Skip to main content
. 2023 Mar 31;14:20417314231164765. doi: 10.1177/20417314231164765

Table 2.

Advantages and limitations of different biomaterials for hydrogels used in AC TET.

No. Name (Abbreviation) Advantages Limitations Refs.
1 Polyethylene glycol (PEG) 1. Biocompatible Biologically inert Wei et al.96
2. Easy to be functionalized Roberts and Bryant107
2 Poly (2-methacryloyloxyethyl phosphorylcholine) (PMPC) 1. Monomer and polymer biocompatible NO cell adhesion molecules Wei et al.96
2. Lubricant
3. Mechanical strength
3 Polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) 1. MSCs chondrogenic differentiation 1. Mechanical strength Wei et al.96
2. Biologically inert Shi et al.108
3. Low cell adhesion Maher et al.109
4. Low bioactivity Bichara et al.110
5. Non-degradable
6. Low equilibrium water content
4 Poly(N-vinylcaprolactam) (PVCL) 1. Thermosensitive 1. Wettability Wei et al.96
2. Biocompatibility 2. Mechanical properties Whittaker et al.111
3. Water uptake capacity 3. Antibiofouling
5 Poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAm) 1. Thermosensitive 1. Low viscosity Lima et al.112
2. Biocompatibility 2. Fast adhesive polymerized properties Guo et al.113
3. Mechanical properties
4. Reversible cell adhesion
6 Polyacrylic acid (PAA) pH-responsive 1. Ionized at high pH Jiang et al.97
2. Lower coefficient of friction Bichara et al.110
7 Polyaniline 1. Electric-responsive Limited hydrophilicity Jiang et al.97
2. Rigid backbone
8 Poly(N,Ndiethylaminoethyl meth acrylate) (PDEAEM) pH-responsive Ionized at low pH Jiang et al.97
9 Poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) 1. Thermosensitive 1. Mechanical strength Sadat Tabatabaei Mirakabad et al.114
2. Approved by the US FDA and European Medicine Agency to use in drug delivery systems 2. Poor loading Qu et al.115
3. Biodegradation 3. High burst release
4. Improved cartilage regeneration 4. Production of acids
5. Biocompatibility
10 Poloxamer 407 (PX) 1. Thermosensitive Induced hyperlipidemia Goo et al.116
2. Mechanical properties Wang et al.117
3. Supersaturating
11 Azobenzene and its derivatives 1. Thermosensitive 1. Stability of the switch in vivo Jiang et al.97
2. Light-responsive 2. Rapid spatiotemporal control
3. Hypoxia-response 3. Absorption wavelengths compatible with biological tissue optical windows
4. UV phototoxic damage
12 Lithium phenyl (2,4,6-trimethylbenzoyl) phosphinate (LAP) 1. UV photoinitiator 1. Cytotoxic Qin et al.94
2. Water-soluble 2. Mutagenic
13 Cellulose 1. Can be sulfated 1. Mechanical properties Wei et al.96
2. Nanofibrils similar to collagen fibrils of tissue ECM 2. Limited 3D nano-scale pore structure Li et al.118
3. Lack of biological function
14 Chondroitin sulfate (CS) 1. Component of natural cartilage Rapid degradation Wei et al.96
2. Regulate hypertrophy during MSCs chondrogenesis Chen et al.119
3. Promote cartilage ECM production
4. Inhibiting inflammation
15 Hyaluronic acid (HA) 1. pH-responsive NO cell adhesion molecules Wei et al.96
2. Component of natural cartilage Jiang et al.97
3. Increase the synthesis of ECM and chondrogenesis
4. Easy to be functionalized
16 Chitosan, chitin and their derivatives 1. Thermosensitive 1. Low solubility Wei et al.96
2. Ions-responsive 2. High viscosity Jiang et al.97
3. Electric-responsive
4. pH-responsive
5. Drug delivery
6. Easy to be functionalized
17 Alginate 1. Thermosensitive 1. Lack of biodegradability Wei et al.96
2. pH-responsive 2. Immunological responses for its endotoxin contents Liu et al.120
3. 3D bioprinting 3. The rapid gelling process
4. Mechanical strength 4. Limited capacity to retain GAGs
5. Gene carriers 5. Insufficiently cell adhesion
6. Biocompatible component with a high water content, good porosity and tunable viscosity
7. Powerful capacity to retain collagen
18 Collagen 1. Natural ECM protein 1. Limited number of functional groups for crosslinking Wei et al.96
2. Immunomodulation 2. Fast degradation Long et al.121
3. Poor mechanical properties
4. Excessive cell-mediated shrinkage
19 Gelatin 1. Promote cell adhesion 1. Weakly mechanical properties and brittleness Shi et al.122
2. UV photoinitiator 2. Low thermal stability Vassallo et al.123
3. 3D bioprinting 3. High sensitivity to enzymatic degradation
4. Highly biocompatible, biodegradable, and cost-effective
20 Silk fibroin (SF) 1. Mimicking the collagen structure of native cartilage with biocompatibility, biodegradability, high tensile strength, and various cells adherence 1. Limited options for anchoring growth factor Cheng et al.124
2. Immunocompatible 2. Large brittleness Qi et al.125
3. The diverse ability to crosslink or solution-to-gel 3. Low stability in aqueous solution
4. Natural photoluminescence 4. Difficult to be crosslinked
21 Fibrin Easy to be functionalized No chondro-permissive Thorpe et al.126
22 Agarose (AG) 1. Thermosensitive 1. Low mechanical properties Bahcecioglu et al.127
2. Biocompatibility 2. Low cell adhesion
3. Promote expression of GAGs
4. Non-immunogenic properties
23 Methacrylic anhydride (MA) Photo-crosslinkable Low mechanical properties Xia et al.95
24 Peptides Promote MSCs chondrogenesis Need proper peptide design, synthesis, and purification Jiang et al.97