Skip to main content
. 2023 Feb 21;198(3):573–582. doi: 10.1007/s10549-023-06872-9

Table 5.

Review of the literature regarding oestrogen receptor concordance

No of samples Concordance (%) IHC clone
Badoual, 2005 [25] 103 90.3 1D5, Immunotech
Burge, 2006 [26] 87 95 SF11, Biocare Medical
Hodi, 2007* [27] 338 98.8 1D5, Dako
Wood, 2007 [28] 100 95.8 ID11, Dako
Arnedos, 2009 [29] 336 98.2 SP1, Ventana
Tamaki, 2010 [30] 353 94.9 SF11, Ventana
Uy, 2010§ [31] 160 81.9 1D5, Dako
Lorgis, 2011° [32] 175 84 6F11, Novocastra
Ough, 2011 [33] 209 88 Not reported
Li, 2012# [34] 2450 92.8
Seferina, 2012° [35] 526 89.5 1D5, Dako
Dekker, 2013 [36] 122 99.1 1D5, Dako
Greer, 2013 [37] 205 89

6F11, Leica

1D5, Dako

Munch-Petersen, 2013 [38] 89 98 SP1, Dako
Motamedolshariati, 2014 [39] 30 96.7 Not reported
Chen, 2017 [40] 996 78.8 SP1, Ventana
Ensani, 2017 [41] 100 90 1D5, Biogenex
Kombak, 2017 [42] 284 93.3 6F11, Leica
Meattini, 2017° [43] 101 94.1 SF11, Ventana
You, 2017§ [44] 1219 97.1 SF11, Novocastra
Berghuis, 2019 [45] 684 95.5 Multiple
Jeong, 2020§ [46] 623 96.5 SP1, Ventana
Shanmugalingam, 2022 [47] 484 96.7 SP1, Ventana
Slostad, 2022 [48] 961 90.8 LDT

*McCarty’s h scoring system, #meta-analysis, ° positivity threshold: 10%, § Allred score, IHC, immunohistochemistry, LDT, laboratory-developed test.