Table 1.
Study | Groups | No. of patients (No. of patients with successful assessment of viral infectivity) |
Sampling time points | Results Viral load (RT-qPCR) |
Assessment of viral infectivity | Results Viral infectivity |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Barrueco et al. [85] |
- 2% PVP-I - 1% H2O2 - 0.07% CPC - 0.12% CHX - Placebo |
54 (29) |
- Baseline - 30 min - 60 min |
- No significant reduction in viral load for PVP-I, H2O2, CPC, or CHX at 30 or 60 min - Significant decrease of viral load for placebo 60 min after rinsing |
Virus rescue in cell culture | Significant decrease of 1.5 log genome copies/mL in CPC group 60 min after gargling |
Alemany et al. [83] |
- 0.07% CPC - Placebo |
105 (80) |
- Baseline - 60 min - 180 min |
No significant reduction in viral load in both groups | Quantification of SARS-CoV-2 nucleocapsid protein by modified ELISA | Significantly increased level of SARS-CoV-2 nucleocapsid protein 60 and 180 min after gargling in test group |
Tarragó-Gil et al. [89] |
- 0.07% CPC - Placebo |
80 (79) |
- Baseline - 20 min |
No significant reduction in viral load in both groups | Quantification of SARS-CoV-2 nucleocapsid protein by modified ELISA | Significantly increased level of SARS-CoV-2 nucleocapsid protein 120 min after gargling in test group |
Meister et al. [75] |
- 0.1% BAC - Placebo |
24 (6) |
- Baseline - 15 min - 30 min |
No significant reduction of viral load for both groups at all time points | Virus rescue in cell culture | Mild non-significant decrease of viral infectivity in test group |
Bonn et al. [90] |
- 0.05% CHX and 0.05% CPC - Placebo |
61 (15) |
- Baseline - 30 min |
Slight (0.5 log10) decrease of viral load in both groups | Virus rescue in cell culture | Significant decrease by 1.4 log10 30 min after gargling in test group |