Table 2.
Summary of studies characteristics and findings on the barriers to physical activity.
| Study | Study Design | Settings | Sample Size | Mean Age of Participants | Key Findings. | Barrier themes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baruth et al.42 | Case-control study | Columbia, South Carolina | 28 | 20–50 years | Injuries and health conditions; Issues related to body size; Competing demands on their time and lack of energy Lack of motivation; Unavailability of exercise partners; Rude and disrespectful comments by people. Lack of access to facilities; High cost of a gym membership. |
Intrapersonal barriers Social barriers Socio-economic barriers |
| Carr et al.43 | Randomized controlled trial | North Carolina | 234 | 50 years and above | Lack of willpower; General sense of role overwhelm; Haircare and maintenance. Cost; Lack of exercise resources. |
Intrapersonal barriers. Socio-economic barriers |
| Mama et al.44 | Case-control | Harris, Houston and Travis Country, Austin, Texas | 164 | 25–60 years | Body composition and body image; Motivational readiness for weight loss Environmental changes. |
Intrapersonal barriers. Environmental barriers |
| Huebschmann et al.45 | Cross-sectional study | Metropolitan Denver area | 51 | 19–73 years | Sweating out my hairstyle; Drying effects on hairstyle; Lack of self-discipline; I am too exhausted at the end of the day Lack of money; Lack of equipment. |
Intrapersonal barriers. Socio-economic barriers. |
| Joseph et al.46 | Case-control | Phoenix, Arizona | 23 | 24–49 years | Perspiration while performing Physical Activity; Maintaining a work-appropriate and socially acceptable hairstyle that is convenient for physical activity; Social comparison to women of other races/ethnicities. | Intrapersonal and Social barriers. |
| Adamus-Leach et al.47 | Cross-sectional study | Houston and Austin, Texas | 388 | 20–65 years | Individual Income status Perception of neighborhood environment |
Socio-economic barrier Environmental barrier |
| Hall et al.48 | Cross-sectional survey study | Winston-Salem, North Carolina | 103 | 21–60 years | Hair concerns and maintenance | Intrapersonal barriers. |
| Gaston et al.49 | Cross-sectional study | Detroit, Michigan | 1 558 | 23–35 years | Hair product use/maintenance | Intrapersonal barriers. |
| Robinson & Wicks50 | Cross-sectional study | Alabama | 19 | 21–60 years | Type of employment and h worked. Religiosity. |
Intrapersonal barriers. Social barrier. |
| Scott et al.51 | Observational study: Use of self-administered questionnaires | Not stated | 113 | Middle-aged. Mean age: 51.3 years | Not enough time; No knowledge of exercise techniques. No one to exercise with me. Lack of access to a gym and childcare Unsafe environment. |
Intrapersonal barriers. Social barrier. Environmental barrier. |
| Gothe & Kendall52 | Qualitative research (with 3 Focus groups) | Detroit metro area and surrounding urban communities | 20 | Between 55 and 75 years, mean age: age = (63.15 ± 4.5) years | Time; physical health and age-related limitations Peer pressure and family responsibilities Weather and poor neighborhood condition |
Intrapersonal barriers Social barriers. Environmental barriers |
| James et al.53 | Cross-sectional survey study | North-central Florida, USA | 413 | Mean age: (35.63 ± 14.72) years | Busy lifestyle and not having enough time; Too much hair care Expensive gym membership; No one to exercise with; Living in an unsafe neighborhood |
Intrapersonal barrier. Socio-economic; Social and Environmental barriers. |
| Ingram et al.31 | Qualitative exploratory design with focus group methodology (4 focus groups) | Chicago | 33 | 44–69 years. Mean age: 54 years | Family and work responsibilities; Musculoskeletal problems and weight issues associated with walking. Lack of role models within the community. Weather; Neighborhood safety. |
Intrapersonal barrier. Social barrier Environmental barrier. |
| Jackson et al.54 | Cross-sectional descriptive study | North Omaha | 47 | 19 years and above | Obesity; Fatigue; Haircare concern; Family and friends; Lack of time. Social support for physical activity. |
Intrapersonal barrier. Social barrier. |
| Zenk et al.55 | Correlational, observational research design | Metropolitan Chicago | 97 | 25–64 years | Affect (feelings). Poor weather. |
Intrapersonal barrier. Environmental barrier. |
| Schoeny et al.56 | Randomized controlled trial | Chicago, Illinois area | 284 | 40–65 years | Physical and psychological health; Pain; BMI; Perceived walkability; Children in the household; Employment. Neighborhood characteristics (Assault/battery rate). |
Intrapersonal barrier. Environmental barrier. |
| Tenfelde et al.57 | Qualitative Research (Focus group) study | The urban Midwest, Chicago, USA | 22 | 18 years and above | Access to Yoga classes within the community; Location of classes; Quality of instruction. The high cost of yoga classes |
Intrapersonal barrier Socio-economic barrier. |
| Kinsman et al.58 | Qualitative focus group study | Agincourt sub-district of rural Mpumalanga province, north-eastern South Africa, |
51 | 13–19 years | Body image ideals. Poverty and associated social stigma; Gender bias in accessing facilities and competitions; Parental interference due to social violence. |
Intrapersonal barrier. Social and Socio-economic barriers. |
| Alvarado et al.59 | Population-based cross-sectional study | Barbados | 17 | 25–35 years | Laidback mentality; Lack of opportunity to walk to jobs, grocery stores, etc. due to a distant residential area. Gender norms; Limited indoor space for home exercise; Limited access to group/gym exercise |
Intrapersonal barrier. Social barriers. |
| Walker.60 | Qualitative Research Design (using grounded theory approach) | Las Vegas, US | 12 (6 mothers, 6 daughters) | Women 42–50 years; Girls 12–17 years | Body image perception; Lack of interest, knowledge, time, and transportation Lack of physical activity history/ motivation; peer pressure; Fear of sexual stereotypes; Racial stereotypes and sports Weather. |
Intrapersonal barriers Social barriers Environmental barrier |