Skip to main content
. 2022 Dec 30;102(3):102456. doi: 10.1016/j.psj.2022.102456

Table 1.

Literature used in this meta-analysis data.

No. Article Level1 Region Ethic Clay mineral Breed Sex Age2 Weight3 Reared4
1. Abaş et al. (2011) 0–20 Turkey Zeolite Ross 308 1 47 42
2. Abbasi Pour et al. (2021) 0–15 Iran yes Sodium Bentonite Ross 11 14
3. Al-Nass et al. (2011) 0–20 Kuwait Zeolite Indian River 1 40 35
4. Alharthi et al. (2022) 0–4 Saudi Arabia yes Bentonite and Zeolite Ross 308 11 30
5. Almeida et al. (2014) 0–30 United States yes Zeolite Ross 308 Male 1 41.6 20
6. Alzueta et al. (2002) 0–20 Spain Sepiolite Cobb Male 1 39 29
7. Attar et al. (2019) 0–15 Iran yes Sodium Bentonite Ross 308 Male 11 24
8. Azar et al. (2011) 0–50 Iran Perlite Ross 308 1 42
9. Bailey et al. (2006) 0–5 United States yes Bentonite Cobb Male 1 35.4 42
10. Banaszak et al. (2022) 0–20 Poland yes Mixed of halloysite and zeolite Ross 308 1 43.5 7
11. Bolandi et al. (2021) 0–10 Iran yes Zeolite Cobb Proper Mix 1 42
12. Bouderoua et al. (2016) 0–50 Algeria yes Sodium Bentonite Hubbard Male 12 450 31
13. Cabuk et al. (2004) 0–25 Turkey Zeolite Mix 1 40 42
14. Cheng et al. (2016) 0–20 China yes Palygorskite5 Arbor Acres Proper Mix 1 40 42
15. Cheng et al. (2018) 0–10 China yes Palygorskite Arbor Acres Proper Mix 1 40.1 42
16. Curtui, (2000) 0–5 Romania Zeolite 1 28
17. Gall-David et al. (2017) 0–0.006 France yes Zeolite Ross Pm3 Male 1 21
18. Grądzki et al. (2020) 0–30 Poland yes Zeolite Ross 308 male 1 42
19. Denli et al. (2009) 0–5 Italy yes Diatomaceous Earth Ross 308 Male 1 47 42
20. Dos Anjos et al. (2015) 0–7.5 United States yes Diatomaceous Earth Ross 308 Male 1 41 21
21. Du et al. (2019) 0–10 China yes Palygorskite Arbor Acres Proper Mix 1 47.5 42
22. Dunislawska et al. (2022) 0–5 Poland yes Zeolite Ross 308 Male 1 46.6 42
23. Durna Aydin et al. (2020) 0–20 Turkey yes Glauconite Ross 308 Male 1 41.3 35
24. El-Husseiny et al. (2008) 0–5 Egypt Diatomaceous Earth Ross 308 Proper Mix 1 39.2 35
25. Ghazalah et al. (2021) 0–5 Egypt yes Bentonite Arbor Acres Male 1 35
26. Hu et al. (2013) 0–0.6 China yes Bentonite Arbor Acres Male 1 21
27. Indresh et al. (2013) 0–10 India Bentonite Vencobb Proper Mix 1 35
28. Joo et al. (2007) 0–3 Korea Bentonite Ross 208 1 42 35
29. Juzaitis-Boelter et al. (2021) 0–5 United States yes Hydrated Sodium Calcium Aluminosilicate Cobb Male 1 43 21
30. Karamanlis et al. (2008) 0–20 Greece Zeolite Cobb 500 1 39.7 42
31. Kavan et al. (2013) 0–30 Iran Zeolite Ross 308 Male 21 42
32. Khanedar et al. (2012) 0–15 Iran Calcium Bentonite and Sodium Bentonite Ross 308 Male 1 42
33. Lemos et al. (2015) 0–15 Brazil Kaolin 15 52
34. Lim et al. (2017) 0–2 Korea Silicate Cobb 1 35
35. Macháček et al. (2010) 0–40 Czech yes Zeolite Bovan 1
36. Mallek et al. (2012) 0–10 Tunis yes Zeolite Hubbard Male 1 45
37. Miazzo et al. (2005) 0–3 Argentina Sodium Bentonite Ross Male 23 50
38. Miles and Henry, (2007a) 0–20 United States Hydrated Sodium Calcium Aluminosilicate Ross Male 1 21
39. Miles and Henry, (2007b) 0–20 United States Hydrated Sodium Calcium Aluminosilicate Ross Male 1 21
40. Modirsanei et al. (2008) 0–30 Iran yes Diatomaceous Earth male 1 42.0 42
41. Nadziakiewicz et al. (2021) 0–10 Poland yes Halloysite Ross 308 Proper Mix 1 45 42
42. Nadziakiewicz et al. (2022) 0–10 Poland yes Halloysite Ross 308 Proper Mix 1 45 43
43. Neeff et al. (2013) 0–5 United States Hydrated Sodium Calcium Aluminosilicate Ross 708 male 1
44. Nikolakakis et al. (2013) 0–30 Greece Zeolite Cobb 500 1 42
45. Oguz and Kurtoglu, (2000) 0–25 Turkey Zeolite Avian 1 21
46. Ortatatli and Oğuz, (2001) 0–25 Turkey Zeolite Avian Mix 1 21
47. Ouachem and Kaboul, (2012) 0–30 Algeria Marl Isa 15 1 56
48. Ouhida et al. (2000) 0–20 Spain yes Sepiolite Male 1 22
49. Owen et al. (2012) 0–30 Nigeria Kaolin Hubbard Mix 1 60 56
50. Pappas et al. (2010) 0–10 Greece yes Palygorskite Cobb Proper Mix 1 45 42
51. Pappas et al. (2014) 0–10 Greece yes Bentonite Ross 308 1 46 42
52. Pappas et al. (2016) 0–10 Greece yes Bentonite Ross 308 1 45 42
53. Prvulović et al. (2008) 0–5 Serbia Aluminosilicate Mix 1 42
54. Qu et al. (2019) 0–10 China yes Zeolite Arbor Acres Male 1 42
55. Rana et al. (2017) 0–10 Tunis Zeolite Hubbard 1 37.6 39
56. Saçakli et al. (2015) 0–20 Turkey yes Zeolite Ross 308 Male 1 42.6 42
57. Safaeikatouli et al. (2010) 0–30 Iran Kaolin and Zeolite Ross 308 Male 1 42
58. Safaeikatouli et al. (2012) 0–30 Iran Bentonite, Kaolin, and Zeolite Ross 308 Male 1 42
59. Shannon et al. (2017) 0–5 United States yes Bentonite 1 37.4 21
60. Shi et al. (2009) 0–3 China Bentonite Avian Proper Mix 1 42
61. Suchý et al. (2006) 0–20 Czech Zeolite Ross 308 Proper Mix 1 43 40
62. Tang et al. (2014) 0–4 China yes Zeolite Arbor Acres 1 42
63. Tang et al. (2015) 0–4.8 China yes Zeolite Arbor Acres Proper Mix 1 40 21
64. Uzunoğlu and Yalçin, (2019) 0–1.5 and 0–15 Turkey yes Bentonite and Sepiolite Ross 308 Male 1 44.1 and 43.9 42
65. Wawrzyniak et al. (2017a) 0–30 Poland yes Zeolite Ross 308 1 42 40
66. Wawrzyniak et al. (2017b) 0–30 Poland yes Zeolite Ross 308 1 41 40
67. Wei et al. (2019) 0–0.5 China yes Modified Hydrated Sodium Calcium Aluminosilicate Cobb 500 male 1 54.2
68. Wu et al. (2013b) 0–20 China yes Zeolite Arbor Acres Male 1 42
69. Wu et al. (2013a) 0–20 China yes Zeolite Arbor Acres Male 1 42
70. Wu et al. (2013c) 0–20 China yes Zeolite Arbor Acres 1 21
71. Wu et al. (2015) 0–20 China yes Zeolite Arbor Acres 1 21
72. Wu et al. (2016) 0–10 China yes Zeolite Arbor Acres 1 42
73. Xia et al. (2004) 0–1.5 China yes Bentonite Avian Male 1 49
74. Xiaohan Li et al. (2017) 0–10 China yes Palygorskite Male 1 39.8 42
75. Xu et al. (2003) 0–1 China yes Bentonite Arbor Acres 1 46.2 42
76. Yalçın et al. (2017) 0–20 Turkey yes Sepiolite Ross 308 Male 1 41.2 42
77. Chen et al. (2016) 0–10 China yes Palygorskite Arbor Acres Proper Mix 1 39 42
78. Chen et al. (2016) 0–10 China yes Palygorskite Arbor Acres Proper Mix 1 39 21
79. Chen et al. (2020) 0–10 China yes Palygorskite Arbor Acres Proper Mix 1 47.3 21
80. Yan et al. (2019) 1 China yes Palygorskite Ross 308 Male 1 43.2 42
81. Yang et al. (2016) 0–1.7 China yes Palygorskite Arbor Acres Proper Mix 1 36.7 42
82. Yang et al. (2017a) 0–1.7 China yes Palygorskite Arbor Acres Proper Mix 1 36.7 21
83. Yang et al. (2017b) 0–1.7 China yes Palygorskite Arbor Acres Proper Mix 1 36.7 42
84. Zha et al. (2022) 0–2 China yes Palygorskite Ross 308 Proper Mix 1 46.3 42
85. Zhang et al. (2017) 0–20 China yes Palygorskite Arbor Acres 1 40.2 42
86. Zhou et al. (2014) 0–20 China yes Attapulgite and Zeolite Male 1 39.2 42
1

Level in mg/kg as fed.

2

Age in day.

3

Weight in gram.

4

Rearing duration of treatment in day.

5

Palygorskite known as attapulgite.