Table 3a.
Model 1: Ordered Logit/MNL | Model 2: MNL | Model 3: MNL with Random Effects | Model 4: Ordinal GLM/G-MNL | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SP-Ordered Categorical | DCEc | SP-Ordered Categorical | DCEc | SP-Ordered Categorical | DCE | SP-Ordered Categorical | DCE | |
Health report | 2.79 [1.59, 4.00] | 8.49 [7.13, 9.85] | 2.74 [1.45, 4.04] | 8.49 [7.13, 9.85] | 2.67 [1.23, 4.10] | 8.49 [7.47, 9.50] | 2.42 [1.05, 3.79] | 7.97 [7.00, 8.93] |
Opening time: 9 am–5 pm* | 0.78 [−0.95, 2.51] | 1.98 [0.05, 3.91] | 1.12 [−0.66, 2.91] | 1.98 [0.05, 3.91] | 2.34 [0.46, 4.21] | 1.98 [0.46, 3.50] | 0.77 [0.32, 1.22] | 0.41 [−0.82, 1.94] |
Opening time: 9 am–8 pm* | 11.04 [9.15, 12.92] | 13.83 [11.59, 16.07] | 12.08 [10.15, 14.02] | 13.83 [11.59, 16.07] | 13.57 [11.33, 15.80] | 13.83 [12.05, 15.61] | 11.07 [9.42, 12.73] | 7.65 [6.40, 9.46] |
Opening time: 2 pm–8 pm* | 5.50 [3.73, 7.28] | 3.44 [1.31, 5.57] | 5.79 [4.08, 7.51] | 3.44 [1.31, 5.57] | 6.64 [4.80, 8.48] | 3.44 [2.00, 4.88] | 5.58 [4.04, 7.13] | −0.68 [−2.17, 1.15] |
Availability: Every weekday: Monday–Friday** | −6.57 [−8.75, −4.40] | −2.46 [−4.04, −0.88] | −7.48 [−9.60, −5.36] | −2.46 [−4.04, −0.88] | −7.99 [−10.45, −5.54] | −2.46 [−3.69, −1.24] | −4.63 [−6.04, −3.21] | −0.38 [−1.42, 0.58] |
Availability: 1 d every 2 mo: Monday–Friday** | −16.06 [−18.15, −13.97] | −18.31 [−20.57, −16.05] | −17.13 [−19.24, −15.02] | −18.31 [−20.57, −16.05] | −16.52 [−18.75, −14.29] | −18.31 [−19.79, −16.84] | −14.25 [−16.32, −12.18] | −15.63 [−17.24, −14.55] |
Availability: 1 d every 2 mo: Saturday or Sunday** | −28.01 [−30.39, −25.63] | −33.65 [−36.55, −30.75] | −28.92 [−31.22, −26.62] |
−33.65 [−36.55, −30.75] | −30.73 [−33.26, −28.19] | −33.65 [−35.46, −31.84] | −29.14 [−30.74, −27.55] | −32.16 [−34.17, −30.25] |
Max donations: 5*** | 13.69 [11.89, 15.49] | 11.81 [9.99, 13.63] | 12.78 [10.92, 14.64] | 11.81 [9.99, 13.63] | 7.44 [5.48, 9.39] | 11.81 [10.39, 13.23] | 18.17 [16.36, 19.99] | 10.48 [9.16, 12.03] |
Max donations: 6*** | 23.20 [21.31, 25.10] | 17.72 [15.88, 19.56] | 21.83 [19.90, 23.75] | 17.72 [15.88, 19.56] | 7.54 [5.64, 9.43] | 17.72 [16.44, 19.00] | 36.74 [33.87, 39.61] | 16.20 [14.74, 17.70] |
CI, confidence interval; DCE, discrete choice experiment; GLM, generalized linear model; G-MNL, generalized multinomial logit; MNL, multinomial logit; MRS, marginal rates of substitution; NHSBT, NHS Blood and Transfusion; SP, stated preference.
Confidence interval calculated with nonparametric bootstrap.
Reference category: *9 am–12 pm and 2 pm–5 pm; **every day: Monday to Sunday; ***4 donations per year.
Models 1 and 2 are the same for the DCE model.