Skip to main content
. 2023 Apr 26;14:103. doi: 10.1186/s13287-023-03331-6

Table 1.

The relationships among the eligible 10 publications

Clinical trial no. First author Publication date Location Follow-up phase (after-treatment)
1 Garcia-Olmo, D. [18] 2009 Spain 8 weeks
Hector, G. [25] 2012 Spain (1) 1 year
(2) 40 months
2 Herreros, M. D. [26] 2012 Spain (1) 12 weeks
(2) 24/26 weeks
(3) 1 year
3 Molendijk, I. [27] 2015 Netherlands (1) 12 weeks
(2) 24 weeks
Barnhoorn, M. C. [28] 2020 Netherlands 4 years
Panés, J. [29] 2016 Seven European countries and Israel 24 weeks
4 Panés, J. [30] 2018 Seven European countries and Israel 52 weeks
Garcia-Olmo, D. [31] 2022 Seven European countries and Israel 104 weeks
5 Garcia-Arranz, M. [32] 2020 Spain (1) 16 weeks
(2) 52 weeks
(3) 2 years
6 Zhou, C. [33] 2020 China (1) 3 months
(2) 6 months
(3) 12 months

aTo avoid bias, the follow-up phase was not adjusted by the same unit like week or month and just presented as 10 publications recording