Table 1.
Interaction type | Qualitative research method | Participants, location, timing | Main topics discussed | |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Exploration global level | Stakeholder interviews, conference workshops | 1a MSF, Brussels 1b UNICEF, SC division, Copenhagen 1 c Vaccine manufacturers 1d Donor organisations 2015–2019 |
Links between Health system development and humanitarian aid, infrastructure gap, skills retention, project handover Vaccine funding, humanitarian mechanisms, vaccine stockpiles Health systems strengthening approach UNICEF, GAVI Improvement potential at interfaces of disciplines, e.g., vaccine manufacturing & procurement conditions, temperature requirements |
2 | Mental model elicitation national immunisation system | Group model building | Senior and middle EPI staff national level. Mixed groups: Kigali 2016: 22 participants from Rwanda, Kenya, Uganda, Tanzania, South-Sudan Nairobi 2017: 25 participants from Rwanda, Kenya, Uganda, Burundi, Tanzania, South-Sudan |
Stakeholders involved in execution and decision making Mental model change from Supply Chain to systems thinking Policy making in cMYP, immunisation plan Private sector role and partnerships (logistics) Sharing views between countries, adapt approach to country Financial mechanisms, equity, sustainability, efficiency Data management and issues, denominator error Vaccine coverage and health outcomes: delays, epidemiology Implementation complexity: new vaccines, eLMIS Workforce capacity, immunisation integration in health services |
3 | Mental model elicitation district level | Interviews, observation, numerical data collection at DHs | Rwanda: 2 district hospitals (2018–2019) Kenya: 2 district hospitals (2018) |
Vaccine supply chain, vaccine wastage, ordering process Outreach planning and funding Skills and training EPI staff and Community Health Workers Diversity between HCs in the district, root causes of coverage variation Demand data availability, district coordinating role |
4 | Mental model elicitation local level | Interviews, observations, numerical data collection at HCs, outreach, CHWs |
Kenya: 5 health facilities (2018) Rwanda: 5 health facilities (2019) |
Local vaccine management organisation, vaccine transport Community health worker, defaulter tracing, disease case detection Demand-side determinants, access to HFs Impact of local problem-solving capacity at HF |
5 | Validation national level IMS model | Feedback workshops | EPI, WHO, implementers Nairobi 2018, Kigali 2019 |
Data management Public-Private health services |
6 | Validation national level IMS model | Feedback meetings | EPI, Kigali, 2019 UNICEF, Kigali, 2019 |
Financial sustainability Supply chain redesign, Digital transformation Disease surveillance, emergency immunisation (measles, Ebola) Integration with other preventive HC systems (nutrition, Primary HC) |
7 | Validation and refinement by international domain experts | Feedback meetings (2019) | 7a Academic anthropologist 7b Funding mechanism expert 7 c Academic Public Health 7d Academic systems expert |
Vaccine hesitancy, emergency immunisation Design thinking, paradigm shift, Innovation interventions Sustainable mechanisms, Local contextual approach, community health Sustainability and resilient systems, systems levels and interventions |