Skip to main content
. 2023 May 11:1–41. Online ahead of print. doi: 10.1007/s11042-023-15443-5

Table 2.

Recent work with sensor-based and vision-based inputs

Ref. Year Key contributions Input type Advantages Disadvantages Dataset used Technique
[32] 2021 comprehensive dataset intended to evaluate passive Human Activity Recognition (HAR) and localization techniques with measurements obtained from synchronized Radio-Frequency (RF) devices and vision-based sensors Sensor, Vision Captures transitioning of activities too. Like walking to falling Spectrograms may differ in most realistic scenarios as the human motions might not be restricted to a single aspect angle with respect to the radar. It could be due to the shadowing of some part of the human body if captured at a different angle Gathered during experiment ML techniques
[28] 2021 integrated system prototype that provides an efficient technological tool to caregivers operating promptly and ensures efficient performance throughout the entire healthcare system process Sensor Takes care of situations where the elderly are to be monitored every time without the use of expensive cameras etc Sensor placements Wireless Sensor Data Mining (WISDN) dataset in Jennifer R. Kwapisz et al. t. [153]. Localization using CNN
[214] 2021 Joint tracking and activity recognition in indoor environment using radar sensors Radar sensors Placement of sensors even in sensitive areas is not a privacy concern

Boundary error

Data representation

Imbalanced dataset

Loss function

Collect own dataset using the setup uses K-fold method as dataset is limited Deep learning
[146] 2021 (HAR) based on Radio Frequency energy harvesting (RFEH) as the harvested voltage signals of different human activities exhibit distinctive patterns. Radio frequency Accuracy and computational efficiency

Interference from other wifi devices

Complex activities and variety of ways in which one may perform them.

Gathered dataset

performance of the system by applying the four light-weight classifiers and calculating their accuracies on the collected datasets

Machine learning classifiers
[51] 2021 HAR for indoor using channel information of wifi signals Wifi signals Cost-effective as wifi devices are mostly already installed. Interference in signal Collected own data set CNN
[182] 2021 Smart-home, smart-gym fitness tracker solution using a single mm-wave radar point cloud data Radar sensors

The privacy of the user is intact.

contactless, accurate, real-time fitness tracker system

for indoor fitness activities, capable of running on edge devices

for applications in IoT-connected healthcare

Interference/noise has not been commented upon Data set collected from radar sensors Deep learning
[170] 2021 Combination of acceleration audio and wifi round trip time localization to recognize indoor activities. Wifi round trip audio acceleration Audio related to activity gives another useful feature in recognition. Accuracy is consistent upon 12 activities

Limited activities,

Maybe not suitable if activities with similar audio are tested, technology used is relatively new and hardware is not ubiquitous

Dataset created and model trained again and again for new activities ML
[7] 2021 Gives a mathematical representation for human body as clusters of different points Radio frequency Time variant features and properties explored while representing human as cluster of scattered points Signa based, stationary objects CSI and IMU data were used as collected ML
[83] 2015 online activity recognition system, which explores WiFi ambient signals for received signal strength indicator (RSSI) fingerprint of different activities. Wifi signal data

Simple use.

Fine average accuracy

context between persons and motions, context between locations and motions, and even context between emotions and motions can be explored as the current scenario is simple Data collected using set up/ wifi ML
[186] 2018 Uses video camera and radar sensors fusion for predicting activities Radar sensors, video camera Fusion of radar and video with deep learning gives good accuracy Computation can be worked upon Accuracy checked on Standard data set DL
[148] 2019 robust approach for human activity recognition which uses the open source library OpenPose to extract anatomical key points from RGB images. Camera vision based Good accuracy on standard datasets. Good approach for independent living for elderly OpenPose can be difficult to use Standard dataset RNN with LSTM