Skip to main content
. 2023 May 4;2023(5):CD013798. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013798.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Aass 2005 Irrelevant interventions (interferon alfa‐2a with/without 13‐cis‐retinoic acid).
Abdel 2018 Wrong study design (single‐arm) and wrong patient population (recurrent/refractory).
Adler 1987 Irrelevant interventions (hormono‐immuno‐ versus hormonotherapy).
Amin 2018 CheckMate 016 study. Wrong study design (non‐randomised).
Amin 2018a CheckMate 016 study. Wrong study design (non‐randomised).
Atkins 1991 Irrelevant comparison (interferon vs. interleukin).
Atkins 1993 Irrelevant comparison (interferon vs. interleukin).
Atzpodien 1997 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin vs. interferon and 5‐fluorouracil).
Atzpodien 1997a Irrelevant comparison (interleukin vs. interferon and 5‐fluorouracil).
Atzpodien 1999 Irrelevant comparison (13‐cis‐retinoic acid, IFN‐alpha, IL‐2 and chemotherapy).
Atzpodien 2001 Irrelevant comparison (interferon+interleuking and 5‐FU versus tamoxifen).
Atzpodien 2004 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin vs. interferon).
Atzpodien 2006 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2/interferon‐alpha2a/13‐retinoic acid‐based chemoimmunotherapy).
Barrios 2009 Wrong study design (single‐group assignment).
Beaumont 2009 RECORD‐1 study. Second‐line treatment.
Beaumont 2011 RECORD‐1 study. Second‐line treatment.
Berg 1998 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin versus interferon alpha‐2A).
Bex 2017 Irrelevant intervention (nephrectomy).
Boccardo 1998 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin versus interferon alpha‐2A).
Bracarda 2007 Wrong study design (same intervention, different schedules).
Buckley 2019 PRISM study. Dose‐finding study.
Cella 2016 Checkmate025 study. Second‐line treatment.
Choueiri 2017 Prior therapy allowed (more than 10% of patients).
Choueiri 2020 Prior therapy allowed (more than 10% of patients).
Choueiri 2020a Prior therapy allowed (more than 10% of patients).
Cirkel 2016 Wrong study design (rotating treatments).
Cirkel 2017 ROPETAR study. Wrong study design (rotating treatments).
Climent 2020 ROPETAR study. Wrong study design (rotating treatments).
Cole 2003 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin versus interferon alpha‐2A).
Collinson 2012 STAR Trial. Irrelevant comparison (sunitinib; temporary cessation versus continuation).
Collinson 2018 PRISM. Dose‐finding study.
Colomba 2021 Wrong study design (single‐group assignment).
Conter 2013 Wrong study design (dose‐finding study).
de Mulder 1991 Irrelevant comparison (interferon versus interleukin).
Demirci 1999 Irrelevant interventions (vinblastine and interferon alpha with 5‐flourouracil).
Dexeus 1988 Irrelevant comparison (chemotherapy versus interferon).
Dexeus 1989 Irrelevant comparison (chemotherapy versus interferon).
DRKS00010309 2016 TAURUS. Terminated study.
Dubois 1997 Irrelevant comparator (p75 tumour necrosis factor receptor immunoglobulin G chimera).
Eisen 2019 Irrelevant intervention (adjuvant therapy).
Elhilali 2000 Irrelevant comparison (interferon vs. placebo).
Epaillard 2020 Wrong study design (biomarker‐driven trial).
Escudier 2005 Irrelevant comparator.
Euctr 2006‐003429‐95‐ES Wrong study design (non‐randomised).
Euctr2006‐002851‐33‐AT Ended prematurely.
Euctr2006‐005751‐16‐NL Study ended prematurely.
Euctr2007‐002556‐41‐AT Irrelevant comparison (trivax (cancer vaccine) with sunitinib versus sunitinib alone).
EUCTR2008‐002667‐13‐DE 2008 Adjuvant setting.
Euctr2012‐001730‐33‐ES Study ended prematurely.
Euctr2015‐002133‐22‐FR Irrelevant intervention(s).
Euctr2018‐001495‐38‐FR Study ended prematurely.
Feldman 2020 Wrong study design (cohort study).
Feldman 2020a Wrong study design (cohort study).
Figlin 1998 Irrelevant comparison (CD8(+) tumour‐infiltrating lymphocytes in combination with recombinant interleukin‐2).
Figlin 1999 Irrelevant comparison (CD8(+) tumor‐infiltrating lymphocytes in combination with recombinant interleukin‐2).
Figlin 2014 ADAPT trial. Terminated (no results).
Figlin 2014a ADAPT trial. Terminated (no results).
Figlin 2017 ADAPT trial. Terminated (no results).
Figlin 2018 ADAPT trial. Terminated (no results).
Figlin 2020 ADAPT trial. Terminated (no results).
Flaherty 2015 Prior therapy allowed.
Foon 1988 Irrelevant comparison (interferon alpha(2B)‐interferon/gamma‐ interferon or the combination).
Fossa 1989 Irrelevant comparison (recombinant interferon‐alpha with or without vinblastine).
Fossa 1992 Irrelevant comparison (recombinant interferon‐alpha with or without vinblastine).
Gao 2017 Prior therapy allowed.
Gao 2019 Prior therapy allowed.
Gedye 2021 Wrong study design (single‐group assignment).
Ghiorghiu 2018 More than 10% received prior therapy.
Gleave 1997 Irrelevant comparison (interferon gamma‐1b injection versus placebo).
Gleave 1997a Irrelevant comparison (interferon gamma‐1b injection versus placebo).
Gleave 1998 Irrelevant comparison (interferon gamma‐1b injection versus placebo).
Gore 2008 Irrelevant comparison (interferon‐a (IFN), interleukin‐2 (IL2) and 5‐fluorouracil (5FU) vs IFN alone).
Gore 2010 Irrelevant comparison (interferon‐a (IFN), interleukin‐2 (IL2) and 5‐fluorouracil (5FU) vs IFN alone).
Gruenwald 2020 Irrelevant intervention (behavioral intervention, concomitant coaching).
Haas 2016 Wrong intervention (adjuvant therapy).
Hainsworth 2015 Irrelevant comparator (CXCR4 inhibitor LY2510924).
Hainsworth 2016 Irrelevant comparator (CXCR4 inhibitor LY2510924).
Han 2002 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 versus subcutaneous interleukin‐2/interferon).
Harima 1990 Irrelevant comparison (interferon‐alpha (IFN) plus fluoropyrimidine (FP) and IFN alone).
Henriksson 1998 Irrelevant comparison (tamoxifen vs interleukin 2, alpha‐interferon (leucocyte) and tamoxifen).
Hutson 2006 Wrong study design (discontinuation design) and wrong patient population (recurrent).
Hutson 2021 CheckMate 920 trial. Wrong study design (non‐randomised).
ISRCTN95351638 PRISM. Dose‐finding study.
Jager 2005 Second‐line therapy.
Jayson 1998 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin 2 and interleukin 2‐interferon alpha).
Jeon 1999 Wrong study design (cohort study).
JPRN‐JapicCTI‐122014 Prior therapy allowed.
JPRN‐jRCTs031180024 Irrelevant comparison (nivolumab combined with image‐guided three dimensional beam‐convergent and extremely hypofractionated radiotherapy).
JPRN‐UMIN000001995 Prior therapy allowed.
Kinouchi 2004 Irrelevant comparison (interferon‐alpha (IFN) versus IFN + cimetidine).
Kinouchi 2006 Irrelevant comparison (interferon‐alpha (IFN) versus IFN + cimetidine).
Larkin 2019 KEYNOTE‐427. Wrong study design (non‐randomised).
Law 1995 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 with or without lymphokine‐ activated killer cells).
Lee 2020 KEYNOTE‐427. Wrong study design (non‐randomised).
Lee 2021 Wrong study design (cohort study).
Lindskog 2020 Irrelevant comparison (ilixadencel plus sunitinib versus sunitinib alone).
Lissoni 1993 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 subcutaneous immunotherapy versus interleukin‐2 plus interferon‐alpha).
Liu 2012 Irrelevant comparison (autologous CIK cell immunotherapy versus interleukin‐2 treatment combination with IFN‐α‐2a).
Lummen 1996 Irrelevant comparison (interferon‐gamma versus interleukin‐2 and interferon‐alpha2b).
Madhusudan 2004 Irrelevant comparison (interferon alpha alone or in combination with thalidomide).
McDermott 2001 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 versus interleuking + interferon).
McDermott 2005 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 versus interleukin + interferon).
McDermott 2013 BEST trial. Prior therapy allowed.
McDermott 2020 KEYNOTE‐427. Wrong study design (non‐randomised).
Mickisch 2001 Irrelevant comparison (radical nephrectomy plus interferon‐alfa‐based immunotherapy compared with interferon alfa alone).
Minasian 1993 Wrong study design (cohort study).
Molina 2009 RECORD‐1 study. Prior therapy allowed.
Motzer 2001 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐12 versus interferon‐alpha2a).
Mulders 2012 Prior therapy (50% of patients).
Naglieri 1998 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 (IL‐2) and interferon‐alpha immunotherapy versus an IL‐2 and 4‐epirubicin immuno‐chemotherapy).
NCT00002737 Irrelevant comparison (interferon alfa plus isotretinoin versus interferon alfa alone).
NCT00005966 Irrelevant comparison (interferon‐alfa2b alone versus interferon‐alfa2b plus thalidomide).
NCT00019539 Irrelvant comparison (bevacizumab versus thalidomide) and prior therapy allowed.
NCT00027664 Irrelevant comparison (interferon alfa with thalidomide versus interferon alfa alone).
NCT00053820 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 and fluorouracil versus interferon alfa alone).
NCT00073307 Second‐line therapy.
NCT00100906 Irrelevant interventions and dose‐finding study.
NCT00378703 One line of prior therapy was allowed.
NCT00416871 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin infusion versus interleukin by injection).
NCT00467025 Irrelevant intervention (AMG386).
NCT00491738 SABRE‐R study. Terminated (no results).
NCT00709995 Phase II not conducted.
NCT00835978 Dose‐finding study.
NCT00873236 Study ended prematurely.
NCT01164228 Irrelevant comparison (sunitinib with or without gemcitabine hydrochloride).
NCT01223027 Second‐line treatment.
NCT01408004 Wrong study design (efficacy of rotating regimen).
NCT01444807 Wrong study design (single‐group assignment).
NCT01616186 Study withdrawn.
NCT01664182 Second‐line therapy.
NCT01673386 Study terminated (no results).
NCT01727089 Second‐line therapy.
NCT01727336 Second‐line therapy.
NCT01793636 Second‐line therapy.
NCT02014636 Phase II (randomised part) not conducted.
NCT02127710 Wrong study design (single‐group assignment).
NCT02667886 Second‐line therapy.
NCT02724020 Second‐line therapy.
NCT02960906 Wrong‐study design (BIOmarker‐driven trial).
NCT03035630 Study terminated (no results).
NCT03092856 Second‐line therapy.
NCT03095040 Second‐line therapy.
NCT03173560 Dose‐finding study.
NCT03501381 Second‐line therapy.
NCT03595124 Second‐line therapy.
NCT03829111 Irrelevant intervention (probiotics in addition to nivolumab and ipilimumab).
NCT04195750 Second‐line therapy.
NCT04300140 Second‐line therapy.
Negrier 1996 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 versus interferon alfa).
Negrier 1997 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 and interferon with or without fluorouracil).
Negrier 1998 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 versus interferon alfa).
Negrier 2000 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 and interferon with or without fluorouracil).
Negrier 2006 Irrelevant comparison (intravenous interleukin versus subcutaneous interleukin).
Negrier 2007 Irrelevant comparison (medroxyprogesterone with interferon alfa‐2a or interleukin 2 versus a combination of both).
Negrier 2008 Irrelevant comparison (intravenous interleukin versus subcutaneous interleukin).
Nosov 2010 Wrong study design (randomised discontinuation trial).
Nosov 2012 Wrong study design (randomised discontinuation trial).
Pal 2015 Second‐line therapy.
Pal 2021a Second‐line therapy.
Passalacqua 2010 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin‐2 versus interferon‐alpha).
Plimack 2015 Wrong study design (dose‐finding study).
Pyrhonen 1995 Irrelevant comparison (interferon alfa‐2a with vinblastine versus vinblastine alone).
Pyrhonen 1996 Irrelevant comparison (interferon alfa‐2a with vinblastine versus vinblastine alone).
Pyrhonen 1999 Irrelevant comparison (interferon alfa‐2a with vinblastine versus vinblastine alone).
Ravaud 2006 Full‐text not available; inclusion criteria unclear.
Ravaud 2016 Adjuvant therapy.
Rexer 2017 Terminated study.
Richards 1977 Irrelevant interventions (chemotherapy).
Rini 2011 Irrelevant comparator (AMG 386).
Rini 2012 Irrelevant comparator (AMG 386).
Rodriguez‐Vida 2020 Terminated study (no results).
Rpcec 2017 Irrelevant comparison (HeberFERON intravenous versus HeberFERON subcutaneous).
Sternberg 2013 Wrong study design (cohort study) and wrong study population (refractory).
Szarek 2021 Second‐line treatment.
Tannir 2016 Terminated study.
Taylor 2020 Wrong study design (single‐group assignment) and wrong patient population (selected solid Tumours).
Taylor 2020a Wrong study design (single‐group assignment) and wrong patient population (selected solid Tumours).
Thiam 2010 RECORD‐1 study. Second‐line treatment.
Trump 2004 Irrelevant comparison (subcutaneous interferon alfa‐2a, subcutaneous interleukin‐2 and intravenous fluorouracil versus oral 13‐cis‐retinoic acid versus IFN‐alpha‐2a and vinblastine.).
Twardowski 2015 Prior therapy allowed (more than 10% with prior therapy).
Twardowski 2017 Prior therapy allowed (more than 10% with prior therapy).
Verzoni 2018 Irrelevant comparator (cytoreductive nephrectomy).
Voss 2015 Wrong study design (single‐group assignment).
Voss 2019 Second‐line therapy (1–3 prior therapy lines).
Witte 1995 Irrelevant comparison (interleukin versus interferon).
Wood 2013 ADAPT study. Terminated (no results).
Wright 2020 Second‐line therapy.
Yang 2002 Prior therapy (majority of patients).
Yang 2003 Prior therapy (majority of patients).
Zhou 2016 Prior chemotherapy (13% of patients).
Zhou 2019 Prior chemotherapy (13% of patients).