Table 3.
CPET results of generalized linear mixed model (GLM model) analysis of 40 subjects without mask (NM) and with three different mask types (SM, CM, FFP2).
Pre (light work) | E1 (moderate work) | E2 (heavy work) | E3 (very heavy work) | Post (light work) | ||||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
NM | SM | CM | FFP2 | NM | SM | CM | FFP2 | NM | SM | CM | FFP2 | NM | SM | CM | FFP2 | NM | SM | CM | FFP2 | |
G.M | Δ p value |
G.M | Δ p value |
G.M | Δ p value |
G.M | Δ p value |
G.M | Δ p value |
|||||||||||
Subjects’ perceived physical exertion | ||||||||||||||||||||
BORG (0–10) |
0.81 | − 0.05 | − 0.04 | − 0.18 | 0.96 |
0.05 0.651 |
0.22 0.306 |
0.33 0.022 |
2.14 |
0.33 0.384 |
0.23 0.522 |
0.89 0.008 |
3.68 |
0.59 0.360 |
0.54 0.419 |
1.21 0.016 |
0.88 |
0.11 0.498 |
0.14 0.475 |
0.22 0.064 |
Pulmonary parameters | ||||||||||||||||||||
Ttot (s) |
3.91 | − 0.08 | − 0.04 | 0.18 | 2.95 |
0.08 0.491 |
− 0.01 0.707 |
0.23 0.130 |
2.53 |
0.04 0.251 |
0.00 0.463 |
0.22 0.333 |
2.11 |
0.06 0.171 |
0.08 0.197 |
0.23 0.124 |
2.95 |
0.03 0.399 |
− 0.03 0.944 |
0.11 0.848 |
RR (min−1) |
15.37 | 0.01 | 0.17 | − 0.85 | 20.31 |
− 0.51 0.521 |
0.14 0.918 |
− 1.52 0.610 |
23.71 |
− 0.38 0.670 |
0.01 0.794 |
− 2.04 0.476 |
28.37 |
− 0.76 0.450 |
− 0.97 0.220 |
− 2.70 0.243 |
20.43 |
− 0.38 0.622 |
0.09 0.869 |
− 0.85 0.731 |
VT (L) |
0.90 | 0 | − 0.01 | − 0.02 | 1.64 |
− 0.01 0.948 |
− 0.04 0.662 |
− 0.01 0.518 |
1.98 |
0 0.922 |
− 0.03 0.792 |
0 0.553 |
2.25 |
− 0.01 0.938 |
0 0.720 |
− 0.03 0.353 |
1.25 |
− 0.02 0.709 |
− 0.05 0.440 |
0 0.599 |
VE (L*min−1) | 12.03 | 0.28 | 0.26 | − 0.42 | 31.26 |
− 0.40 0.380 |
− 0.39 0.407 |
− 1.91 0.506 |
45.47 |
− 0.67 0.344 |
− 0.93 0.293 |
− 3.95 0.164 |
62.52 |
− 1.93 0.187 |
− 2.51 0.129 |
− 7.19 0.035 |
23.3 |
− 0.88 0.225 |
− 0.65 0.328 |
− 0.92 0.937 |
VO2 (ml*min−1) | 301.78 | − 27.34 | − 21.06 | − 36.51 | 1050.92 |
− 19.36 0.095 |
− 36.41 0.367 |
− 73.39 0.251 |
1474.55 |
− 21.65 0.067 |
− 33.02 0.217 |
− 92.81 0.168 |
1910.85 |
− 38.02 0.076 |
− 39.58 0.191 |
− 124.26 0.176 |
475.16 |
35.8 0.858 |
43.45 0.838 |
43.78 0.621 |
VCO2 (ml*min−1) |
243.71 | − 20.26 | − 14.02 | − 23.12 | 889.26 |
− 29.53 0.264 |
− 32.85 0.649 |
− 59.74 0.525 |
1361.39 |
− 36.30 0.198 |
− 32.13 0.446 |
− 94.92 0.555 |
1850.06 |
− 42.07 0.184 |
− 38.13 0.424 |
− 122.94 0.520 |
526.86 |
− 48.50 0.881 |
− 40.13 0.759 |
− 36.44 0.668 |
VE/VO2 | 39.87 | 4.96 | 3.89 | 3.87 | 29.74 |
0.17 < 0.001 |
0.68 0.014 |
0.28 0.004 |
30.83 |
0 < 0.001 |
0.07 0.001 |
− 0.79 < 0.001 |
32.71 |
− 0.37 < 0.001 |
− 0.66 < 0.001 |
− 1.76 < 0.001 |
49.03 |
− 5.17 0.086 |
− 5.37 0.116 |
− 5.92 0.096 |
VE/VCO2 | 49.36 | 5.70 | 4.11 | 3.24 | 35.15 |
0.74 < 0.001 |
0.88 0.035 |
0.23 0.030 |
33.39 |
0.41 < 0.001 |
0.11 0.003 |
− 0.62 0.002 |
33.78 |
− 0.27 < 0.001 |
− 0.67 < 0.001 |
− 1.69 < 0.001 |
44.20 |
2.66 0.094 |
2.33 0.343 |
1.43 0.295 |
EELV (L) | 3.98 | 0.20 | 0.37 | 0.02 | 3.88 |
0.06 0.413 |
− 0.01 0.129 |
0.32 0.920 |
3.81 |
0.09 0.758 |
0.15 0.540 |
− 0.10 0.698 |
3.94 |
− 0.30 0.125 |
− 0.29 0.064 |
− 0.43 0.142 |
4.28 |
− 0.06 0.458 |
− 0.38 0.034 |
− 0.71 0.031 |
BR (%) | 10.85 | 0.44 | 0.51 | − 0.13 | 28.15 |
0.16 0.400 |
0.40 0.427 |
− 1.05 0.528 |
40.93 |
0.16 0.365 |
0.27 0.313 |
− 2.59 0.178 |
56.28 |
− 0.70 0.201 |
− 0.78 0.140 |
− 5.19 0.039 |
20.98 |
− 0.41 0.236 |
− 0.03 0.343 |
− 0.31 0.957 |
Metabolic parameters | ||||||||||||||||||||
pH | 7.41 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 | 7.40 |
− 0.01 0.756 |
− 0.01 0.932 |
− 0.01 0.930 |
7.39 |
− 0.01 0.623 |
− 0.01 0.967 |
− 0.01 0.380 |
7.37 |
− 0.02 0.252 |
− 0.01 0.904 |
− 0.02 0.027 |
7.38 |
− 0.01 0.381 |
− 0.01 0.581 |
− 0.01 0.428 |
pCO2 (mmHg) | 36.13 | 0.65 | 0.67 | 1.33 | 37.77 |
0.83 0.845 |
0.53 0.802 |
1.40 0.995 |
37.80 |
0.46 0.748 |
0.31 0.573 |
1.72 0.663 |
35.94 |
1.23 0.397 |
1.05 0.590 |
2.39 0.133 |
33.99 |
0.50 0.866 |
0.65 0.985 |
1.55 0.664 |
pO2 (mmHg) | 90.79 | − 3.58 | − 1.00 | − 2.18 | 92.17 |
− 2.82 0.640 |
− 1.15 0.942 |
− 2.21 0.994 |
91.16 |
− 2.82 0.472 |
− 1.15 0.712 |
− 2.21 0.891 |
89.45 |
− 2.92 0.701 |
− 2.70 0.290 |
− 2.22 0.965 |
94.03 |
− 1.00 0.137 |
− 0.38 0.727 |
− 0.05 0.230 |
Lactate (mmol/L) | 1.22 | 0.00 | 0.01 | 0.04 | 1.61 |
− 0.02 0.774 |
0.01 0.895 |
0.10 0.780 |
2.51 |
0.04 0.896 |
0.00 0.860 |
0.12 0.883 |
4.58 |
0.03 0.987 |
− 0.11 0.616 |
0.09 0.826 |
3.79 |
0.04 0.929 |
− 0.06 0.698 |
0.05 0.761 |
sO2 (%) | 97.17 | − 0.34 | − 0.18 | − 0.33 | 97.27 |
− 0.32 0.947 |
− 0.18 0.959 |
− 0.27 0.730 |
96.87 |
− 0.25 0.643 |
− 0.08 0.603 |
− 0.21 0.531 |
96.72 |
− 0.46 0.528 |
− 0.35 0.382 |
− 0.53 0.309 |
97.17 |
− 0.12 0.282 |
− 0.03 0.474 |
− 0.08 0.209 |
BORG Borg scale, BR Breathing reserve, CM Community mask, CPET Cardiopulmonary exercise test (spiroergometry), Δ Difference to NM, EELV End-expiratory lung volume, FFP2 Filtering face piece class 2, G.M. Geometric mean, NM No mask, pCO2 Partial pressure of carbon dioxide, pO2 Partial pressure of oxygen, pH Potential of hydrogen in blood, RR Respiratory rate, sO2 Haemoglobin oxygen saturation, SM Surgical mask, Tin Inspiratory time, Tex Expiratory time, Ttot Inspiratory and expiratory time, VCO2 Carbon dioxide production, VE Minute ventilation, VE/VCO2 Ventilation per litre of carbon dioxide, VE/VO2 Ventilation per litre of oxygen, VO2 Oxygen uptake, VT Tidal volume.
Masks were tested using the mask adapter (details see Methods). The situation without mask in each specific load level (pre, E1, E2, E3, post) was always used as reference. For NM geometric mean (G.M.), for the three mask types (SM, CM, FFP2) differences (Δ) to NM and p values are shown.
Significant values are in bold.