Skip to main content
. 2023 Mar 22;14:1024120. doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2023.1024120

Table 2.

Subgroup analysis results of Total glucosides of paeony.

Outcomes Subgroup Overall effect Heterogeneity test Statistical method Studies (N) Sample size (N) Figure
Effect 95%CI P I2 (%) P(Q)
DAS28 12 weeks WMD=-0.80 [-1.68, 0.07] 0.07 93.09 <0.001 Random 5 670 Figure S1
24 weeks WMD=-1.06 [-2.51, 0.39] 0.15 98.00 <0.001 Random 2 314
≥36 weeks WMD=-1.03 [-2.73, 0.66] 0.23 96.61 <0.001 Random 2 162
ESR ≤12 weeks WMD=-6.53 [-9.92, -3.13] <0.001 87.17 <0.001 Random 11 1018 Figure S2
24 weeks WMD=-5.57 [-14.50, 3.37] 0.22 81.66 <0.001 Random 4 424
36 weeks WMD=-5.80 [-9.59, -2.01] <0.001 Random 1 80
CRP ≤12 weeks SMD=-1.44 [-2.14, -0.73] <0.001 95.90 <0.001 Random 11 1001 Figure S3
24 weeks SMD=-1.23 [-2.13, -0.33] <0.001 92.98 <0.001 Random 4 350
≥36 weeks SMD=-1.00 [-1.33, -0.67] 0.00 0.00 0.42 Random 2 162
RF ≤12 weeks SMD=-1.20 [-1.89, -0.50] <0.001 94.23 <0.001 Random 7 700 Figure S4
≥ 24 weeks SMD=-5.26 [-9.62, -0.89] 0.02 99.26 <0.001 Random 3 284
Adverse events ≤12 weeks RR=0.56 [0.42, 0.77] <0.001 0.00 0.86 Random 9 852 Figure S5
≥24 weeks RR=0.53 [0.37, 0.76] <0.001 0.00 0.95 Random 6 510
DAS28 Twice a day WMD=-1.8 [-2.08, -1.52] 0.00 Random 1 120 Figure S6
Three times a day WMD=-0.80 [-1.38, -0.21] <0.001 92.85 <0.001 Random 8 1026
ESR Twice a day WMD=-13.54 [-19.32, -7.77] <0.001 86.33 0.00684 Random 2 200 Figure S7
Three times a day WMD=-5.13 [-7.67, -2.58] <0.001 67.79 0.000121 Random 14 1322
CRP Twice a day SMD=-3.67 [-5.56, -1.77] <0.001 96.50 <0.001 Random 3 320 Figure S8
Three times a day SMD=-0.87 [-1.23, -0.50] <0.001 88.58 <0.001 Random 14 1193
RF Twice a day SMD=-7.15 [-11.07, -3.23] <0.001 98.79 <0.001 Random 3 320 Figure S9
Three times a day SMD=-0.40 [-0.94, 0.15] 0.15 91.30 <0.001 Random 7 664
Adverse events Twice a day RR=0.48 [0.28, 0.81] <0.001 0.00 0.80 Random 3 280 Figure S10
Three times a day RR=0.57 [0.44, 0.74] <0.001 0.00 0.96 Random 12 1082