[Preprint]. 2023 Jun 20:2023.04.18.537240. Originally published 2023 Apr 19. [Version 2] doi: 10.1101/2023.04.18.537240

Table 2.

Strategies examined in the benchmark and associated parameters applied to load_confounds

strategy	image	`high_pass`	`motion`	`wm_csf`	`global_signal`	`scrub`	`fd_thresh (mm)`	`compcor mask`	`n_compcor`	`ica_aroma`	`demean`
baseline	`desc-preproc_bold`	`True`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`True`
simple	`desc-preproc_bold`	`True`	`full`	`basic`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`True`
simple+gsr	`desc-preproc_bold`	`True`	`full`	`basic`	`basic`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`True`
scrubbing.5	`desc-preproc_bold`	`True`	`full`	`full`	`N/A`	`5`	`0.5`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`True`
scrubbing.5+gsr	`desc-preproc_bold`	`True`	`full`	`full`	`basic`	`5`	`0.5`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`True`
scrubbing.2	`desc-preproc_bold`	`True`	`full`	`full`	`N/A`	`5`	`0.2`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`True`
scrubbing.2+gsr	`desc-preproc_bold`	`True`	`full`	`full`	`basic`	`5`	`0.2`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`True`
compcor	`desc-preproc_bold`	`True`	`full`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`anat_combined`	`all` ^*	`N/A`	`True`
compcor6	`desc-preproc_bold`	`True`	`full`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`anat_combined`	`6`	`N/A`	`True`
aroma^**	`desc-smoothAROMAnonaggr_bold`	`True`	`N/A`	`basic`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`N/A`	`full` ^***	`True`

50% variance explained.

^**

In Ciric et al. (2017), there was a variation of the ICA-AROMA strategy including global signal regressor. The global signal regressor generated by fMRIPrep does not follow the recommendation of Pruim et al. (2015). The result of ICA-AROMA+GSR can be found in the first version of the preprint.

^***

Referring to the non-aggressive implementation in Pruim and colleagues’ work (2015)