Skip to main content
. 2021 Oct 28;12(1):36–51. doi: 10.1080/20476965.2021.1992300

Table 3.

Examples of immunisation system leverage points classified according to Malhi et al. (2009) based on Meadows (1989).

Intervention level IMS Leverage points and potential directions of change
1. Paradigm
  • Expanding the mindset behind the IMS: from the anthropocentric ethic of preventive health as an enabler for human wellbeing, to the One Health/Planetary Health concept: Multi-stakeholder health approach (human, animal, environment) (Whitmee et al., 2015)

  • Emergence instead of centrally controlled system: Social cohesion as cornerstone of health-seeking behaviour (Ubuntu) (Barugahare, 2018)

2. Goals Complement IMS targets based on SDG3, IHRs and national immunisation targets with targets addressing
  • Vulnerable groups and geographic diversity

  • Sustainability targets beyond financial sustainability

  • Differentiation based on transdisciplinary thinking

3. System structure (across IMS loops and outside IMS) Self-Organising power
  • Country-specific IMS, adapted to local circumstances

  • Self-Organisation at subnational level: counties, districts, health centres

Rules of the system
  • Planned and emergency immunisation as one holistic system

  • Synchronisation at vaccination point: differentiation, effectiveness, efficiency

  • Community engagement, CHWs connecting immunisation demand and supply

  • National immunisation programme adequacy and funding sustainability

Information flows
  • Patient-based data, real-time vulnerability maps available to health workers

  • Patient-based health information available to population for fostering personal and community health engagement

  • Supply-related data available to relevant stakeholders

4. Feedback and delays Reinforcing feedback loops
  • Efficiency of vaccine supply loop: vaccine wastage reduction

  • Efficiency and effectiveness of workforce and infrastructure loop

  • Strength of wellbeing loop, linked to education and poverty


Balancing feedback loops
  • Outbreak prevention loop strength: ability of surveillance and response

  • Interface between national and international response to epidemics


Delays
  • Immunisation delivery options with different dynamics: RI, campaigns

  • Delays in outbreak prevention loop and outbreak response loop

  • Synchronisation of vaccine supply and distribution delays to create stability in the system

5. Structural elements (within IMS loops)
  • Vaccine Supply chain network layout

  • Size of warehouses and vaccine inventory levels

  • Workforce capacity