Skip to main content
. 2022 Dec 9;10(5):2734–2745. doi: 10.1002/nop2.1540

TABLE 1.

Characteristics of the 17 studies included in the meta‐analysis

Study author (year) Region Publication type Mean age r N Resilience measurement PTG measurement JBI score
Lu, 2014 Northeastern Dissertation 50.47 0.249 159 CD‐RISC PTGI‐19 8
Cai & Shi, 2015 Northeastern Journal 50.75 0.383 101 CD‐RISC PTGI‐20 7
Jia et al., 2016 Eastern Journal 46.78 0.572 303 CD‐RISC PTGI‐20 9
Lei et al., 2017 Eastern Journal 46.78 0.434 350 CD‐RISC PTGI‐20 8
Wang et al., 2017 Eastern Journal 43.2 0.381 120 CD‐RISC PTGI‐21 7
Liu et al., 2018 N/A Journal 49 0.350 108 FRAS‐C PTGI‐SF 7
Yu et al., 2018 Eastern Journal N/A 0.491 302 CD‐RISC‐10 PTGI‐20 8
Li, 2019 Central Dissertation N/A 0.379 244 CD‐RISC PTGI‐21 8
Li et al., 2019 Central Journal N/A 0.386 224 CD‐RISC PTGI‐21 9
Shi et al., 2019 Eastern Journal N/A 0.748 160 RS‐14 PTGI‐21 6
Yan et al., 2019 Eastern Journal 49.91 0.650 180 CD‐RISC PTGI‐21 8
Ding, 2020 Eastern Journal N/A 0.301 299 CD‐RISC‐10 PTGI‐20 7
Geng et al., 2020 Eastern Journal 49.16 0.491 302 CD‐RISC‐10 PTGI‐20 8
Zhu & Liu, 2020 Central Journal 41.28 0.502 78 RS‐14 PTGI‐21 8
Tu et al., 2020 Eastern Journal 51.54 0.610 201 CD‐RISC PTGI‐21 7
Zhang, 2021 Central Dissertation 47 0.157 236 CD‐RISC PTGI‐20 8
Shi et al., 2022 Northeastern Journal 53.28 0.307 789 RS‐14 PTGI‐21 8

Note: N/A=Not reported.

Abbreviations: CD‐RISC, Connor‐Davidson Resilience Scale; FRAS‐C, Shortened Chinese Version of the Family Resilience Assessment Scale; CD‐RISC‐10, Simplified CD‐RISC was compiled by Campbell‐Sills; RS‐14, 14‐item Resilience Scale; PTGI‐21, Posttraumatic Growth Inventory. PTGI‐19, 19‐items PTGI; PTGI‐20, 20‐items PTGI; PTGI‐SF, Short Form of the Posttraumatic Growth Inventory.