Table 4.
Author | Year | Type of study | Sample size (n) | Method of sleep disorder assessment | Method of hormone measurement | Duration of data acquisition | Multiple measurements | Overall ratinga |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Thomson and Oswald [101] | 1977 | Controlled trial | 34 | Electrophysiological recording | — | 14 weeks | Yes | Fair |
Furuhjelm and Carlström [102] | 1977 | Pre-Post | 209 | Self-report | Blood | 3.5 years | Yes | Poor |
Hagen et al [103] | 1982 | Cross-sectional | 313 | Questionnaires | Blood | Not stated | No | Fair |
Shargil [104] | 1985 | Controlled trial | 100 | Questionnaires | — | 3 years | Yes | Fair |
Erkkola et al [105] | 1991 | Pre-Post | 249 | Interviews | — | 6 months | Yes | Fair |
Yang et al [106] | 1995 | Pre-Post | 20 | Questionnaires | — | 3 months | No | Fair |
Polo-Kantola et al [107] | 1999 | Cross-sectional | 63 | Polysomnography, self-report | Blood | 4 months | Yes | Good |
Polo-Kantola et al [108] | 1999 | Randomized controlled | 66 | Polysomnography, self-report | Blood | 7 months | Yes | Fair |
Strickler et al [109] | 2000 | Randomized controlled | 398 | Questionnaires | Blood | 12 months | Yes | Good |
Antonijevic et al [110] | 2000 | Pre-Post | 11 | Polysomnography, questionnaire | — | Not stated | No | Fair |
Li et al [111] | 2000 | Cross-sectional | 693 | Questionnaires, interviews | — | 3 years | No | Good |
Hollander et al [112] | 2001 | Cohort | 436 | Questionnaire | Blood | 2 years | Yes | Good |
Montplaisir et al [113] | 2001 | Randomized parallel group | 21 | Polysomnography, questionnaires | — | 6 months | Yes | Good |
Barnabei et al [114] | 2002 | Randomized controlled | 2763 | Questionnaires | — | 4 years | Yes | Good |
Netzer et al [115] | 2003 | Cross-sectional | 53 | Polysomnography | Blood | Not stated | No | Fair |
Shahar et al [116] | 2003 | Cross-sectional | 2852 | Polysomnography, questionnaires | — | 51 months | No | Fair |
Young et al [117] | 2003 | Cohort | 589 | Polysomnography, questionnaire | — | 8 years | Yes | Good |
Polo-Kantola et al [118] | 2003 | Randomized controlled | 62 | Polysomnography, static-charge-sensitive bed | Blood | 7 months | Yes | Fair |
Manber et al [119] | 2003 | Within subject | 6 | Polysomnography, sleep diary | Blood | 40 days | No | Good |
Freeman et al [120] | 2004 | Cohort | 436 | Interviews, questionnaires | Blood | 5 years | Yes | Good |
Ford et al [121] | 2005 | Cohort | 660 | Interviews, questionnaires | Blood | 10 years | Yes | Good |
Gambacciani et al [122] | 2005 | Randomized controlled | 60 | Questionnaires | — | 12 weeks | Yes | Fair |
Nielsen et al [123] | 2006 | Randomized controlled | 335 | Questionnaires | Blood | 2 years | Yes | Fair |
Rowley et al [124] | 2006 | Pre-Post | 35 | Polysomnography | Blood | 30 days | No | Fair |
Murphy and Campell [125] | 2007 | Cross-sectional | 10 | Polysomnography, self-report | Blood | 2 weeks and 3 nights | Yes | Fair |
Dennerstein et al [126] | 2007 | Cohort | 204 | Interviews, questionnaires | Blood | 13 years | Yes | Good |
Carranza-Lira et al [127] | 2007 | Pre-Post | 14 | Questionnaires | — | 3 months | No | Fair |
Kravitz et al [128] | 2008 | Cohort | 3045 | Self-report | Blood | 7 years | Yes | Good |
Sowers et al [129] | 2008 | Cross-sectional | 365 | Polysomnography, questionnaire | Blood | 35 days | Yes | Good |
Pien et al [130] | 2008 | Cohort | 436 | Questionnaires | Blood | 8 years | Yes | Good |
Schüssler et al [131] | 2008 | Randomized cross-over | 10 | Polysomnography, questionnaire | — | 2x 21 days | No | Good |
Woods and Mitchell [132] | 2010 | Cohort | 286 | Self-report diary | Urine | 17 years | Yes | Good |
Zheng et al [133] | 2015 | Cross-sectional | 163 | Wrist actigraphy, diaries | — | 35 days | No | Fair |
Baker et al [134] | 2015 | Case-control | 72 | Polysomnography, diary | Blood | 2 weeks | No | Fair |
Santoro et al [135] | 2016 | Randomized controlled | 727 | Self-report | Blood | 2 years | Yes | Fair |
Slopien et al [136] | 2018 | Cross-sectional | 140 | Questionnaires | Blood | Not stated | No | Fair |
Cintron et al [137] | 2018 | Randomized controlled | 727 | Questionnaire | — | 2 years | Yes | Good |
Geiger et al [138] | 2019 | Placebo-controlled | 172 | Questionnaires, self-report | — | 12 months | Yes | Fair |
Hatcher et al [139] | 2020 | Cohort | 762 | Questionnaire | Blood | 1 year | Yes | Good |
Luo et al [140] | 2020 | Cohort | 458 | Questionnaires | Blood | Recruited in 2005, follow-up ongoing in 2020 | Yes | Good |
as rated by the NIH Quality Assessment Tools.