Table 3.
Convenience sample of partially clustered trials | Number of reports |
---|---|
Trial type | |
Individual randomisation with post-randomisation clustering | 11 |
Group-based treatment designs | 9 |
Facilitator effect designs | 2 |
Individual randomisation within pre-existing clusters | 13 |
Re-randomisation designs | 11 |
Other designs | 2 |
Cluster randomisation of pre-existing clusters | 11 |
Balanced randomisation within pre-existing clusters | 5 |
Report type a | |
Protocol paper | 10 |
Primary results | 30 |
Trial design reporting practices | |
‘Partial clustering’ or ‘partial nesting’ used in the main description of the trial design | 7 |
Partial clustering inferred from the Methods section | 32 |
Design sub-section | 3 |
Participants/inclusion criteria sub-section | 3 |
Intervention sub-section | 7 |
Randomisation sub-section | 8 |
Otherb | 11 |
Partial clustering inferred from the results | 1 |
Protocol papers were included if a publication of the primary trial results could not be identified. The list of included reports is included in the Supplemental Material (Appendix 2).
‘Other’ includes combined sub-sections such as ‘participants and allocation’ and Methods sections without any sub-sections.