Skip to main content
. 2023 Mar 15;9(3):230. doi: 10.3390/gels9030230

Table 1.

Advantages and disadvantages of physical and chemical cross-linking.

Cross-Linking Advantages Disadvantages
Physical Self-assembly Reversible mechanism [A] [52]
Compatibility with biological systems [B] [3]
Shear-thinning [2]
Self-healing [2]
Additional post-cross-linking [C] [42]
Poor mechanical properties [D] [52]
Prolonged self-healing [2]
Ionic interactions [A,B] [3,52]
Working under mild conditions [89]
[C,D] [42,52]
Exhaustive of the number of ions [42]
Thermal cross-linking [A,B] [3,52]
Rapid reassembly to hydrogel [2]
Work under physiological conditions [89]
[C] [42]
Precise temperature for cell viability [2]
Stereo-complexation [A,B] [3,52] [C,D] [42,52]
Chemical Photo-induced Stabilization of weak cross-linked hydrogels [3,6]
Fast gelation [6]
Spatiotemporal control of the reaction [42]
Room temperature conditions [42]
Light irradiation may affect cells [3]
Precise determination of photo-initiator, intensity light and exposure time [3,42]
Click chemistry
Diels-Alder
SP-AAC
Thiol-ene
Oxime
Thiol-Michael
Aldehyde-hydrazide
Fast gelation (all mechanisms) [90]
Mild conditions (all mechanisms) [2,90]
Spontaneous reaction (all mechanisms) [90,91]
Good mechanical properties (all mechanisms) [90]
Not sensitive to oxygen or water (Thiol-ene) [90]
Long gelation without initiator (Diels-Alder) [92]
Numerous steps for the cyclooctyne’s synthesize (SP-AAC) [90]
Use of an initiator (Thiol-ene) [90]
Basic pH could damage cells (Oxime) [93]
Enzymatic No exogenous reagents [3]
Spontaneous reaction [79]
Control over the reaction [79]
Specificity [52]
Fast gelation [89]
Mild conditions [42,52]
Needs additional catalyst (enzyme): the activity can change during the storage of the stock solution [3]
The costs of the enzyme are additional costs [52]