Skip to main content
. 2023 Mar 30;6(3):e235755. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.5755

Table 2. VE of 3-Dose Inactivated Vaccine vs 2-Dose Vaccine.

Characteristic Close contacts, No. (%) VE (95% CrI)
Individuals spreading infection with 2 doses [reference] Individuals spreading infection with 3 doses Crude Adjusteda
Contact tested positive Contact tested negative Contact tested positive Contact tested negative
Overall 94 (1.4) 6536 (98.6) 321 (0.8) 40 360 (99.2) 44.7 (30.3 to 56.1) 28.9 (7.7 to 45.2)
Sex of individual spreading infection
Male 54 (1.6) 3666 (98.4) 138 (1.0) 13 439 (99.0) 30.3 (4.3 to 49.2) 28.4 (−4.9 to 51.3)
Female 40 (1.4) 2870 (98.6) 183 (0.7) 26 921 (99.3) 51.2 (31.2 to 65.4) 18.4 (−15.9 to 44.1)
Age of individual spreading infection, y
0-15 54 (2.5) 2077 (97.5) 0 0 NAb NAb
16-65 31 (0.8) 3988 (99.2) 302 (0.8) 39 716 (99.2) 2.2 (−29.3 to 67.5) 3.3 (−32.9 to 29.8)
>65 9 (1.9) 471 (98.1) 19 (2.9) 644 (97.1) −35.2 (−70.9 to 30.8) −34.0 (−70.7 to −32.7)
Time since last vaccine dose for individual spreading infection, d
15-90 3 (1.3) 222 (98.7) 13 (1.1) 1225 (98.9) 21.5 (−64.0 to 77.8) 48.5 (23.9 to 61.4)
91-180 9 (1.0) 862 (99.0) 46 (0.9) 5138 (99.1) 14.3 (−43.1 to 58.2) 13.2 (−44.7 to 58.3)
≥180 82 (1.5) 5452 (98.5) 262 (0.8) 33 997 (99.2) 48.8 (34.2 to 60.1) 19.7 (−4.4 to 38.3)
Symptom status of individual spreading infection
Symptomatic 8 (0.5) 1668 (99.5) 8 (1.0) 802 (99.0) −51.9 (−82.0 to 22.3) −32.0 (−89.4 to 77.1)
Asymptomatic 86 (1.7) 4868 (98.3) 313 (0.8) 39 558 (99.2) 55.2 (43.0 to 64.8) 34.9 (15.1 to 50.1)
Contact setting
Household 62 (19.1) 267 (80.9) 154 (13.4) 990 (86.6) 33.0 (7.3 to 51.6) 39.1 (12.7 to 57.5)
Nonhousehold 32 (0.5) 6269 (99.5) 167 (0.4) 39 370 (99.6) 16.9 (−17.6 to 43.1) 8.1 (−27.5 to 38.8)

Abbreviations: CrI, credible interval; NA, not applicable; VE, vaccine effectiveness.

a

Variables adjusted in the model were sex, age of individuals who spread the infection and got infected, last exposed calendar date of contacts, importation status of individual spreading the infection, contact setting, and vaccine status of individual getting infected.

b

These estimates were not calculated owing to insufficient sample size, which led to noninformatively wide 95% CrIs.