Skip to main content
. 2023 May 12;9:81. doi: 10.1186/s40814-023-01303-4

Table 1.

Step 1: Systematic braiding. Shared elements of SafeCare and SFH

Elements SafeCare elements Shared elements Smoke-free home elements
Participants Parents of young children involved with child welfare Parents of children 0–5 years who are at increased risk for SHS exposure Targets low-income households with at least one smoker and at least one nonsmoker
Focus Parent skill training for new parenting behaviors Parent behavior change Implement smoke-free home rules and change smoking behavior
Target for session delivery Individual parent and child Individual parent Parent as household change agent
Mode of delivery In-person at home In-home Telephone and mail to homes
Dosage Weekly for 18–20 weeks Brief Once every 2 weeks for 6 weeks
Length 18 sessions  ≥ 6 weeks Four contacts in 6 weeks
Content Explain, practice, model, and feedback approach to target behaviors for child safety and health and parent–child interactions Structured curricula with protocol guidance for intervention deliverers. Parent-friendly content to help generalize skill change “Five-Step Guide to a Smoke-Free Home” booklet, challenges and solutions booklet, stickers, signs pledges, newsletter, photonovella and coaching to set goals
Process assessment Observational and satisfaction measures Program evaluation embedded in delivery Relevance, usefulness, satisfaction
Theoretical underpinnings Social cognitive theory97 Social cognitive theory Social cognitive theory, TTM99
Provider Bachelor’s degree or above Bachelor’s degree sufficient None specified

Fidelity

monitoring

Score audio recorded sessions with fidelity checklist Audio recordings of coaching Documentation of mailing sent, audio recording of coaching calls, and feedback