Table 2.
Comparison between the cells and EVs regarding their intrinsic and application properties.
| Properties | Cells | Extracellular vesicles | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Intrinsic | Nature | - Natural, bilayer membranes with heterogeneous & cell-dependent distribution of glycolipids and glycoproteins | - Natural or synthetic, biomimetic (235), bilayer membranes |
| Morphology | - Highly heterogeneous | - Heterogeneous | |
| Physicochemical | - Large | - Small, higher resistance to low temperatures (185) | |
| Prone to change | - Responsive to the environment (185, 186) | - Non-responsive to the environment (185) | |
| Proliferation | - Proliferative/self-replicative (185) | - Non-proliferative (185) | |
| Functional | - Self-renewal and differentiation capacity (in vitro) (236) - Secrete active compounds, can initiate tumorigenesis (237) - Senescence may induce thrombosis by obstruction of small blood vessels (237) |
- Mediators of intercellular signaling/communication (238–240) - Paracrine and autocrine actions on stemness maintenance or cell differentiation (241) - Exhibit producer cell-dependent phenotypes (242–244) - EVs’ cargo can be drastically altered by culture conditions (243, 245) - EVs can mediate tumor initiation, progression, angiogenesis, and metastasis (235, 246) - EVs play role as disease biomarkers (239, 247, 248) - EVs demonstrate an age-related content (249) - MSC-EVs have prothrombotic effects (237) |
|
| Administration | Size | - Because of their size (10 µm), they can obstruct capillaries | - Pass through capillaries and BBB, and spinal cord barriers (250–253) |
| Dosage | - Their potential for proliferation can limit the dose of administration | - They can have a wide range of administered doses | |
| Route | - Intravenous, intrathecal, intraventricular, subarachnoid, intra-arterial, intraperitoneal | - Intranasal, intravenous, intraperitoneal, intracranial, intracochlear, inhalation, oral, subcutaneous (141, 253–255) | |
| In the body | Immunogenicity | - Low risk of immune rejection | - Lower risk of immune rejection (185, 187) - EVs are involved in antigen presentation (256) - Pathogenic EVs contain autoantigens (241) - Regulate the migration, proliferation, activation, and polarization of various immune cells (257, 258) - Promote a tolerogenic immune response (259, 260) - Inhibiting inflammatory response (259, 260) - Stimulate or suppress anti-cancer immunity |
| Circulation time | - Short circulation life | - Longer circulation life (137, 261) | |
| Target cell selection | - Homing capability to some target sites, such as ischemic tissues | - Innate tropism to specific sites, which can also be engineered (76) - Exhibit cell-targeting properties (111) |
|
| Long term effects | - Limited proliferation potential | - Not clear yet | |
| Tracking strategies | - X-ray–based methods (plain films and computed tomography (CT), optical imaging (bioluminescence and fluorescence), ultrasound/echocardiography, single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT), positron emission tomography (PET), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) (262) - Single-cell Tracking of cells (175) |
- Membrane labelling, vesicle interior labelling, labelling EV-specific cargoes (1, 69) | |
| Manufacturing | Isolation | - Relatively simple isolation and characterization methods | - More complicated isolation steps (263) |
| Storage | - Not possible to store them at room temperature, reduced viability after freeze and thaw | - Long-term preservation and storage stability (241) | |
| Off the shelf | - Not an off-the-shelf product | - Potent to be stored as lyophilized material (112) - Easier scale-up (185, 264, 265) |
|
| Biopharmaceutical | - Biocompatible (137) - Biodistribution preference to lungs, liver, and kidneys (137) - Suitable for multi-drug delivery (137) |
- Biocompatible (181) - Biodistribution preference to the liver, administration route-dependent biodistribution (266) - Untargeted accumulation in tumor tissues (137) - Intelligent Nano-carriers (267) - Multifunctional drug delivery systems (266) |
|
| Manipulation | Loading methods | - Various drug encapsulation methods (137, 268) | - Suitable manipulative platform (269) - Various exogenous and endogenous loading (205, 270) methods (235, 271, 272) |
| Regulations |
Regulatory bodies
and international communities |
- FDA (Food and Drug Administration) - ISCT (International Society for Cell and Gene Therapy) - ISBT (International Society of Blood Transfusion) - ISSCR (International Society for Stem Cell Research) |
- FDA (Food and Drug Administration) - ISCT (International Society for Cell and Gene Therapy) - ISEV (International Society for Extracellular Vesicles) - ISBT (International Society of Blood Transfusion) |
| GMP standards and guidelines | - Well-defined GMP standards | - Lacking good manufacturing standards (137, 142) - Guidelines for novel EV-based therapeutics (111) |
|