Table 2.
Ref. | ML/DL | Algorithm/Method | Dataset Size | TBI-related Clinical Assessment |
Performance | Main Contribution |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
[77] | ML | ReliefF feature selection, SVM | 17 | ICP > 15 vs. ICP ≤ 15 |
Acc: 81.79 ± 2.3 Sen: 82.25 ± 1.7 Spec: 81.20 ± 0.04 |
Textural-based ICP estimation using Histogram analysis, GLRLM, DWPT, Fourier Transform, and DT-CWT |
[80] | ML | SVM | 17I | ICP > 12 vs. ICP ≤ 12 |
Acc: 70.2 ± 4.5 Sen: 65.2 ± 8.6 Spec: 73.7 ± 4.6 |
Textural-based ICP estimation using Histogram analysis, GLRLM, DWPT, Fourier Transform, DT-CWT as well as hematoma volume, manual MLS measurement, age, and ISS |
[81] | ML` | SVM | 17 | ICP > 12 vs. ICP ≤ 12 |
Acc: 73.7 Sen: 68.6 Spec: 76.6 |
Textural-based; improving previous model [80] by adding intracranial air cavities, ventricle size related feature |
[83] | ML | GA-SVM and GA-KNN based feature selection, SVM classification method |
59 | ICP > 15 vs. ICP < 15 |
Acc: 86.5 | Textural-based; using anisotropic complex wavelet as textural feature for ICP classification |
[82] | ML | GA-SVM based feature selection, SVR classification method |
59 | ICP > 15 vs. ICP < 15 |
Acc: 0.94 MAE: 4.25 mmHg |
Textural-based; comparing anisotropic complex wavelet transform extracted features vs. DT-CWT extracted features in ICP classification. |
[76] | Hounsfield units thresholding | 20 | ICP > 20 vs. ICP < 20 |
Acc: 0.67 | Morphological-based; brain parenchyma segmentation, ICP estimation based on csfv/icvv ratio | |
[69] | ML | Black box model | 11 | ICP | MAE: 4.0 ± 1.8 mmHg | Physiological-based; non-invasive prediction of ICP using ABP and FV of major cerebral arteries. |
[70] | ML | SVM | 446 | ICP | Mean ICP error: 6.7 mmHg | Physiological-based; noninvasive measurement of ICP using ABP and FV of major cerebral arteries |
[71] | ML | Linear regression |
74 | ICP > 20 vs. ICP ≤ 20 |
AUC: 0.94 | Morphological-based; estimating the probability of increase ICP by measuring MRI-based ONSD |
[80] | ML | Gaussian mixture model | 57 | ICP > 12 vs. ICP ≤ 12 |
Acc: 0.70 | Textural-based ICP estimation; using tissue textural features, manual MLS quantification, ISS, and age |
[79] | ML | Information gain ratio, GA feature selection, SVM | 57 | ICP > 12 vs. ICP ≤ 12 |
Acc: 0.70 Sen: 0.65 Spec: 0.73 |
Textural-based ICP estimation; automated iML detection; using textural features, MLS, and blood amount to estimate ICP |
[87] | Bezier curve, GA | 81 | MLS | Acc: 0.95 | Symmetry-based; detecting dML at the foramen of Monro level; Low performance in case of severe TBI |
|
[88] | ML | H-MLS (Linear Regression based), visual symmetry information | 11 | MLS | - | Symmetry-based; tracing dML based on the brain hemorrhage detection |
[89] | Weighted midline, maximum distance | 41 | MLS | Acc: 0.92 | Symmetry-based; estimating MLS based on the maximum distance between WML and iML close to the foramen of Monro |
|
[94] | ML | CT density, spatial filtering, cluster analysis | 273 | MLS | Sen:1 Spec: 0.98 |
Landmark-based; using spatial filtering, CT density thresholds, and cluster analysis to segment blood and CSF. The symmetry of CSF pixels in the lateral ventricles is used to assess MLS |
[90] | ML | Level-set | 170 | MLS | Acc: 0.68 | Landmark-based; automating CT slice selection, rotation, and segmentation |
[91] | ML | Active contour, Logistic regression | 48 | MSS vs. MLS |
AUC: 0.71 Acc: 0.79 |
Landmark-based; volumetric measurement of displaced brain mass was significantly correlated with GOS on discharge |
[44] | DL | NPL | 313, 318 (Qure25k dataset); 491 (CQ500 dataset) as validation set | MLS | AUC: 0·969 Sen: 0.938 Spec: 0.907 |
Detecting mass effect which consists of MLS, ventricular effacement, herniation, or local mass effect |
[92] | DL | RLDN | 189 (CQ500 dataset [44] and local resources) | MLS | F1-score: 0.78 | Developing a multi-scale bidirectional FCN based method [95] for midline delineation in severe brain deformation |
[93] | DL | U-Net | 45 | MLS | Acc: 0.94 | Deformed right and left hemispheres were automatically segmented. The junction of these two segments was then traced to forms dML. |
[43] | DL | U-Net based FCN | 38 | MLS < 5 mm vs. MLS > 5 mm |
Acc: 0.89 | MLS estimation at all levels between the lateral ventricles roof and foramen of Monro was performed. The greatest MLS score was considered the final MLS. |