Skip to main content
. 2023 Mar 22;14:1024120. doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2023.1024120

Table 3.

Subgroup analysis results of curcumin.

Outcomes Subgroup Overall effect Heterogeneity test Statistical method Studies (N) Sample size (N) Figure
Effect 95%CI P I2 (%) P(Q)
DAS28 ≤250mg MD=-0.93 [-1.83, -0.02] 0.045 89.86 <0.001 Random 3 79 Figure S11
500mg MD=-1.30 [-1.99, -0.61] <0.001 71.11 0.02 Random 4 68
ESR ≤250mg MD=-71.94 [-153.31, 9.42] 0.083 99.13 <0.001 Random 3 79 Figure S12
500mg MD=-44.53 [-89.09, 0.02] 0.050 98.46 <0.001 Random 5 112
CRP 250mg MD=-0.40 [-0.49, -0.30] <0.001 0.00 0.92 Random 2 30 Figure S13
500mg MD=-0.32 [-0.63, -0.02] 0.037 95.76 <0.001 Random 3 74
RF 250mg MD=-50.52 [-63.67, -37.37] <0.001 0.00 0.78 Random 2 30 Figure S14
500mg MD=-52.08 [-65.21, -38.95] <0.001 0.00 0.69 Random 2 30
DAS28 8 weeks MD=-0.33 [-1.18, 0.53] 0.46 0.00 0.97 Random 2 38 Figure S15a
12 weeks MD=-1.29 [-1.93, -0.65] <0.001 88.40 <0.001 Random 5 109
ESR 8 weeks MD=-4.51 [-9.38, 0.36] 0.069 19.28 0.29 Random 4 131 Figure S15b
12 weeks MD=-107.27 [-115.32, -99.22] <0.001 0.00 0.97 Random 4 60
CRP 8 weeks MD=-0.06 [-0.13, 0.01] 0.084 Random 1 44 Figure S15c
12 weeks MD=-0.43 [-0.50, -0.36] <0.001 0.00 0.72 Random 4 60