Skip to main content
. 2023 Mar 23;18(3):e0283375. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0283375

Table 2. Descriptions of acupuncture interventions.

Study ID Acupuncture stimulation method Needle type Acupuncture point Retention time Treatment regimen Practitioner background
Yao 2015 [15] MA NR BL1,EX-HN7,GB1, LR3,ST1,shangming, jianming NR 1 session every 2 days for 21 days NR
Yang 2019 [16] MA NR BL2,BL23,EX-HN5,EX-HN7,L14,L20,SP6, ST36 30min 1 session every day for 3 months NR
Wang 2019 [17] MA NR BL1,EX-HN5,GB1, GB37, K16, L14, LI11,ST36,ST40 30min 2 sessions a week for 2 months NR
liu 2016 [18] MA 0.25×25 mm BL1,BL2, EX-HN1, GB1 30min 1 session every day for 30 days NR
Xia 2014 [25] MA 0.25×(40–50) mm BL1,BL2, EX-HN5, EX-HN14,GB20,ST1 / 2 session a week for 2 months NR
Wang 2017 [26] MA 0.25×25 mm BL1,BL2,BL24,BL26,CV9,DU20,EX-HN4,EX-HN5,EX-HN7,GB14,GB37,K13, LR3, SP6, SP10, ST1,ST36,ST40, shangming 30min 1 session every day for 30 days NR
Qin 2020 [27] MA NR BL10,EX-HN5,GB20,SJ23,ST1,xinming 20min 1 session every day for 20 days NR
Xia 2013 [28] MA 0.25×(40/50) mm BL1,EX-HN7, GB1, LR3, ST1 30min 2 sessions a week for 2 months NR
Jiao 2011 [29] MA 0.25×(25–50) mm BL1,BL2,BL18,BL20,BL23,EX-HN5,GB1,GB14,GB20,GB37, ST2, ST40 30min 1 session every day for 50 days NR

MA, manual acupuncture; NR, not reported.