Table 1.
Study | Study Design | Study Population | No. of Patients Analyzed | No. of Rituximab Courses | Rituximab Regimen per Course, mg/m2 | Maintenance Immunosuppression | Immune Cells | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Colucci et al.,18 2016 | Retrospective cohort study | FRNS/SDNS | 28 | 1 | 375 × 1 (n=24) 375 × 2 (n=4) |
Steroid MMF CNI For more than 3 months |
B cells T cells |
Complete depletion of total CD19+, transitional, mature-naive, and memory B-cell subsets, which started to reappear at 6 months; normalization of total CD19+, transitional, mature-naive B cells at 12 months; significant reduction of memory B-cell subsets at 12 months. A delayed recovery of total memory B cells and in particular of switched memory B cells was associated with a reduced risk of relapse. No association with relapse was found for the other B-cell subsets. No modification in total CD3+ T cells; normalization of the initially low CD4+/CD8+ T-cell ratio at 12 months. No association with relapse. |
Chan et al.,19 2016 | Cohort study | SDNS (n=4) SRNS (n=18) |
22 | 1 | 375 × 2 (n=10) 375 × 4 (n=12) |
Steroid and CNI for <3 months MMF for more than 3 months |
B cells T cells |
Total CD19+ B cells started to reappear at 7 months. No association with relapse. At baseline, ex vivo activated T cells (CD154+CD4+CD3+, IFNγ+CD3+, IL-2+CD3+) were lower in responders compared with nonresponders; at 6 months, recovery of all three activated T-cell subsets was observed in responders and no modification was induced in nonresponders. |
Bhatia et al.,14 2018 | Cohort study | SDNS | 18 | 1 | 375 × 2 (n=18) | Steroid Tapered in 3–5 months |
B cells T cells |
Complete depletion of total CD19+ B cells in 16/18 patients, which started to reappear at 6 months. An earlier recovery of total CD19+ B cells and total memory B cells was associated with relapse. Reduction of Th17 and Th2 cells; increase of regulatory T cells. At relapse, patients had higher Th17 and Th2 cells and lower regulatory T cells. No modification of Th1 cells. |
Boumediene et al.,15 2018 | Double-blind RCT | CNI- or MMF-dependent FRNS/SDNS |
23 | 1 | 375 × 2 (n=10) Placebo (n=13) |
Steroid MMF CNI For <3 months |
B cells T cells |
Not evaluated. No modification of total CD3+ T cells and of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells; reduction of T follicular helper cells and invariant natural killer T cells, associated with remission; increase of regulatory T cells. At relapse, patients had lower regulatory T cells. |
Fribourg et al.,20 2021 | Cohort study | CNI-dependent SDNS | 30 | 1 | 375 × 1 (n=15) Ofatumumab 1.50 g/1.73 m2 × 1 (n=15) |
Steroid CNI For < 3 months |
B cells T cells Innate immune cells |
Total CD19+, transitional, naive, regulatory, antibody-secreting and memory B-cell subsets were significantly reduced after 3–7 months. An earlier recovery of switched B-cell subsets was associated with relapse. Reduction of Th17 and T follicular helper cells. No modification of Th1 or regulatory T cells. No association with relapse. No significant modification. No association with relapse. |
Ravani et al.,16 2021 | Open-label, RCT | CNI-dependent SDNS | 69a | 1 | 375 × 1 (n=33) Ofatumumab 1.50 g/1.73 m2 × 1 (n=36) |
Steroid MMF CNI For <3 months |
B cells |
Complete depletion of total CD19+, transitional, mature-naive, total memory, IgM memory, switched memory B cells and plasmablasts at 1 month, which started to reappear at 3 months in the rituximab arm and at 6 months in the ofatumumab arm; normalization of total CD19+, transitional, mature-naive B cells and plasmablasts at 12 months; significant reduction of memory B-cell subsets at 12 months. The transient more prolonged B-cell depletion with ofatumumab compared with rituximab did not modify the incidence of relapse at 12 and at 24 months. |
T cells | Transient increase of total CD3+ T cells at 1–3 months, with normalization at 12 months; regulatory T cells started to increase at 1–3 months and were still significantly higher at 12 months. Association with relapse was not evaluated. |
|||||||
Innate immune cells | Transient increase of total CD56+ natural killer cells at 1–3 months, with normalization at 12 months. Association with relapse was not evaluated. |
FRNS, frequently relapsing nephrotic syndrome; SDNS, steroid-dependent nephrotic syndrome; MMF, mycophenolate mofetil; CNI, calcineurin inhibitor; SRNS, steroid-resistant nephrotic syndrome; RCT, randomized controlled trial.
Data on immunological modifications were available for 69/140 enrolled patients.