Skip to main content
. 2023 Apr 6;18(4):e0283685. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0283685

Table 1. Characteristics of included publications in the literature.

Author; year Geographical Region Year of Data Collection Children (No); Age Sample Strategy Study Design Population Characteristics Quality Assessment Score
Abdalla et al. 2009 El Fau (Rural area) in Sudan 2003 N = 150
6–60 months
Random sampling Cross sectional study Children under five in the three target villages Medium
Abu-Manga et al. 2021  Sudan 2019 N = 145,002
0–5 years
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five from households in the Sudanese community High
Aitsi-Selmi 2014 Egypt 1992–95 N = 9,201
0–5 years
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five in the community High
2005–8 N = 13,376
0–5 years
Almasi et al. 2019 Egypt 2014 N = 14898.9
0–5 years
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five in the Eastern Mediterranean countries Medium
Libya 2007 N = 10723
0–5 years
Morocco 2011 N = 6872.6
0–5 years
Sudan 2014 N = 11712.3
0–5 years
Tunisia 2012 N = 2677.3
0–5 yrs.
Barouaca 2012 Morocco 2004 N = 5311
0–5 yrs.
Multistage sampling surveys Cross sectional study Children under five in the community Medium
1997 N = 5240
0–5 years
1992 N = 4502
0–5 years
Dahab et al 2020 Sudan 2014 N = 14,081
0–5 years
Stratified multistage cluster sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five from households in armed conflicts in Darfur in Eastern state, Blue Nile and South Kordofan High
Elsary 2017 Egypt (Tamiya district in Fayoum) 2014 N = 400
0–5 years
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five who attend the health care facilities High
El-Taguri et al. 2009 Libya 2003 N = 7232
0–5 years
Multistage sampling designs Cross sectional study Children under five in five Arab countries (Libya, Djibouti, Syria, Morocco and Yemen High
Morocco 2003 N = 5380
0–5 years
El Taguri et al. 2008 Libya 1995 N = 5348
0–5 years
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five from households across Libya High
Fagbamigbe et al. 2020  Egypt 2014 N = 13,682
0–5 years
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five in the community High
Figueroa and Kurdi 2019 Egypt 2014 N = 13601
6–59 months
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five in the community Medium
2008 N = 9103
6–59 months
2005 12131
6-59m
Ghattas et al. 2020  Egypt 2014 N = 13,857
6–59 months
Stratified cluster sampling Cross sectional study Children under five in Middle East and North African (MENA) region High
Algeria 2013 N = 13,077
6–59 months
Sudan 2014 N = 12,538
6–59 months
Morocco 2003 N = 5309
6–59 months
Tunisia 2012 N = 2593
6–59 months
Kavle et al. 2015  (Egypt) 2008 N = 6091
6–59 months
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five from households across Egypt High
2005 N = 7794
6–59 months
Kerac et al 2019 Egypt 2014 N = 1,210
0–6 months
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children less than six months of age in developing countries High
Kiarie et al. 2021  Sudan Yambio country 2018 N = 630
6–59 months
Cluster multistage sampling method Cross Sectional study Children aged 6–59 months living in Yambio County, Sudan High
Mberu et al. 2016 Egypt (Slum communities) 2003 N = 5761
0–5 years
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five in the community Medium
Musa et al. 2014 Sudan (Khartoum State) 2014 N = 411
0–5 years
Simple random sampling Cross sectional study Children under five in Khartoum state, Sudan Medium
Nikooyeh et al. 2022  Egypt 2020 N = 163
0–5 years
Online surveys Cross sectional study Children under five in Eastern Mediterranean countries Medium
2015 N = 258
0–5 years
2010 N = 409
0–5 years
2005 N = 713
0–5 years
2000 N = 1142
0–5 years
Sudan 2020 N = 29
0–5 years
2015 N = 99
0–5 years
2010 N = 266
0–5 years
2005 N = 80
0–5 years
2000 N = 28
0–5 years
Libya 2020 N = 74
0–5 years
2015 N = 111
0–5 years
2010 N = 225
0–5 years
2005 N = 320
0–5 years
2000 N = 241
0–5 years
Morocco 2020 N = 286
0–5 years
2015 N = 347
0–5 years
2010 N = 640
0–5 years
2005 N = 652
0–5 years
2000 N = 679
0–5 years
Tunisia 2020 N = 507
0–5 years
2015 N = 960
0–5 years
2010 N = 1064
0–5 years
2005 N = 1212
0–5 years
2000 N = 985
0–5 years
Özaltin et al. 2010 Egypt 2005–2008 N = 33440
0–59 months
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five in Egypt and Morocco High
Morocco 2003–04 N = 5544
0–59 months
Rico et al. 2010 Egypt 2005 N = 3242
6–59 months
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five in the community High
Seedhom et al. 2014 Egypt (El-Minia) 2014 N = 700
6–24 months
Non-random sampling Cross sectional study Children 6–24 months in Minia region, Egypt Medium
Shaker-Berbari et al 2021 Egypt 2014 N = 5100
6–23 months
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five in the Middle East High
Sudan 2014 N = 4009
6–23 months
Sharaf and Rashad 2016  Egypt 2014 N = 12,997
0–5 years
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five in the community Medium
Sulaiman et al. 2018  North Sudan (Rural area) 2014 N = 1635
0–5 years
Cluster multistage sampling method Cross Sectional study Children under five who live in the Four Nile River rural area of Sudan High
Tzioumis et al. 2016  Egypt 2008 N = 9275
0–5 years
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five in the community High
2005 N = 12038
0–5 years
2003 N = 5911
0–5 years
2000 N = 10078
0–5 years
1995 N = 10165
0–5 years
1992 N = 7241
0–5 years
Winskill et al. 2021  Egypt 2014 N = 11,706
0–5 years
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five in 39 low to middle-income countries High
Zotarelli et al. 2007 Egypt 2000 N = 10194
0–5 years
Multi-stage stratified sampling design Cross sectional study Children under five in the community High

High = 7–9; medium = 4–6, and poor = 0–3