Table 1.
Author | Year | Journal | Design | N | Treatments | Timeframe | Withdrawal-related findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Birath, B. et al. a | 2017 | Drug and Alcohol Dependence | Randomized placebo-controlled pilot trial | 11 | Ibudilast (0 mg, 50 mg, 100 mg each for 5 days) | 27 days hospitalized with last assessment at day 22 | Significantly reduced variability in response time to an attention task compared to placebo. |
Black, D.S. & Amaro, H. a,† | 2019 | Behavioral Research and Therapy | Randomized-controlled trial; residential treatment setting | 200 | Mindfulness-based intervention (80 min sessions, 2 per week); psychoeducation control | 6 weeks; abstinence began upon admission to setting | Greater retention that the control group. |
Brooks, S. et al. a | 2016 | NeuroImage: Clinical | Non-randomized controlled trial | 66 | Working memory training (30 mins per day) plus TAU; TAU | 8 weeks; no definition of start of abstinence at baseline | Increases of the bilateral basal ganglia and reduced bilateral cerebellum volume; improvements in self-reported impulsivity scores in the working memory training group, but not in the treatment-as-usual group. |
Cruickshank, C.C. et al. a | 2008 | Drug and Alcohol Review | Randomized placebo-controlled pilot trial | 31 | Mirtazapine (30 mg nocte); placebo | Treatment during first 2 weeks of withdrawal period with follow-up at day 35 | No significant association with retention in out-patient withdrawal treatment |
Glasner-Edwards, S. et al. a,† | 2017 | Mindfulness | Randomized-controlled trial | 63 | Mindfulness-based relapse prevention (8 weekly groups); health education (8 weekly groups) | 12-week trial; 4 weeks contingency management lead in then randomized to: 8 weeks MBRP+CM; 8 weeks HE+CM | Mindfulness-based intervention plus contingency management showed significantly greater reductions in depression and anxiety symptoms compared to Health Education for those with MDD or GAD. |
Hester, R. et al. a | 2010 | Experimental and Clinical Psychopharmacology | Randomized placebo-controlled pilot trial | 20 | Modafinil (200 mg/d); placebo | First 7 days of withdrawal | Significantly improved verbal recall and nonsignificant—but improved—executive function and delayed memory tasks compared to placebo. |
Heinzerling, K.G. et al. b | 2010 | Drug and Alcohol Dependence | Randomized placebo-controlled trial | 71 | Modafinil (400 mg/d); placebo | 12 weeks following randomization | No significant association with depressive symptoms, cravings, and retention |
Jayaram-Lindström et al. b,‡ | 2008 | American Journal of Psychiatry | Randomized placebo-controlled trial | 80 | Naltrexone (50 mg/d); placebo | 12 weeks outpatient; 2 weeks abstinence prior to starting medication | Significantly greater reduction in craving |
Kongsakin, R. et al. a,‡ | 2005 | International Clinical Psychopharmacology | Randomized placebo-controlled trial | 20 | Mirtazapine (15 mg/d titrated to 60 mg/d depending on response) | 14 days, during detoxification | Significantly greater improvement in Amphetamine Withdrawal Questionnaire scores, anxiety, and hyperarousal compared to placebo at days 3 and 14 |
Liang, Y. et al. a | 2018 | JAMA Psychiatry (research letter) | Randomized placebo-controlled trial | 50 | Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (10 Hz, left DLPFC); sham | Two sessions daily for five days with two days between sessions following initial abstinence of 1–15 days | Significantly greater reductions in withdrawal symptoms, craving, depressive symptoms, anxiety symptoms, and greater improvements in sleep quality compared to placebo. |
McGregor, C. et al. a | 2008 | Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment | Three-group clinical trial comparing modafinil, mirtazapine, and historical treatment-as-usual | 49 | Modafinil (400 mg/d); mirtazapine (60 mg/d); periciazine (2.5–5 mg/d) | First 10 days of withdrawal | Significantly lower Amphetamine Cessation Symptom Assessment scores in modafinil and mirtazapine groups compared to periciazine group; greater hours of sleep but more sleep disturbance in the mirtazapine group compared to the modafinil group. |
Miles, S.W. et al. b,‡ | 2013 | Addiction | Randomized-controlled trial | 79 | Extended release methylphenidate (54 mg/d); placebo | 22 weeks following randomization | No significant difference in craving compared to placebo, though retention was higher in those who received methylphenidate. |
Rawson, R.A. et al. a | 2015 | Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment | Randomized controlled trial | 135 | Exercise (45 mins high intensity, 3 per week) plus TAU vs Health education (3 per week) plus TAU | 8 weeks, recruited upon entry in residential treatment | Significantly greater reductions in depressive and anxiety symptoms compared to health education control group. |
Srisurapanont, M. et al. a,‡ | 1999 | Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry | Randomized-controlled trial | 44 | Amineptine (100 mg/d); placebo | 2-week inpatient trial; abstinence started < 5 days prior to randomization | Amineptine reversed decreased energy, increased appetite and craving for sleep compared to placebo |
Su, H. et al. a | 2017 | Drug and Alcohol Dependence | Randomized placebo-controlled pilot trial | 30 | Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (10 Hz, left DPLFC); sham | 3 weeks, but duration of initial abstinence not reported | Significantly greater improvements in verbal learning, memory, and social cognition compared to sham. |
Thompson, R.G., Jr. et al. b | 2021 | Journal of Psychopharmacology | Randomized placebo-controlled pilot trial with planned crossover | 34 | d-amphetamine (60 mg/d); placebo | 4 weeks following randomization | Significant attenuation of craving compared to placebo group; heart rate elevated in placebo during week 1 |
Trivedi, M. et al. b | 2021 | New England Journal of Medicine | Randomized placebo-controlled trial | 403 |
Bupropion (450 mg/d) with extended release naltrexone (380mg at 3 weeks); placebo | 12-week trial; assessments collected weeks 5–6 and 11–12. | Lower craving for combination treatment compared to placebo in assessment weeks |
Symptom-focused trial during the withdrawal period.
Stimulant use reduction trial reporting withdrawal symptoms.
Study participants included both people who used methamphetamine and people who used cocaine.
Study participants included those who used any amphetamine-type stimulant.