Table 1.
References | Risk of bias1 | Country | Setting2 | Data source3 | Study design4 | Gender, sex5 | Age in years | Sample size | Individual | Social | Physical | Macro | F, V, FV6 | Consumer behavior | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Consumption, purchase | What, how, where, when | ||||||||||||||
Adenegan et al. (28) | H | Nigeria | U, R | P | CSS | F, M | NR | 200 | ✓ | F, V | Purchase | What | |||
Adeoye et al. (29) | H | Nigeria | U | P | CSS | F, M | 21–60+ | 150 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | V | Purchase | What | |
Amare et al. (30) | L | Ethiopia | U | P | CSS | F, M | 18–65+ | 356 | ✓ | F, V | Consumption | What, how | |||
Amo-Adjei and Kumi-Kyereme (31) | M | Ghana | U, R | S | CSS | F, M | 15–59 | 9,484 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | F, V | Consumption | What | |
Badurally et al. (32) | H | Mauritius | U, R | P | CSS | F, M | NR | 374 | ✓ | ✓ | F, V | Consumption | What | ||
Banwat et al. (33) | H | Nigeria | U | P | CSS | F, M | 18–60+ | 250 | ✓ | FV | Consumption | What | |||
Bhurosy and Jeewon (34) | M | Mauritius | U, R | P | CSS | F | 18–65 | 400 | ✓ | F, V | Consumption | How | |||
Bloomfield et al. (35) | L | Kenya | PU | P | CSS | F, M | 16–64 + | 4,037 | ✓ | FV | Consumption | What | |||
Bosha et al. (36) | M | Ethiopia | R | P | LONGL | F | 20–40 | 578 | ✓ | FV, F, V | Consumption | What | |||
De Filippo et al. (37) | L | Nigeria | U, PU | P | CSS | F, M | 18–65 | 632 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | FV | Consumption | What | |
Demmler et al. (38) | L | Kenya | U | P, S | LONGL | F, M | 18 + | 1,199 | ✓ | FV | Consumption | What | |||
Gelibo et al. (39) | M | Ethiopia | U, R | P | CSS | F, M | 15–69 | 10,260 | ✓ | ✓ | FV | Consumption | What | ||
Hall et al. (40) | L | Tanzania | R | S | LONGL | F, M | NR | 1,256 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | FV, F, V | Consumption | What | |
Jordan et al. (41) | L | Uganda | U, R | P | LONGL | F | 30.95 | 445 | ✓ | FV, F, V | Consumption | What, where | |||
Kabwama et al. (42) | L | Uganda | U, R | S | CSS | F, M | 18–69 | 3,962 | ✓ | ✓ | FV | Consumption | What | ||
Keding et al. (43) | L | Kenya | R | P | LONGL | F | 40.2 (±16.5) | 272 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | FV, F, V | Consumption | What, how, when | |
Keetile et al. (44) | M | Botswana | U, R | S | CSS | F, M | < 24–65+ | 1,178 | ✓ | FV | Consumption | What | |||
Kibr (45) | M | Ethiopia | U | P | CSS | F | 15–49 | 423 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | FV | Consumption | What |
Labadarios et al. (46) | M | South Africa | U, R | P | CSS | F, M | 16 + | 3,287 | ✓ | FV, F, V | Consumption | What | |||
Lagerkvist et al. (47) | M | Ghana | U | P | CSS | F, M | 17–60 | 332 | ✓ | V | Consumption | How*, when | |||
Layade et al. (48) | H | Nigeria | U | P | CSS | F, M | 15–34 | 200 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | FV | Purchase | What | |
Leyna et al. (49) | M | Tanzania | R | P | CSS | F, M | 15-44 | 1,014 | ✓ | F, V | Consumption | How | |||
Lomira et al. (50) | M | Uganda | U, R | P | CSS | F, M | NR | 400 | ✓ | ✓ | FV | Consumption | What | ||
MacIntyre et al. (51) | L | South Africa | U, R | P | CSS | F, M | 15–80 | 1,751 | ✓ | F, V | Consumption | What | |||
Mayén et al. (52) | L | Seychelles | U, R | S | CSS | F, M | 25–64 | 2,476 | ✓ | FV | Consumption | How | |||
Modibedi et al. (53) | M | South Africa | U | P | CSS | F, M | NR | 254 | ✓ | ✓ | V | Consumption | How | ||
Msambichaka et al. (54) | M | Tanzania | SU | S | CSS | F, M | 15–60+ | 7,953 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | FV, F, V | Consumption | What, how | |
Musaiger et al. (55) | M | Sudan | U | P | CSS | F, M | 18–30 | 400 | ✓ | F, V | Consumption | How | |||
Neergheen-Bhujun et al. (56) | M | Mauritius | U, R | P | CSS | F, M | 18–65 + | 675 | ✓ | ✓ | V | Consumption | How | ||
Obayelu et al. (57) | H | Nigeria | U | P | CSS | F, M | < 20–50 + | 100 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | F | Purchase | What | |
Odunitan-Wayas et al.b (58) | M | South Africa | U | P | CSS | F, M | ≥ 18 | 422 | ✓ | FV | Purchase | How | |||
Odunitan-Wayas et al.b (59) | M | South Africa | U | P | CSS | F, M | 18–55+ | 395 | ✓ | ✓ | F, V | Purchase | What | ||
Okop et al. (60) | M | South Africa | U, R | P | CSS | F, M | 30–75 | 535 | ✓ | ✓ | FV | Consumption | What | ||
Onah et al. (61) | M | Uganda, Rwanda, Malawi, Zambia, Mozambique | R | S | CSS | F | 28.95 | 10,041 | ✓ | FV, V | Consumption | What | |||
Oyedele et al. (62) | H | Nigeria | U | P | CSS | F, M | 36.7 ± 9.2 | 311 | ✓ | ✓ | V | Purchase | What | ||
Padrão et al. (63) | L | Mozambique | U, R | P | CSS | F, M | 25–64 | 12,902 | ✓ | F, V | Consumption | How | |||
Padrão et al. (64) | L | Mozambique | U, R | P | CSS | F, M | 25–64 | 3,298 | ✓ | ✓ | F, V | Consumption | What | ||
Peltzer and Pengpid (65) | L | South Africa | U, R | S | CSS | F, M | 15+ | 15,310 | ✓ | F, V | Consumption | What | |||
Peltzer and Promtussananon (66) | M | South Africa | R, PU | P | CSS | F, M | 18–64 | 200 | ✓ | FV | Consumption | What | |||
Pengpid and Peltzer (67) | M | Kenya | U, R | S | CSS | F, M | 18–69 | 4,479 | ✓ | FV, F, V | Consumption | What | |||
Raaijmakers et al. (68) | M | Nigeria | U | P | CSS | F | 18–55 | 1,220 | ✓ | ✓ | V | Consumption | What, how | ||
Ravaoarisoa et al. (69) | L | Madagascar | R | P | LONGL | F | 18–45 | 608 | ✓ | F, V | Consumption | How | |||
Reyes-García et al. (70) | L | Cameroon | R | P | LONGL | F, M | 16+ | 160 | ✓ | FV, F, V | Consumption, Acquisition | What, where | |||
Riha et al. (71) | L | Uganda | R | P, S | CSS | F, M | 13+ | 7,340 | ✓ | FV | Consumption | What | |||
Savy et al. (72) | L | Burkina Faso | R | P | LONGL | F | <20–30+ | 550 | ✓ | FV, F, V | Consumption | What | |||
Sinyolo et al. (73) | M | South Africa | U, R | P, S | CSS | F, M | 45.72 | 20,908 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | F, V | Consumption | What, how | |
Subratty and Jowaheer (74) | H | Mauritius | U, R | P | CSS | F, M | 15–60 | 1,213 | ✓ | F | Consumption | How, when | |||
Tata et al. (75) | M | Cameroon | R | P, S | CSS | F | 29.7 ± 7.032 | 247 | ✓ | FV, F, V | Consumption | What | |||
Thakwalakwa et al. (76) | L | Malawi | U, R | P | LONGL | F | 27.8 ± 6.0 | 274 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | F, V | Consumption | What, when |
Torheim et al. (77) | M | Mali | R | P | CSS | F, M | 15–45 | 491 | ✓ | F | Consumption | What | |||
Unwin et al. (78) | M | Tanzania | U, R | P | LONGL | F, M | 15-59 | 209 | ✓ | F, V | Consumption | What | |||
Wang et al. (79) | H | Ghana | U | P | CSS | F, M | 39.2 | 1,100 | ✓ | ✓ | F | Consumption | How | ||
Yaya and Bishwajit (80) | M | Namibia | U, R | S | CSS | F, M | 15–49 | 14,185 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | FV | Consumption | What |
Risk of bias: H, high; M, moderate; L, low;
Setting: R, rural; U, urban; PU, peri-urban; SU, semi-urban;
Data source: P, primary; S, secondary;
Study design: CSS, Cross-sectional study; LONGL, longitudinal study;
Gender, sex: F, female; M, male;
F;V;FV; F, Fruit; V, Vegetable; FV, Fruit and vegetables combined;
References referring to one study;
How*: referring to how foods were treated before consumption.