Table 1.
Summary of articles included in this review (n = 31)
Article [Refs.] (Author, Year, Journal) |
Cancer types (No. patients) | Research question | Patient data sources, years | Cancer care continuum | Reporting quality |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Abbas et al., 2021, Ann Surg Oncol [26] |
Colon (n = 26,287) Lung (n = 16,645) Pancreatic (n = 6,183) Rectal (n = 3,174) Esophageal (n = 1,427) |
Are county-level SVI and race/ethnicity associated with patterns of hospice utilization among those who underwent a cancer resection and who lived ≥ 30 days after the surgery? | Medicare, 2013–17 | End-of-life | Excellent |
Azap et al., 2020, Surgery [27] |
Pancreatic (n = 18,841) Liver (n = 13,301) |
Is county-level SVI associated with the probability of post-op textbook outcomes in those who underwent a cancer resection? | Medicare, 2013–17 | Treatment Recovery | Excellent |
Azap et al., 2021, Ann Surg Oncol [28] |
Pancreatic (n = 15,931) | Are county-level SVI and race/ethnicity associated with the probability of undergoing a cancer resection or receiving chemotherapy? | SEER-Medicare, 2004–16 | Treatment | Excellent |
Azap et al., 2021, JAMA Surg [29] |
Liver (n = 10,888) | Are county-level SVI and race/ethnicity associated with the probability of undergoing a cancer resection or transplant? | SEER-Medicare, 2004–17 | Treatment | Excellent |
Barmash et al., 2020, J Am Coll Surg [30] |
Colon (n ~ 35,324) | Is county-level SVI associated with emergent vs. non-emergent colon resection and post-op outcomes? | Medicare, 2016–17 |
Treatment Treatment Recovery |
Low |
Bhandari et al., 2021, Blood [31] |
Acute myeloid leukemia (n = 652 in California) | Is census tract-level SVI associated with 1-year non-relapse mortality? | Single institution(s) in California, 2013–19 | N/A | Low |
Bowers et al., 2020, Lab Invest [32] |
Leukemia (NR; 727 counties in 14 states) |
Does leukemia subtype incidence vary within and between areas of SES disparity? SDOH Measures: Gini, income inequality, county-level SVI, residential segregation, rurality |
SEER-21, 2000–16 | Diagnosis | Low |
Carmichael et al., 2022, Am J Surg [33] |
Colorectal (n = 392) | Is census tract-level SVI associated with increased risk of post-op 30-day morbidity following colectomy? | Single institutions in Colorado, 2013–2017 | Treatment Recovery | Good |
Dalmacy et al., 2021, Surgery [34] |
Pancreatic (NR) Liver (NR) |
Is county-level SVI associated with risk of fragmented post-op care among those who had ≥ 1 readmission within 90 days? | Medicare, 2013–17 |
Treatment Treatment Recovery |
Excellent |
Diaz et al., 2021, Ann Surg Oncol [35] |
Lung (n = 14,403 in California) Rectal (n = 7,520 in CA) Pancreatic (n = 3,744 in CA) Esophageal (n = 1,270 in CA) |
Is county-level SVI associated with utilization of high-volume hospitals for high-risk cancer operations? | California OSHPD, 2012–16 | Treatment | Excellent |
Diaz et al., 2021, J Gastrointest Surg [36] |
Colon (n = 33,312) | Is county-level SVI associated with the probability of having a non-elective vs. elective colon resection? | MedPAR, 2016–17 |
Treatment Treatment Recovery |
Excellent |
Diaz et al., 2021, J Surg Oncol [37] |
Lung (n = 33,803) Colon (n = 21,939) |
What is the impact of county-level SVI and racial/ethnic residential diversity on post-op outcomes among those who underwent a cancer resection? | Medicare, 2016–17 |
Treatment Treatment Recovery |
Excellent |
Diaz et al., 2021, Surgery [38] |
Pancreatic (n = 13,393) Liver (n = 3,594) |
Is county-level SVI associated with use of a high-volume or Magnet recognition hospital? | Medicare, 2013–17 |
Treatment Treatment Recovery |
Excellent |
Ganatra et al., 2021, Circulation [39] |
Any (NR) | Is county-level SVI associated with mortality from cardiovascular disease and concomitant cancer (cardio-oncology)? | CDC WONDER, 2014–18 | N/A | Low |
Grant et al., 2021, Blood [40] |
Liquid tumors (e.g., multiple myeloma, leukemia, lymphoma) (n = 338 in North Carolina) | Is county-level SVI associated with physical frailty? |
Carolina Senior Registry, NR Registry for Adults with PCDs, NR |
N/A | Low |
Grant et al., 2021, J Clin Oncol [41] |
Multiple myeloma (NR; 456 trials registered in North Carolina) | Is county-level SVI associated with multiple myeloma trial availability in North Carolina? | ClinicalTrials.gov, accessed 01/24/2021 | Treatment | Low |
Hawley et al., 2022 JAMA Netw Open [42] |
Any, except NMSCs (n = 4,749) | Is there a spatiotemporal association in COVID-19 outcomes? | CCC19, Mar.–Nov. 2020 | Treatment | Excellent |
Hyer et al., 2021, J Am Coll Surg [43] |
Colon (n = 113,929) Lung (n = 70,642) Rectal (n = 14,849) Esophageal (n = 4,380) |
Are there differences in textbook outcomes relative to county-level SVI and race/ethnicity among those who underwent a cancer operation? | Medicare, 2013–17 |
Treatment Treatment Recovery |
Excellent |
Labiner et al., 2022, J Gastrointest Surg [44] |
Pancreas? Liver? (n = 26,540) | Does county-level SVI subtheme analysis in patients undergoing hepatopancreatic surgery better stratify potential gaps in identifying risks of post-op complications? | Medicare, 2013–17 | Treatment Recovery | Good |
McAlarnen et al., 2021, Gynecol Oncol [45] |
Ovarian, uterine, cervical, or vaginal/vulvar (n = 270 in NYC) | Is census tract-level SVI associated with the utilization of virtual gynecologic oncology visits at the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic? | Single institution(s) in NYC, 2020 | Survivorship Care | Good |
McAlarnen et al., 2022, Cancer Epidemiol Biomark Prev [46] |
Cervical (n = 66 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin) | Are demographic and geographic factors (e.g., census tract-level SVI) associated with diagnosis of locally advanced cervical cancer? | Single institution(s) in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, 2016–21 | Diagnosis | Low |
Mock et al., 2021, Transplant Cell Ther [47] |
Acute myeloid leukemia (n = 818 in Virginia) | Do hematopoietic cell transplantation rates for acute myeloid leukemia vary between different regions in Virginia? Or vary by census tract-level SVI? | Virginia Cancer Registry, 2013–17 | Treatment | Excellent |
Pan et al., 2021, Hepatology [48] |
Liver (n = 99 in NYC) | Do neighborhood-level (e.g., census tract-level) characteristics impact alcohol-associated liver disease outcomes (including development of HCC)? | Single institution(s) in NYC, 2012–19 |
Prevention Diagnosis |
Low |
Papageorge et al., 2021, J Am Coll Surg [49] |
Liver (n = 19,751 in 12 states) | Was county-level SVI associated with the impact of Medicaid expansion on the diagnosis of HCC? | SEER, 2010–16 | Diagnosis | Excellent |
Parks et al., 2022, JAMA [50] |
Any (n = 3,619,393 in 1,206 counties) | Is county-level tropical cyclone exposure associated with county-level cause-specific mortality (including cancer-specific mortality)? | CDC NCHS, 1988–18 | Prevention | Excellent |
Puvvula et al., 2021, Water [51] |
All pediatric cancers (n = 2,559 in Nebraska) | Are atrazine concentrations at watersheds associated with the incidence of pediatric cancers in Nebraska? Model: adjusted for census tract-level SVI | Nebraska Cancer Registry, 1987–16 |
Prevention Diagnosis |
Good |
Rice et al., 2021, Ann Surg Oncol [52] |
Liver (n = 14,369) | What factors (e.g., county-level SVI) are associated with hospice utilization and end-of-life healthcare expenditures among those who died of HCC? | SEER-Medicare, 2004–16 | End-of-life | Excellent |
Taylor et al., 2021, Gastroenterology [53] |
Colon (n = 146,041) | Is Medicaid-Medicare dual eligibility status associated with non-elective surgery for colon cancer and variation in outcomes and spending? Analyses: stratified by county-level SVI | Medicare, 2014–18 | Treatment | Low |
Ying et al., 2020, Hepatology [54] |
Liver (n = 143 in NYC) | Are racial and neighborhood-level factors (e.g., SVI) associated with adverse outcomes in those with cirrhosis due to viral hepatitis? | Single institutions(s) in NYC, 2012–19 |
Prevention Diagnosis |
Low |
Ying et al., 2021, Hepatology [55] |
Liver (n = 98 in NYC) | Is SVI associated with advanced-stage HCC diagnosis in those with cirrhosis due to viral hepatitis? | Single institution(s) in NYC, 2012–20 |
Prevention Diagnosis |
Low |
Zhang et al., 2022, Health Aff (Project Hope) [56] |
Colon (n = 203,732) | Is county-level SVI associated with unplanned surgeries for one of three specified access-sensitive conditions (including colectomy for colon cancer)? | MedPAR, 2014–18 | Treatment | Excellent |
*Nationwide, unless otherwise indicated
SVI social vulnerability index, post-op post-operative, SEER Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results Program, SDOH social determinants of health, SES socioeconomic status, CA California, OSHPD Office of State-wide Health Planning and Development, MedPAR Medicare Provider Analysis and Review, CDC Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, WONDER Wide-ranging Online Data for Epidemiologic Research, PCD plasma cell disorder, NMSC non-melanoma skin cancer, COVID-19 coronavirus disease 2019, CCC19 COVID-19 and Cancer Consortium, NYC New York City, HCC hepatocellular carcinoma, NCHS National Center for Health Statistics, NR not reported