Table 1.
Author (Year) | Location | Journal | Study level | Study design | n | Number of shoulder arthroplasties | Sex, M:F | Age (years.)a | Side, L:R | Diagnosis (OA; ON; RA) | Parkinson's severity (I-V)b | Preop duration of symptoms (months)a | Shoulder replacement type | Glenoid (cemented) | Humerus (cemented) | Rotator cuff repair | Follow-up (years.)a | MINORS score |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Koch et al22 (1997) | Mayo Clinic, USA | JSES | 4 | Retrospective Case Series | 15c | 16 | 6; 9 | 66 (49 -84) | 7; 9 | 12; 3; 1 | 2 I; 6 II; 5 III; 1 IV; 1 V | 44 (4 -108) | TSA (12 Neer; 4 Cofield Implants) | 12 out of 16 | 3 out of 16 | 1 out of 16 | 5.3 (1.2-15 years) | 11 |
Kryzak et al23 (2009) | Mayo Clinic, USA | JSES | 3 | Retrospective Cohort Study | Unknown | 49 | 32; 17 | 69.7 (54 -87) | 20; 29 | Not described | NA | Not described | TSA (31 Cofield; 13 Neer; 4 Tournier; 1 Biomet | 41 out of 49 | 4 out of 49 | 3 out of 49 | 8d (years) | 11 |
Kryzak et al24 (2010) | Mayo Clinic, USA | CORR | 4 | Retrospective Case Series | 7 | 8 | 5; 2 | 72 (60-84) | 5; 2 | Fracture | 1 II; 6 III | NA | Hemiarthroplasty (6 Neer; 1 Cofield) | NA | 6 out of 7 | NA | 9.9 (years) | 12 |
Dunn et al27 (2011) | Michigan; Brigham & Women's, USA | AmJOrth | 4 | Retrospective Case Series | 3 | 3 | 0; 3 | 75 | 0; 3 | 2 Revision; 1 Fracture | NA | NA | Reverse Total Shoulder Arthroplasty | 0 out of 3 | 1 out of 3 | NA | 17 months | 5 |
Burrus et al25 (2015) | Virginia, USA | JSES | 3 | Retrospective Cohort Study | 7032 | 7032 with PD (107,178 Total incl controls) | 2874; 4158 | 445 < 65; 4586 65-79; 2000 >/= 80 | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | 16 |
Cusick et al26 (2017) | Florida, USA | Orthopedics | 4 | Retrospective Case Series | 10 | 10 | 4; 6 | 76 (63 -85) | Unknown | Unknown | Stage I and II only | Unknown | Reverse Total Shoulder Arthroplasty | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | 43 months (24-128) | 18 |
Borbas et al28 (2021) | Zurich, Switzerland | Orthopedics | 4 | Retrospective Case Series | 17 | 17 | 7; 10 | 73.9 (±9.5 years) | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | Reverse Total Shoulder Arthroplasty | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | 65 months | 18 |
Moore et al29 (2022) | Weill Cornell; Yale, USA | JSES | 3 | Retrospective Case-Control | 478 | 478 with PD (5193 Total incl controls) | 2602; 2591 | 71 (±6 years) | Unknown | OA | Unknown | Unknown | TSA | Unknown | Unknown | Unknown | 60 months | 18 |
Abbreviations: CORR, clinical orthopaedics and related research; JSES, Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery; TSA, total shoulder arthroplasty.
Values are reported as mean ± SD or mean (range).
Parkinson's Disease Severity = Hoehn and Yahr Classification of severity of Parkinson's Disease
15 patients underwent 16 shoulder arthroplasties.
43 patients.