Table 1.
First author (Year) | Location | Final sample size | Participant characteristics | Intervention description | Types of components |
Effect sizes for Pap test | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Education | Patient navigation | Phone call | Counseling | Systems | Other | ||||||
Blumenthal (2005) | Tennessee and Georgia, USA | 3914 | Age 18+, African American living in predominantly black census tracts of 4 study cities | Educational sessions, mass media campaigning with local partners, and community events | X | Mass media, CBPR | Tenn.: + 2.5% Georg.: − 3.7% |
||||
Braun (2015) | Hawaii, USA | 488 | Age not specified, Asian and Pacific Islander, Medicare beneficiaries | Patient navigators assisted with breast, cervical, colorectal, and prostate screening | X | X | X | + 20.6% | |||
Fernandez (2009) | New Mexico, Texas, and California, USA | 243 | Age 50+, Hispanic, low-income, farmworker, no cancer history, not up-to-date for cervical or breast cancer screening | LHW presented in-home educational session, provided local screening information, and followed-up after 2 weeks | X | Community health worker | + 15.9% | ||||
Maxwell (2003) | California, USA | 530 | Age 40+, Filipino women | Female Filipino health educator led a group educational session and provided information on local facilities and free testing | X | + 4.0% | |||||
Paskett (1999) | North Carolina, USA | 302 | Age 40+, predominantly African American, living in low-income housing communities in the 2 study cities | Educational programs with LHWs (group and individual), targeted mailings, mass media campaigns, and in clinic services (posters, literature, counseling, follow-up) | X | X | X | + 21.0% | |||
Studts (2012) | Kentucky, USA | 345 | Age 40–64, living in rural Appalachian counties in Kentucky, overdue for cervical cancer screening | Educational lunch, home visits with lay health advisor, and newsletters addressing barriers to treatment | X | X | + 7.0% | ||||
Taylor (2002) | Washington, USA and British Columbia, Canada | 482 | Age 20–69, Chinese, living in 2 study cities, under-utilizers of Pap testing, spoke Cantonese, Mandarin or English, no history of cervical cancer, no hysterectomy |
Intervention 1: outreach worker provided tailored counseling and assistance with logistics of screening Intervention 2: direct mail of educational resources |
X | X | Home visits, transportation | + 10.0% + 24.0% |
|||
Taylor (2010) | Washington, USA | 234 | Age 20–79, Vietnamese, speak Vietnamese or English, living in Seattle during study, has a uterus, not up-to-date for Pap test | Vietnamese-American community health workers made home visits, provided education with video and print resources, and addressed cultural barriers to screening | X | X | Community health worker home visit | + 10.0% | |||
Thompson (2016) | Washington, USA | 443 | Age 21–64, Latina, living in the Yakima Valley, seen by one of the FQHCs in the past 5 years, not up-to-date for Pap test, no prior hysterectomy |
Intervention 1: low-intensity intervention, educational video sent to participants’ homes Intervention 2: high-intensity intervention, video plus in-home promo-tora education session |
X | X | + 4.7% + 19.4% |