Table A1.
Study | Randomization Process | Deviation from Intended Interventions | Missing Outcome Data | Measurement of Outcome | Selection of Reported Result | Overall |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kokudo et al., 2021 [34] |
1.2 Y, 1.1 Y, 1.3 N
LR |
Part1: 2.1/2.2 Y, 2.3 PY, 2.4 PN
SC Part2: 2.6Y LR |
3.1 Y
LR |
4.1 N, 4.2 N, 4.3 Y, 4.4 PN
LR |
5.2/5.3 N 5.1 Y
LR |
SC |
Kanemitsu et al., 2021 [33] |
1.2 Y, 1.1 Y/PY, 1.3 N/PN
LR |
Part1: 2.1/2.2 Y, 2.3 PY, 2.4 PN
SC Part2: 2.6Y LR |
3.1 Y
LR |
4.1 N, 4.2 N, 4.3 Y, 4.4 PN
LR |
5.2/5.3 N 5.1 Y
LR |
SC |
Kemeny et al., 2011 [43] |
1.2 NI, 1.3 PN
SC |
Part1: 2.1/2.2 NI, 2.3 N
LR Part2: 2.6 Y LR |
3.1 Y
LR |
4.1 N, 4.2 N, 4.3 Y, 4.4 PN
LR |
5.2/5.3 N 5.1 Y
LR |
SC |
Ychou et al., 2009 [46] |
1.2 NI, 1.3 PN
SC |
Part1
: 2.1/2.2 Y, 2.3 PY, 2.4 PN
SC Part2: 2.6N, 2.7 PN SC |
3.1 Y
LR |
4.1 N, 4.2 N, 4.3 Y, 4.4 PN
LR |
5.2/5.3 N 5.1 Y
LR |
HR |
Portier et al., 2006 [48] |
1.2 NI, 1.3 PN
SC |
Part1: 2.1/2.2 Y, 2.3 PY, 2.4 PN
SC Part2: 2.6Y LR |
3.1 Y
LR |
4.1 PY
HR |
5.2/5.3 N 5.1 Y
LR |
HR |
Kemeny et al., 2002 [56] |
1.2 NI, 1.3 PN
SC |
Part1: 2.1/2.2 Y, 2.3 Y, 2.4 PN
SC Part2: 2.6 N, 2.7 PY HR |
3.1 Y
LR |
4.1 NI, 4.2 N, 4.3 Y, 4.4 PN
LR |
5.2/5.3 N 5.1 Y
LR |
HR |
Tono et al., 2000 [57] |
1.2 Y, 1.1 Y, 1.3 N
LR |
Part1
: 2.1/2.2 Y, 2.3 N
LR Part2: 2.6 PY LR |
3.1 Y
LR |
4.1 N, 4.2 N, 4.3 Y, 4.4 PN
LR |
5.2/5.3 N 5.1 Y
LR |
LR |
Kemeny et al., 1999 [58] |
1.2 NI, 1.3 PN
SC |
Part1: 2.1/2.2 Y, 2.3 Y, 2.4 NI, 2.5 NI HR
Part2: 2.6 Y, 2.7 PY HR |
3.1 Y
LR |
4.1 N, 4.2 N, 4.3 Y, 4.4 PN
LR |
5.2/5.3 N 5.1 Y
LR |
HR |
Rudroff et al., 1998 [59] ¹ |
1.2 NI, 1.3 PN
SC |
Part1: 2.1/2.2 Y, 2.3 PN
LR Part2: 2.6 PY LR |
3.1 Y
LR |
4.1 NI, 4.2 Y
HR |
5.2/5.3 N 5.1 Y
LR |
HR |
Lorenz et al., 1998 [60] |
1.2 Y, 1.1 NI, 1.3 PN
LR |
Part1: 2.1/2.2 Y, 2.3 PY, 2.4 PN
SC Part2 : 2.6Y LR |
3.1 Y
LR |
4.1 N, 4.2 N, 4.3 Y, 4.4 PN
LR |
5.2/5.3 N 5.1 Y
LR |
SC |
Abbreviations: LR: low risk; SC: some concern; HR: high risk. 1 The risk of bias assessment for this study focuses only on the comparison between groups A and B.