Table 4.
Load reducing methods as defined by Mayer and Moreno19 and applied during content development.
Load reducing method | Definition | VHA affordances | Translation to website* |
---|---|---|---|
1. Off-loading | Moving some essential processing from visual channel to auditory channel. Better transfer when words are presented as narration rather than as on-screen text | The use of a VHA provides the opportunity to diversify modalities and use visual and auditory channels to deliver information | Video clips with audio and visuals, with bulleted text |
2. Segmenting | Allow time between successive bite-sized segments. Better transfer when info is presented in learner-controlled segments rather than as a continuous unit | Users have the option to access the website after talking to the VHA, allowing for learner-controlled segmenting | Segmenting of information on the website into topic-specific sections |
3. Pretraining | Provide pretraining in names and characteristics of components | The VHA introduces users to key concepts related to colorectal cancer nutrition risk factors and prevention | The website expands on the same key terms from VHA. |
4. Weeding | Eliminate interesting but extraneous material to reduce processing load | VHA only presents “need to know” content to eliminate extraneous info as determined by user feedback | Pilot data may be used to test algorithms that filter content based on user input |
5. Signaling | Provide cues for how to process, select, and organize the material. Signaling is most useful when extra information is in a presentation, as it helps learners focus on the most important content | Plans to use signaling in VHA include adding pop-up images and text to emphasize keywords and facts. Participant suggestions include pop-up text when the VHA discusses nutrition risk factors, a pop-up image of a colon, pop-up number when the statistics are presented | Visible headers signal the reading path to readers. Keywords are bolded and defined in sidebar boxes |
6. Aligning | Place printed words near corresponding parts of graphics to reduce the need for visual scanning | N/A | Placed key terms next to corresponding graphics to prevent excessive scanning |
7. Eliminating redundancy | Avoid presenting identical streams of printed and spoken words. Better transfer when words are presented as narration rather than narration and on-screen text | Did not have subtitles in the VHA prototype however, based on previous work in this area and in accordance with ADA guidelines, we plan to build and test a final version with subtitles to enhance accessibility | Website text will be run through text Lexile calculator with a target Lexile range of 740-875 |
8. Synchronizing | Present narration with animation simultaneously to minimize the need to hold representation in mind | The current VHA does not include added animations. Plans to include animations in updated prototypes will follow best practices related to synchronizing | The website will house a VHA narrated, animation of the correct stool collection method |
9. Individualizing | Typically used when synchronization is not possible to ensure users can hold mental representations | This would entail matching high-quality media design with the users' spatial learning ability if synchronizing could not be implemented | N/A |