Skip to main content
. 2023 Mar 23;18(3):e0283309. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0283309

Table 2. Participant and study characteristics, and physiological adaptations and main findings.

Article, year Country Participants characteristics (mean±SD age, activity level, % women) Sample size), Duration of intervention Exercise(s) BFRT group exercise parameters Control group exercise parameters Progression for BFRT group Progression for Control group Main findings in physiological adaptations in strength and muscle size
Bowman et al., 2020 USA total age:26.2±3.4
Trained young adults
58% women
BFR-RT, n = 14
LL-RT, n = 10
2 sessions per week for6 weeks External rotation
Internal rotation
Biceps curl
Triceps extension
Prone horizontal abduction
4 sets
30/15/15/15 repetitions
30 secs between-set rest
30% 1RM
60% LOP (Delfi system©)
Same training parameters without BFR Weight was
increased as needed to accomplish 7–8 RPE
Weight was
increased as needed to accomplish 7–8 RPE
↑30%, 23%, 22%, and 13% in scaption, flexion, abduction, and grip strength in favour of the BFRT group, respectively
↑arm and forearm circumferences in favour of the BFRT group (p<0.01)
Brumitt et al., 2020 USA total age:25.0±2.2
53% reported resistance training for the shoulders more than once per week
43.5% women
BFR-RT, n = 24
LL-RT, n = 22
2 sessions per week for
8 weeks
External rotation 4 sets
30/15/15/15 repetitions
30 secs between-set rest
30% 1RM
50% LOP (Delfi system©)
Same training parameters without BFR NA NA Significant within-group supraspinatus and external rotators strength gains for both BFR and LL-RT group (p<0.001)
No between-group differences in supraspinatus (p = 0.750) and external rotator strength (p = 0.708) and supraspinatus tendon thickness (p = 0.610)
Green et al., 2020 USA range 20–29 years
Trained young adults
0% women
BFR-RT, n = 6
HL-RT, n = 5
2 sessions per week for4 weeks Bench press
Scapular retraction
External rotation
Bent over row
4 sets
30/15/15/15 repetitions
Each exercise was performed within 7 min
1 minute rest between-exercise
20% 1RM
50% LOP (Delfi system©)
Same exercises without BFR
3 sets
10/10/10 repetitions
70% 1RM
NA NA No between-group significant strength differences (p>0.05)
↑within-BFRT strength for pectoralis major, lower trapezius, and 1RM for prone rows (p<0.05)
↑within-control group strength for pectoralis major, lower trapezius, external rotators, and 1RM for scapula retraction (p<0.05)
Lambert et al., 2021 USA BFRT age:27.6±4.3
Control age:25.8±4.1
Untrained young adults
28% women
BFR-RT, n = 16
LL-RT, n = 16
2 sessions per week for8 weeks Internal rotation
External rotation
Side lying external rotation
Scaption
4 sets
30/15/15/fatigue repetitions
30 secs between-set rest
2 minutes rest between-exercise
20% of isometric max
50% LOP (Delfi system©)
Same training parameters without BFR 1 lb per week per exercise if 75 reps achieved for both weekly sessions 1 lb per week per exercise if 75 reps achieved for both weekly sessions ↑shoulder region lean mass in the arm in favour of the BFRT group (p<0.05)
↑isometric strength (p<0.001) and strength endurance (p<0.01) for IR at 0° of ABD in favour of the BFRT group
Salyers, 2017 USA total age:22.1±1.5
Trained young adults
0% women
BFR-RT, n = 4
HL-RT, n = 4
3 sessions per week
for 4 weeks
Bench press 4 sets
30/15/15/15 repetitions
45 secs between-set rest
20% 1RM
LOP: RPE 7/10 with elastic band
Same exercises without BFR
3 sets
15/15/15 repetitions
90 secs between-set rest
Started with 65% 1RM
Weekly increased over 4 weeks
20% 1RM
25% 1RM
30% 1RM
32.5% 1RM
Weekly modified over 4 weeks
65% 1RM/15 repetitions
75% 1RM/10 repetitions
80% 1RM/8 repetitions
85% 1RM/6 repetitions
No significant between-group differences in body composition and strength measurements (p<0.05)
Thiebaud et al., 2013 USA BFRT age:59.0±2.0
Control age:62.0±2.0
Untrained older adults
100% women
BFR-RT, n = 6
HL-RT, n = 8
3 sessions per week for 8 weeks Chest press
Seated row
Seated shoulder press
3 sets
30/15/15 repetitions
30 secs between-set rest
30 secs to 2 minutes between-exercise rest
10–30% 1RM based on 7–9 RPE on OMNI-RES AM scale
80-120mmHg LOP
(KAATSU-Master device©)
3 sets 10/10/10 repetitions
2 min between-set rest
30 secs to 2 minutes between-exercise rest
70–90%1RM based on 7–9 RPE on OMNI-RES AM scale
Weekly increased LOP over 4 weeks
80mmHg
90mmHg
100mmHg
110-120mmHg
Exercise modified to reach a 7–9 RPE on OMNI-RES AM scale ↑within-group strength increases in chest press, seated row, shoulder press (p<0.05) and pectoralis major thickness in both groups (p<0.05)
No between-group differences in lean body mass, strength, and muscle thickness (p>0.05)
Yamanaka et al., 2012 USA total age 19.2±1.8,
Trained young adults
0% women
BFR-RT, n = 16
LL-RT, n = 16
3 sessions per week for4 weeks Bench press 4 sets
30/20/20/20 repetitions
45 secs between-set rest
20% 1RM
LOP restricted by elastic band (pulled to overlap 2 inches)
Same training parameters without BFR NA NA ↑within-group strength and girth measures for both groups (p<0.05)
↑bench press 1RM (7% within-group), upper and lower chest girths (within-group 3% and 3%, respectively), and left upper arm girth in favour of the BFRT group (p<0.05)
Yasuda et al., 2010 Japan BFRT age:25.8±6.3
Control age:25.6±3.2
Trained young adults (no resistance training for a year)
0% women
BFR-RT, n = 5
LL-RT, n = 5
6 sessions per week for2 weeks Bench press 4 sets
30/15/15/15 repetitions
30 secs between-set rest
30% 1RM
LOP using an elastic band: The training air pressure started at 100mmHG
Same training parameters without BFR Training pressure started at 100mmHG and was increased by 10 mmHg each day until 160 mmHg (Day 7) NA Significant increase in triceps brachii (8%) and pectoralis major muscle (16%) thickness in favour of the BFRT group (p<0.05) compared to the non-BFRT group Significant increase (p<0.05) in
1-RM bench press strength (6%) in favour of the BFR-T (6%) group compared to the non-BFRT group
Yasuda et al., 2011 Japan HI-RT age:25.3±2.9
BFRTL age:23.4±1.3
BFRTC age:23.8±2.1
Control age:23.6±1.6
Trained young adults (no resistance training for 6 months)
0% women
HI-RT, n = 10
BFRTL, n = 10
BFRTC, n = 10
Control, n = 10
3 sessions per week for8 weeks Bench press 4 sets
30/15/15/15 repetitions
30 secs between-set rest
30% 1RM
LOP elastic band: The training air pressure started at 100mmHG and was increased by 10 mmHg each day until 160 mmHg (Day 7)
HI-RT:
3 sets
10/10/10 repetitions
2–3 minutes between-set rest
75% 1RM
BFRTC: performed
BFRTL twice a week and
HI-RT once a week
1-RM was assessed after 3 weeks to adjust the training load for BFRTH. Training load was constant for BFRTL NA Similar increases in bench press 1-RM in the HI-RT (19.9%) and BFRTC (15.3%) groups and lower in the BFRTL group (8.7%, p<0.05)
↑11.3% and 6.6% in maximal isometric elbow extension for BFRTH and BFRTC, respectively
↑8.6%, 7.2%, and 4.4% in the cross-sectional area of the triceps brachii for HI-RT, BFRTC, and BFRTL, respectively
Significant change in relative isometric strength (3.3%) in favour of HI-RT (p<0.05) compared to BFRTL (-3.5%) and control (-0.1%) groups

Abbreviations: ABD, abduction; BFRT, blood flow restriction training; C, combined high intensity resistance training and low BFRT; HI-RT, high intensity resistance training; IR, internal rotation; L, low; LOP, limb occlusion pressure; NA, not applicable; OMNI-RES AM, OMNI Resistance for active muscle scale; RM, repetition maximum; RPE, rating of perceived exertion; SD, standard deviation; secs, seconds.