velocity low-amplitude (HVLA) manipulation plus exercise. 2 sessions/week for 4 weeks. TG2: Myofascial release group: suboccipital inhibition plus exercise. 2 sessions/week for 4 weeks. |
Exercise intervention | Headache frequency: personal diary (days/2-week) Headache pain severity: Visual Analogical Scale |
Pre-Post- treatment and 3 months |
Gopichandran et al. [96] | 169 | Adult men and women diagnosed with chronic TTH | Progressive muscle relaxation (PMR) and deep breathing exercises. 12 weeks, 20 min,5 sessions/week, in the evening with an instruction booklet | Standard routine care (no interventions) | Pain intensity: Wong-Baker Faces Pain Scale | 4 weeks 8 weeks 12 weeks |
Runa et al. [97] | 252 | Men and women aged 18–75 diagnosed with anxiety and TTH | Warming acupuncture and moxibustion at temples combined with Deanxit (drug to improve depression and anxiety) | Warm acupuncture therapy (predominantly around the temple area) | Pain intensity: Visual Analogue Score Frequency of tension type headache: Interview Duration of tension type headache: Interview |
Pre-Post treatment |
TTH = Tension Type Headache, TG = Treatment Group.