Skip to main content
. 2023 May 11;18(5):e0285629. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0285629

Table 5. Unmatched test scores in five noise sources at all SNRs.

The results are averaged over all testing utterances.

Noise Algorithm STOI (in%) PESQ SDR
Airport Noise Noisy (UnP) 71.6 1.83 0.14
DNN-IRM 82.6 2.27 6.30
LSTM-IRM 85.0 2.37 6.84
LSTM-KF 85.9 2.40 6.96
FDNN-KF 83.4 2.31 6.41
DeepXi-KF 86.7 2.45 7.21
DeepResGRU-KF 86.9 2.46 7.31
Proposed 87.6 2.48 7.39
Babble Noise Noisy (UnP) 65.9 1.72 0.19
DNN-IRM 76.7 2.12 6.13
LSTM-IRM 78.5 2.23 6.31
LSTM-KF 79.1 2.28 6.35
FDNN-KF 77.2 2.15 6.18
DeepXi-KF 80.2 2.30 6.45
DeepResGRU-KF 80.8 2.32 6.51
Proposed 81.0 2.35 6.62
Car Noise Noisy (UnP) 67.5 1.65 0.13
DNN-IRM 79.6 2.17 6.38
LSTM-IRM 82.8 2.33 6.92
LSTM-KF 83.1 2.40 7.01
FDNN-KF 80.1 2.21 6.45
DeepXi-KF 84.2 2.45 7.12
DeepResGRU-KF 84.8 2.48 7.28
Proposed 86.0 2.49 7.45
Factory Noise Noisy (UnP) 66.1 1.61 0.18
DNN-IRM 75.7 2.08 5.92
LSTM-IRM 78.6 2.24 6.39
LSTM-KF 78.8 2.29 6.45
FDNN-KF 76.0 2.10 8.98
DeepXi-KF 79.5 2.35 6.57
DeepResGRU-KF 80.2 2.38 6.71
Proposed 81.3 2.39 6.87
Street Noise Noisy (UnP) 66.8 1.73 0.22
DNN-IRM 77.8 2.18 6.06
LSTM-IRM 81.5 2.31 6.34
LSTM-KF 81.9 2.35 6.40
FDNN-KF 78.0 2.21 6.10
DeepXi-KF 82.6 2.38 6.45
DeepResGRU-KF 84.7 2.40 6.58
Proposed 85.1 2.42 6.63