Skip to main content
. 2022 Nov 7;12(5):5420–5435. doi: 10.1002/cam4.5364

TABLE 1.

Basic features of included studies

Study name Type Number Age Dose Endpoint Study design Tumor position
1 Cyrus Emir Alavi 2017 8 A 15 67 Adductor muscle jerking RCT Lateral wall
B 15 69.2 15 ml 1% lidocaine
2 Guven Erbay 2016 9 A 49 69.2 Adductor muscle jerking Retrospectively evaluate Lateral wall
C 47 69.6 10 ml 1% lidocaine
3 Zeki Tuncel Tekgül 2013 10 A 36 65.8 Tumor recurrence Retrospectively evaluate Lateral wall
B 32 67.1 10 ml 0.25% levobupivacaine
4 Deniz Bolat 2015 11 A 35 67.7 Adductor muscle jerking RCT Lateral wall
B 35 70.1 10 ml 0.25% levobupivacaine
5 Mohammad Hatef Khorrami 2010 12 A 30 61 Leg jerking RCT Lateral wall
D 30 62 10 ml 1% lidocaine
6

Kamil DARÇIN

2012 13

A 30 61.1 Adductor muscle jerking RCT Lateral wall
B 30 60.9 10 ml 3.75% levobupivacaine
7 Deepak Sharma 2017 14 B 20 66.4 10 ml 2% lignocaine+5 ml 0.5% bupivacaine Resectability of tumor RCT Lateral wall
E 20 63.6
8 Chao Han 2019 15 F 25 65.1 10 ml 0.5% bupivacaine Adductor muscle jerking RCT Lateral wall
G 25 64.1
9 Srilata Moningi 2014 16 B 30 58.6 10 ml 0.25% bupivacaine Adductor muscle jerking RCT Lateral wall
H 30 58.6
10 Recai Dagli 2019 17 B 28 61 10 ml 0.25% bupivacaine Duration of the procedure RCT Lateral wall
H 33 58.6
11 Youn Yi Jo 2011 18 B 50 64.5 10 ml 1% lidocaine Success rate RCT Lateral wall
H 51 62.4
12 Dawood Agha mohammadi 2017 19 H 35 63.23 10 ml 1% lidocaine Success rate RCT Lateral wall
B 35 67.49
13 Yong Beom Kim 2019 20 C 31 70 10 ml 1.5% lidocaine Failure rate RCT Not mentioned
F 31 68
14 Alberto Manassero 2012 21 F 25 70 10 ml 2% lidocaine Duration of the procedure RCT Lateral wall
C 25 66.5
15 Nida Farooq Shah 2017 22 F 30 53.87 10 ml 0.5% bupivacaine Success rate RCT Lateral wall
C 30 55.57
16 Mohammadhatef Khorrami 2012 23 D 34 55.4 15 ml 2% lidocaine Leg jerking RCT Lateral wall
A 31 57.8 15 ml physiologic saline
E 47 58.4 15 ml 2% lidocaine
17 Cuneyd Sevinc 2021 24 A 30 64.3 Adductor muscle jerking Retrospectively evaluate Lateral wall
B 30 65.1 5 ml 2% prilocaine
18 Nici Markus Dreger 2021 25 A 58 71.8 Adductor muscle jerking Retrospectively evaluate Lateral wall
E 36 70.9 10–20 ml 2% lidocaine
19 Omer Gokhan Doluoglu 2021 26 A 53 64.3 Tumor recurrence RCT Lateral wall
C 51 64.6 10 ml 1% lidocaine
20 Gamal E. Abourjila 2020 27 A 39 61.3 Adductor muscle jerking RCT Lateral wall
C 35 65.2 10 ml 1% lidocaine
21 Dr.S. Narmatha Yangtse 2020 28 F 30 54.7 10 ml 0.5% bupivacaine Success rate RCT Lateral wall
C 30 53.6
22 Brijesh Tiwari 2022 29 C 25 65 10 ml 1.5% lidocaine Success rate RCT Not mentioned
F 25 67
23 Houman Teymourian1 2018 30 B 62 63.21 10 ml 1.5% lidocaine Adductor muscle jerking RCT Not mentioned
G 62 62.11
24 Ozan Horsanali 2021 31 A 55 66.02 Tumor recurrence Retrospectively evaluate Lateral wall
C 51 63.29 10 ml 2% lidocaine

Abbreviation: RCT, randomized controlled trial.