Comparison of mean deep-ocean (below 2 km) solubility anomalies measured at the BATS site with model predictions using the L13 gas exchange parameterization in which the bubble terms are multiplied by a scalar, b. Measured isotopic anomalies (ΔIR; left-hand side) and elemental ratio anomalies (ΔER; right-hand side) both suggest that an enhancement of bubble fluxes is needed (i.e., b > 1), with an optimal value of b ≈ 2 compatible with five of six independent tracers. Error bars indicate ±1 SE, accounting for both measurement uncertainties and uncertainties in the solubility equilibrium values. Deep-ocean mean Δ(Kr/Ar) and Δ(Xe/Ar) values shown from this study (light blue) and ref 24 (dark blue), excluding artifactually low Δ(Kr/Ar) below −2% in ref 24. Modeled Δ(N2/Ar) is compared with the below 2-km mean of published Δ(N2/Ar) measurements from the BATS site (16, 25).