Skip to main content
. 2023 Mar 23;11(4):818. doi: 10.3390/microorganisms11040818

Table 2.

Characteristics of the analyzed extraction kits on blood specimens and applied pretreatments as DNA extraction strategies.

Kit’s Description Manufacturer Whole Blood Specimens Volume Pretreatment
Method
Detection Limit Species Reference
Automatic kits
EZ1TM DNA Tissue Kit * Qiagen 200 μL - 1400 ng/μL C.glabrata [38]
EZ1TM DNA Tissue Kit * Qiagen 200 μL N2 570 ng/μL C.glabrata [38]
NucliSENSTM EasyMAGTM * Fisher Scientific 200 µL CB
LB
10 CFU/mL Ct < 20 C. albicans
C.glabrata
C.parapsilosis
C.tropicalis C. krusei
[43]
EZ1TM DNA Blood 200 µL Kit * Qiagen 200 µL - 106 CFU/mL [43]
EZ1TM DNA Blood 200 µL Kit * Qiagen 200 µL CB
LB
10 CFU/mL Ct < 20 [43]
EZ1TM DNA Tissue Kit * Qiagen 190 µL LyT 10 CFU/mL Ct < 20 [43]
EZ1TM DNA Tissue Kit * Qiagen 100μL−1 mL - 103 CFU/mL C. albicans [44]
EZ1TM DNA Tissue Kit * Qiagen 100μL−1 mL TTE
LyS
LyT
102 CFU/mL C. albicans [44]
QIAampTM 96DNA QIAcube HT kit * Qiagen 200 μL - 106 CFU/mL C. albicans
C.glabrata
C.parapsilosis
C.tropicalis
C. krusei
[43]
Macherey-Nagel™ Pathogène NucleoMag™ * BioMérieux 150 μL - 106 CFU/mL [43]
Mag-BindTM Viral DNA/RNA kit * Omega Bio-tek 200 μL - 106 CFU/mL [43]
MagMAX™ Viral/
PathogenNucleic Acid Isolation Kit *
Applied Biosystems
MGISP
400 μL - 106 CFU/mL [43]
Chemagic Viral DNA/RNA 300 kit H96 * PerkinElmer 200 μL - 106 CFU/mL [43]
Virus DNA/RNA Extraction Kit * MGI 200 μL - 106 CFU/mL [43]
BioextractTM SuperballTM kit * Biosellal 200 μL - 106 CFU/mL [43]
Maxwell 16 Cell LEV DNA Purification Kit * Promega Co. 100μL−1 mL - 102 CFU/mL C. albicans [44]
Maxwell 16 Cell LEV DNA Purification Kit * Promega Co. 100μL−1 mL TTE
LyS
LyT
102 CFU/mL C. albicans [44]
Maxwell 16 Blood DNA Purification Kit * Promega Co. 100μL−1 mL - 106 CFU/mL C. albicans [44]
Maxwell 16 Blood DNA Purification Kit * Promega Co. 100μL−1 mL TTE
LyS
LyT
102 CFU/mL C. albicans [44]
Manual kits
DNeasy Blood and Tissue * Qiagen 100μL−1 mL - Not detected C. albicans [44]
DNeasy Blood and Tissue * Qiagen 100μL−1 mL TTE
Ammonium chloride
LyS
LyT
Bead Beating
102 CFU/mL C. albicans [44]
QIAamp DNA Blood Min i * Qiagen 100μL−1 mL - 106 CFU/mL C. albicans [44]
QIAamp DNA Blood Mini * Qiagen 100μL−1 mL LyS
LyT
Bead Beating
102 CFU/mL C. albicans [44]
PureLink Genomic DNA Mini * Invitrogen Co 100μL−1 mL - 106 CFU/mL C. albicans [44]
PureLink Genomic DNA Mini * Invitrogen Co 100μL−1 mL LyS
LyT
106 CFU/mL C. albicans [44]
High Pure PCR Template Preparation * Roche Inc. 100μL−1 mL - 106 CFU/mL C. albicans [44]
High Pure PCR Template Preparation * Roche Inc. 100μL−1 mL LyS
LyT
103 CFU/mL C. albicans [44]
UMD-Universal CE IVD * Molzym GmbH & Co. 100μL−1 mL - 101 CFU/mL C. albicans [44]
QIAamp DNA mini kit * Qiagen 2 µL - < 10 ng/μL Candida spp.:
C. albicans
C. glabrata
C. parapsilosis
C. tropicalis
C. famata
C. krusei
C. dubliniensis
C. haemulonii
[41]
QIAamp DNA mini kit * Qiagen 2 µL SDS
β-mercaptoethanol
20 ng/μL [41]
QIAamp DNA mini kit * Qiagen 2 µL glass beads 198 ± 18.9 ng/μL [41]
Chelex-100/boiling Not commercial 200 μL - 104 CFU/mL C. albicans [45]
In-house protocol * Not commercial 50–100 µL guanidinium thiocyanate acid
PK
260 CFU/mL (whole blood)
200 CFU/mL
(serum)
C. albicans [46]
QIAamp DNA Blood Mini * Qiagen 1 mL Polaris (Biocartis) enrichement
LB
1 CFU/mL
Ct < 35
C. albicans [47]
QIAamp DNA Blood Mini * Qiagen 5 mL Polaris (Biocartis) enrichement
LB
1 CFU/mL
Ct < 35
C. albicans [47]
In-house protocol ** - 3 mL TTE
SDS
potasium acetate
centrifugation
cold ethanol
1–10 CFU/mL C. albicans [48]
GeneReleaser ** Eurogentec 3 mL LB
SDS
TTE
β-mercaptoethanol
1–10
CFU/mL
C. albicans [48]
QIAamp Tissue ** Qiagen 3 mL LB
SDS
TTE
β-mercaptoethanol
10 CFU/mL C. albicans [48]
PureGene D 6000 ** Gentra 3 mL LB
SDS
TTE
β-mercaptoethanol
102
CFU/mL
C. albicans [48]
DNAzol ** Sigma 3 mL LB
SDS
TTE
β-mercaptoethanol
103 CFU/mL C. albicans [48]
PKPC Not commercial 400 μL PK
PC
TTE
103 CFU/mL Candida spp. [49]
HLGT Not commercial 400 μL guanidine thiocyanate acid
heat lysis
10 CFU/mL Candida spp. [49]
QIAamp DNA Blood * Qiagen 400 μL - 10
CFU/mL
Candida spp. [49]
High Pure PCR Template Preparation * Roche Inc. 400 μL - 102
CFU/mL
Candida spp. [49]
DNAzol * Sigma 400 μL - 104
CFU/mL
Candida spp. [49]
QIAamp DNA mini kit * Qiagen 1 mL LyT 96 ± 21 C. albicans [31]
QIAamp DNA mini kit * Qiagen 1 mL glass beads 89 ± 44 C. albicans [31]
MasterPure yeast DNA purification kit * Epicentre 1 mL TTE 215 ± 109 C. albicans [31]
BAGH * Not commercial 1 mL benzyl alcohol
guanidine hydrochloride
TTE
33 ± 42 C. albicans [31]
Dr GenTle (gene trapping by liquid extraction) * Takara Bio 1 mL TTE 36 ± 18 C. albicans [31]
yeast DNA extraction reagent (Y-DER) * Pierce Biotechnology 1 mL TTE 23 ± 10 C. albicans [31]
YeaStar genomic DNA kit * Zymo Research 1 mL TTE 11 ± 4 C. albicans [31]

TTE = Triton-Tris-EDTA (20 mM Tris-HCl [pH 8.3], 1 mM EDTA, and 1% Triton), PK = proteinase K, LyS = lysozyme, LyT = lyticase, CB = ceramic beads, LB = lysis buffer, N2= liquid nitrogen maceration. * the study involved blood samples from healthy patients spiked with fungal cells, ** samples from neutropenic patients suspected or diagnosed with systemic candidiasis.