Aass 2005 |
Irrelevant interventions (interferon alfa‐2a with/without 13‐cis‐retinoic acid). |
Abdel 2018 |
Wrong study design (single‐arm) and wrong patient population (recurrent/refractory). |
Adler 1987 |
Irrelevant interventions (hormono‐immuno‐ versus hormonotherapy). |
Amin 2018 |
CheckMate 016 study. Wrong study design (non‐randomised). |
Amin 2018a |
CheckMate 016 study. Wrong study design (non‐randomised). |
Atkins 1991 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon vs. interleukin). |
Atkins 1993 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon vs. interleukin). |
Atzpodien 1997 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin vs. interferon and 5‐fluorouracil). |
Atzpodien 1997a |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin vs. interferon and 5‐fluorouracil). |
Atzpodien 1999 |
Irrelevant comparison (13‐cis‐retinoic acid, IFN‐alpha, IL‐2 and chemotherapy). |
Atzpodien 2001 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon+interleuking and 5‐FU versus tamoxifen). |
Atzpodien 2004 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin vs. interferon). |
Atzpodien 2006 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2/interferon‐alpha2a/13‐retinoic acid‐based chemoimmunotherapy). |
Barrios 2009 |
Wrong study design (single‐group assignment). |
Beaumont 2009 |
RECORD‐1 study. Second‐line treatment. |
Beaumont 2011 |
RECORD‐1 study. Second‐line treatment. |
Berg 1998 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin versus interferon alpha‐2A). |
Bex 2017 |
Irrelevant intervention (nephrectomy). |
Boccardo 1998 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin versus interferon alpha‐2A). |
Bracarda 2007 |
Wrong study design (same intervention, different schedules). |
Buckley 2019 |
PRISM study. Dose‐finding study. |
Cella 2016 |
Checkmate025 study. Second‐line treatment. |
Choueiri 2017 |
Prior therapy allowed (more than 10% of patients). |
Choueiri 2020 |
Prior therapy allowed (more than 10% of patients). |
Choueiri 2020a |
Prior therapy allowed (more than 10% of patients). |
Cirkel 2016 |
Wrong study design (rotating treatments). |
Cirkel 2017 |
ROPETAR study. Wrong study design (rotating treatments). |
Climent 2020 |
ROPETAR study. Wrong study design (rotating treatments). |
Cole 2003 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin versus interferon alpha‐2A). |
Collinson 2012 |
STAR Trial. Irrelevant comparison (sunitinib; temporary cessation versus continuation). |
Collinson 2018 |
PRISM. Dose‐finding study. |
Colomba 2021 |
Wrong study design (single‐group assignment). |
Conter 2013 |
Wrong study design (dose‐finding study). |
de Mulder 1991 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon versus interleukin). |
Demirci 1999 |
Irrelevant interventions (vinblastine and interferon alpha with 5‐flourouracil). |
Dexeus 1988 |
Irrelevant comparison (chemotherapy versus interferon). |
Dexeus 1989 |
Irrelevant comparison (chemotherapy versus interferon). |
DRKS00010309 2016 |
TAURUS. Terminated study. |
Dubois 1997 |
Irrelevant comparator (p75 tumour necrosis factor receptor immunoglobulin G chimera). |
Eisen 2019 |
Irrelevant intervention (adjuvant therapy). |
Elhilali 2000 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon vs. placebo). |
Epaillard 2020 |
Wrong study design (biomarker‐driven trial). |
Escudier 2005 |
Irrelevant comparator. |
Euctr 2006‐003429‐95‐ES |
Wrong study design (non‐randomised). |
Euctr2006‐002851‐33‐AT |
Ended prematurely. |
Euctr2006‐005751‐16‐NL |
Study ended prematurely. |
Euctr2007‐002556‐41‐AT |
Irrelevant comparison (trivax (cancer vaccine) with sunitinib versus sunitinib alone). |
EUCTR2008‐002667‐13‐DE 2008 |
Adjuvant setting. |
Euctr2012‐001730‐33‐ES |
Study ended prematurely. |
Euctr2015‐002133‐22‐FR |
Irrelevant intervention(s). |
Euctr2018‐001495‐38‐FR |
Study ended prematurely. |
Feldman 2020 |
Wrong study design (cohort study). |
Feldman 2020a |
Wrong study design (cohort study). |
Figlin 1998 |
Irrelevant comparison (CD8(+) tumour‐infiltrating lymphocytes in combination with recombinant interleukin‐2). |
Figlin 1999 |
Irrelevant comparison (CD8(+) tumor‐infiltrating lymphocytes in combination with recombinant interleukin‐2). |
Figlin 2014 |
ADAPT trial. Terminated (no results). |
Figlin 2014a |
ADAPT trial. Terminated (no results). |
Figlin 2017 |
ADAPT trial. Terminated (no results). |
Figlin 2018 |
ADAPT trial. Terminated (no results). |
Figlin 2020 |
ADAPT trial. Terminated (no results). |
Flaherty 2015 |
Prior therapy allowed. |
Foon 1988 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon alpha(2B)‐interferon/gamma‐ interferon or the combination). |
Fossa 1989 |
Irrelevant comparison (recombinant interferon‐alpha with or without vinblastine). |
Fossa 1992 |
Irrelevant comparison (recombinant interferon‐alpha with or without vinblastine). |
Gao 2017 |
Prior therapy allowed. |
Gao 2019 |
Prior therapy allowed. |
Gedye 2021 |
Wrong study design (single‐group assignment). |
Ghiorghiu 2018 |
More than 10% received prior therapy. |
Gleave 1997 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon gamma‐1b injection versus placebo). |
Gleave 1997a |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon gamma‐1b injection versus placebo). |
Gleave 1998 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon gamma‐1b injection versus placebo). |
Gore 2008 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon‐a (IFN), interleukin‐2 (IL2) and 5‐fluorouracil (5FU) vs IFN alone). |
Gore 2010 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon‐a (IFN), interleukin‐2 (IL2) and 5‐fluorouracil (5FU) vs IFN alone). |
Gruenwald 2020 |
Irrelevant intervention (behavioral intervention, concomitant coaching). |
Haas 2016 |
Wrong intervention (adjuvant therapy). |
Hainsworth 2015 |
Irrelevant comparator (CXCR4 inhibitor LY2510924). |
Hainsworth 2016 |
Irrelevant comparator (CXCR4 inhibitor LY2510924). |
Han 2002 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 versus subcutaneous interleukin‐2/interferon). |
Harima 1990 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon‐alpha (IFN) plus fluoropyrimidine (FP) and IFN alone). |
Henriksson 1998 |
Irrelevant comparison (tamoxifen vs interleukin 2, alpha‐interferon (leucocyte) and tamoxifen). |
Hutson 2006 |
Wrong study design (discontinuation design) and wrong patient population (recurrent). |
Hutson 2021 |
CheckMate 920 trial. Wrong study design (non‐randomised). |
ISRCTN95351638 |
PRISM. Dose‐finding study. |
Jager 2005 |
Second‐line therapy. |
Jayson 1998 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin 2 and interleukin 2‐interferon alpha). |
Jeon 1999 |
Wrong study design (cohort study). |
JPRN‐JapicCTI‐122014 |
Prior therapy allowed. |
JPRN‐jRCTs031180024 |
Irrelevant comparison (nivolumab combined with image‐guided three dimensional beam‐convergent and extremely hypofractionated radiotherapy). |
JPRN‐UMIN000001995 |
Prior therapy allowed. |
Kinouchi 2004 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon‐alpha (IFN) versus IFN + cimetidine). |
Kinouchi 2006 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon‐alpha (IFN) versus IFN + cimetidine). |
Larkin 2019 |
KEYNOTE‐427. Wrong study design (non‐randomised). |
Law 1995 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 with or without lymphokine‐ activated killer cells). |
Lee 2020 |
KEYNOTE‐427. Wrong study design (non‐randomised). |
Lee 2021 |
Wrong study design (cohort study). |
Lindskog 2020 |
Irrelevant comparison (ilixadencel plus sunitinib versus sunitinib alone). |
Lissoni 1993 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 subcutaneous immunotherapy versus interleukin‐2 plus interferon‐alpha). |
Liu 2012 |
Irrelevant comparison (autologous CIK cell immunotherapy versus interleukin‐2 treatment combination with IFN‐α‐2a). |
Lummen 1996 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon‐gamma versus interleukin‐2 and interferon‐alpha2b). |
Madhusudan 2004 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon alpha alone or in combination with thalidomide). |
McDermott 2001 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 versus interleuking + interferon). |
McDermott 2005 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 versus interleukin + interferon). |
McDermott 2013 |
BEST trial. Prior therapy allowed. |
McDermott 2020 |
KEYNOTE‐427. Wrong study design (non‐randomised). |
Mickisch 2001 |
Irrelevant comparison (radical nephrectomy plus interferon‐alfa‐based immunotherapy compared with interferon alfa alone). |
Minasian 1993 |
Wrong study design (cohort study). |
Molina 2009 |
RECORD‐1 study. Prior therapy allowed. |
Motzer 2001 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐12 versus interferon‐alpha2a). |
Mulders 2012 |
Prior therapy (50% of patients). |
Naglieri 1998 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 (IL‐2) and interferon‐alpha immunotherapy versus an IL‐2 and 4‐epirubicin immuno‐chemotherapy). |
NCT00002737 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon alfa plus isotretinoin versus interferon alfa alone). |
NCT00005966 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon‐alfa2b alone versus interferon‐alfa2b plus thalidomide). |
NCT00019539 |
Irrelvant comparison (bevacizumab versus thalidomide) and prior therapy allowed. |
NCT00027664 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon alfa with thalidomide versus interferon alfa alone). |
NCT00053820 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 and fluorouracil versus interferon alfa alone). |
NCT00073307 |
Second‐line therapy. |
NCT00100906 |
Irrelevant interventions and dose‐finding study. |
NCT00378703 |
One line of prior therapy was allowed. |
NCT00416871 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin infusion versus interleukin by injection). |
NCT00467025 |
Irrelevant intervention (AMG386). |
NCT00491738 |
SABRE‐R study. Terminated (no results). |
NCT00709995 |
Phase II not conducted. |
NCT00835978 |
Dose‐finding study. |
NCT00873236 |
Study ended prematurely. |
NCT01164228 |
Irrelevant comparison (sunitinib with or without gemcitabine hydrochloride). |
NCT01223027 |
Second‐line treatment. |
NCT01408004 |
Wrong study design (efficacy of rotating regimen). |
NCT01444807 |
Wrong study design (single‐group assignment). |
NCT01616186 |
Study withdrawn. |
NCT01664182 |
Second‐line therapy. |
NCT01673386 |
Study terminated (no results). |
NCT01727089 |
Second‐line therapy. |
NCT01727336 |
Second‐line therapy. |
NCT01793636 |
Second‐line therapy. |
NCT02014636 |
Phase II (randomised part) not conducted. |
NCT02127710 |
Wrong study design (single‐group assignment). |
NCT02667886 |
Second‐line therapy. |
NCT02724020 |
Second‐line therapy. |
NCT02960906 |
Wrong‐study design (BIOmarker‐driven trial). |
NCT03035630 |
Study terminated (no results). |
NCT03092856 |
Second‐line therapy. |
NCT03095040 |
Second‐line therapy. |
NCT03173560 |
Dose‐finding study. |
NCT03501381 |
Second‐line therapy. |
NCT03595124 |
Second‐line therapy. |
NCT03829111 |
Irrelevant intervention (probiotics in addition to nivolumab and ipilimumab). |
NCT04195750 |
Second‐line therapy. |
NCT04300140 |
Second‐line therapy. |
Negrier 1996 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 versus interferon alfa). |
Negrier 1997 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 and interferon with or without fluorouracil). |
Negrier 1998 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 versus interferon alfa). |
Negrier 2000 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 and interferon with or without fluorouracil). |
Negrier 2006 |
Irrelevant comparison (intravenous interleukin versus subcutaneous interleukin). |
Negrier 2007 |
Irrelevant comparison (medroxyprogesterone with interferon alfa‐2a or interleukin 2 versus a combination of both). |
Negrier 2008 |
Irrelevant comparison (intravenous interleukin versus subcutaneous interleukin). |
Nosov 2010 |
Wrong study design (randomised discontinuation trial). |
Nosov 2012 |
Wrong study design (randomised discontinuation trial). |
Pal 2015 |
Second‐line therapy. |
Pal 2021a |
Second‐line therapy. |
Passalacqua 2010 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 versus interferon‐alpha). |
Plimack 2015 |
Wrong study design (dose‐finding study). |
Pyrhonen 1995 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon alfa‐2a with vinblastine versus vinblastine alone). |
Pyrhonen 1996 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon alfa‐2a with vinblastine versus vinblastine alone). |
Pyrhonen 1999 |
Irrelevant comparison (interferon alfa‐2a with vinblastine versus vinblastine alone). |
Ravaud 2006 |
Full‐text not available; inclusion criteria unclear. |
Ravaud 2016 |
Adjuvant therapy. |
Rexer 2017 |
Terminated study. |
Richards 1977 |
Irrelevant interventions (chemotherapy). |
Rini 2011 |
Irrelevant comparator (AMG 386). |
Rini 2012 |
Irrelevant comparator (AMG 386). |
Rodriguez‐Vida 2020 |
Terminated study (no results). |
Rpcec 2017 |
Irrelevant comparison (HeberFERON intravenous versus HeberFERON subcutaneous). |
Sternberg 2013 |
Wrong study design (cohort study) and wrong study population (refractory). |
Szarek 2021 |
Second‐line treatment. |
Tannir 2016 |
Terminated study. |
Taylor 2020 |
Wrong study design (single‐group assignment) and wrong patient population (selected solid Tumours). |
Taylor 2020a |
Wrong study design (single‐group assignment) and wrong patient population (selected solid Tumours). |
Thiam 2010 |
RECORD‐1 study. Second‐line treatment. |
Trump 2004 |
Irrelevant comparison (subcutaneous interferon alfa‐2a, subcutaneous interleukin‐2 and intravenous fluorouracil versus oral 13‐cis‐retinoic acid versus IFN‐alpha‐2a and vinblastine.). |
Twardowski 2015 |
Prior therapy allowed (more than 10% with prior therapy). |
Twardowski 2017 |
Prior therapy allowed (more than 10% with prior therapy). |
Verzoni 2018 |
Irrelevant comparator (cytoreductive nephrectomy). |
Voss 2015 |
Wrong study design (single‐group assignment). |
Voss 2019 |
Second‐line therapy (1–3 prior therapy lines). |
Witte 1995 |
Irrelevant comparison (interleukin versus interferon). |
Wood 2013 |
ADAPT study. Terminated (no results). |
Wright 2020 |
Second‐line therapy. |
Yang 2002 |
Prior therapy (majority of patients). |
Yang 2003 |
Prior therapy (majority of patients). |
Zhou 2016 |
Prior chemotherapy (13% of patients). |
Zhou 2019 |
Prior chemotherapy (13% of patients). |