Skip to main content
. 2023 Apr 12;31:100492. doi: 10.1016/j.pacs.2023.100492

Table 1.

Comparison of detection sensitivity performance with previous PAS publications.

Species Wavelength
(μm)
Power
(mW)
Integration time MDL NNEA coefficient
(cm−1 W Hz−1/2)
Ref.
CO
CH4
C2H2
1.567
1.617
1.534
< 1 mW
< 1 mW
< 1 mW
2.6 s 249.6 ppm
293.7 ppm
1.5 ppm
3.4 × 10−9
1.4 × 10−9
3.6 × 10−9
[18]
CO
CH4
C2H2
4.69
3.22
1.533
∼15 [W] (broadband)
∼15 [W] (broadband)
15 mW
1 s 40 ppb
150 ppb
200 ppb
\ [21]
CO
CH4
C2H2
1.568
1.529
1.532
1000 (amplified by EDFA)
1000 (amplified by EDFA)
1000 (amplified by EDFA)
1 s 4.6 ppm
87 ppm
1.3 ppb
\ [23]
H2O
C2H2
1.368
1.529
21.2
10
300 ms 49 ppm
11 ppm
9.12 × 10−7
1.51 × 10−7
[28]
H2O
CH4
N2O
1.392
7.707
7.71
6.2
128
128
100 ms 20 ppm
18 ppb
5 ppb
\ [29]
H2O
CH4
CO2
1.396
1.653
1.574
7
2.1
4
181 s
195 s
136 s
1.17 ppm
1.76 ppm
83 ppm
6.03 × 10−10
2.36 × 10−9
5.46 × 10−10
[30]
CO
CH4
C2H2
4.59
3.37
1.52
44
8
32
1 s 89 ppb
80 ppb
664 ppb
5.3 × 10−7
1.9 × 10−8
4.2 × 10−8
This paper