Skip to main content
. 2023 Mar 23;18(3):e0283375. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0283375

Table 3. Subgroup analysis.

Subgroup analysis No. of trials (reference nos.) No. of patients I2 RR [95% CI] P value
Clinical efficacy rates Overall 7 (15–18,24,25,27) 492 0 1.29 [1.17, 1.42] <0.0001
Type of intervention
Including TCM 5 (15–17,24,25) 362 0 1.22 [1.11, 1.35] <0.0001
Without TCM 2 (18,27) 130 0 1.56 [1.17, 2.07] 0.002
Intervention course
20–50 days 5 (15,18,24,25,27) 331 0 1.33 [1.17, 1.52] <0.0001
51–90 days 2 (16,17) 161 21 1.21 [1.06, 1.39] 0.006
AMD type
Dry AMD 2 (24,25) 132 0 1.22 [1.05, 1.42] 0.01
Wet AMD 3 (15,16,18) 196 18 1.26 [1.06, 1.50] 0.01
Dry and wet AMD 2(17,27) 164 0 1.39 [1.16, 1.65] 0.0002
Subgroup analysis No. of trials (reference nos.) No. of patients I 2 SMD [95% CI] P value
BCVA Overall 5 (16–18,23,25) 335 89% 0.95 [0.26,1.64] 0.007
Type of intervention
Including TCM 3 (16,17,25) 221 56% 0.76 [0.34, 1.18] 0.0004
Without TCM 2 (18,23) 114 96% 1.23 [-1.00, 3.46] 0.28
Intervention course
20–50 days 2 (18,25) 100 65% 0.47 [-0.22, 1.16] 0.18
50–90 days 3 (16,17,23) 235 93% 1.28 [0.21, 2.34] 0.02
AMD type
Dry AMD 2 (23,25) 134 93 1.58 [0.04, 3.11] 0.04
Wet AMD 2 (16,18) 127 0 0.31 [-0.04, 0.66] 0.09
Dry and wet AMD 1 (17) 74 NA 1.11 [0.62, 1.60] <0.0001
Subgroup analysis No. of trials (reference nos.) No. of patients I 2 MD [95% CI] P value
CMT Overall 3(16–18) 201 67% -32.74 [-60.94, -4.55] 0.02
Type of intervention
Including TCM 2 (16,17) 161 83% -31.69 [-71.37, 7.99] 0.12
Without TCM 1 (18) 40 NA -32.60 [-77.59, 12.39] 0.16
Intervention course
20–50 days 1 (18) 40 NA -32.60 [-77.59, 12.39] 0.16
51–90 days 2 (16,17) 161 83% -31.69 [-71.37, 7.99] 0.12
AMD type
Wet AMD 2 (16,18) 127 0 -16.21 [-40.80, 8.39] 0.2
Dry and wet AMD 1 (17) 74 NA -49.93 [-64.13, -35.73] <0.0001

NA, not applicable.