Table 3.
Diagnostic Test | Comments for CAPA Patients | Advantages | Disadvantages |
---|---|---|---|
Lung biopsy | Post-mortem CT-guided biopsies have been used as an alternative to necropsy | Provides definitive CAPA/IAPA diagnosis | High risk of complications |
BAL with FBC | In the first wave, practically dismissed due to risk to health personnel. Rarely used during the first wave due to risk to health personnel. | Visualization of trachea and bronchi BAL GM, LFD, and PCR Directed sample |
Aerosol generation Potentially poor tolerance in some patients |
Not bronchoscopic lavage Non-bronchoscopic lavage | Proposed as an alternative to BAL | Obtains sample from lower respiratory tract. Validated technique for VAP Closed technique |
Not well validated for CAPA/IAPA Not well validated for GM/PCR Blind sample |
Tracheal aspirate | Colonization in patients with COVID-19? | Easy to perform in MV patients | Sample is less representative of the lower respiratory tract Not validated for biomarkers |
Sputum | Colonization in patients with COVID-19? | Easy to perform on all patients | Sample is less representative of the lower respiratory tract Not validated for biomarkers |
Serum | Frequently negative in CAPA | Allows GM, LFD, 1-3-β-D-glucan, and PCR Easily obtained | 1-3-β-D-glucan results not specific |
BAL, bronchoalveolar lavage; GM, galactomannan; LFD, lateral flow device test; VAP, ventilator-associated pneumonia; MV, mechanical ventilation; PCR, polymerase chain reaction.