Table 1.
Randomized controlled trials on nitric oxide administration for the treatment of various clinical conditions.
Trial | Aim/hypothesis | Population (N) | Treatment group | Control group | NO dose | Primary endpoint | Main results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| |||||||
Respiratory failure | |||||||
| |||||||
Wu, 2016 [19] | Efficacy in PPHN | Newborns (86) | iNO + HFOV | HFOV | 20–80 ppm | PAP, FiO2, OI, duration of MV and O2 therapy, mortality | All endpoints better in the iNO than in control group |
Bronicki, 2015 [20] | iNO ↓ MV duration in HRF | Pediatric (55) | iNO until death or 28 d or ventilator free | Placebo until death or 28 d or ventilator free | 5 ppm | VFD at 28 d | VFD greater in the iNO group (p = 0.05) |
González, 2010 [21] | Early iNO prevents severe HRF in moderate HRF and PAH | Newborns (56) | iNO + conventional MV | Conventional MV | 20 ppm | Rate of progression to OI > 40 | 25% iNO vs 61% control group (p < 0.05) |
Su, 2008 [22] | iNO ↓ OI in HRF | Preterm infants (65) | iNO + conventional care | Conventional care | 5–20 ppm | Mean OI at 24 h | OI ↓ in the iNO group (p < 0.01) |
Dani, 2007 [23] | iNO ↓ BPD and/or death in HRF | Preterm infants (40) | iNO at 10 ppm for 4 h, then 6 ppm until extubation or FiO2 <30% w/MAP <8 cm H2O + conventional care | Conventional care | 6–10 ppm | BPD incidence and death | 50% iNO vs 90% control group (p = 0.016) |
Lindwall, 2005 [24] | Effect of iNO on oxygenation in HRF | Preterm infants (15) | iNO for 30 min + nasal CPAP | Nasal CPAP + placebo | 10 ppm | Changes in oxygenation measured as aAPO2 | aAPO2 ↑ 20% in the iNO group (p = 0.006) |
Schreiber, 2003 [25] | iNO ↓ incidence of chronic lung disease/ death | Preterm infants (207) | iNO 10 ppm day 1, then 5 ppm for 6 d | Placebo | 5–10 ppm | Incidence of chronic lung disease/death | 48,6% iNO vs 63.7% control group (p = 0.03) |
Sadiq, 2003 [26] | iNO prevents worsening of PAH in PPHN | near-term and term infants (80) | iNO + conventional care | Conventional care | Up to 80 ppm | Development of severe PPHN | 15% iNO vs 58% control group (p < 0.0005) |
Srisuparp, 2002 [27] | Safety and effect of iNO on oxygenation in mild to moderate HRF | Preterm infants (34) | iNO 20 ppm, then weaned to 5 ppm over 1–2 d | Conventional care | 5–20 ppm | IVH incidence, OI, paO2 | No differences in IVH incidence between groups. OI ↓ 15% and paO2 ↑ by 50% in iNO group (p = 0.04 and 0.02, respectively) |
Baxter, 2002 [28] | Efficacy of iNO on oxygenation, shunt and PVRI in HRF | Adults (14) | iNO + 100% O2 for 30 min, then 30 min wash-out, then no iNO + 100% O2 for 30 min. | Randomized cross-over | 5–25 ppm | Shunt, PVRI, oxygenation | iNO ↓ pulmonary shunt (p = 0.002). Other endpoints: ns |
Christou, 2000 [29] | iNO ↓ mortality and ↓ ECMO use in PPHN | near-term and term newborns (40) | iNO + HFOV | HFOV | Up to 40 ppm | Mortality, ECMO use | ECMO use: 14% iNO vs 55% control group (p = 0.007), Mortality: ns. |
Clark, 2000 [30] | Low-dose iNO ↓ ECMO use in PPHN | near-term and term newborns (248) | iNO at 20 ppm up to 1 d, then 5 ppm up to 4 d | Placebo | 5–20 ppm | ECMO use | ECMO use: 38% iNO vs 64% control group (p = 0.001) |
The Franco- Belgium Collaborative NO Trail Group, 1999 [31] | iNO ↑ oxygenation in HRF | preterm and near-term newborns (204) | iNO | Placebo | 10 ppm | OI change at 2 h | OI ↓ 6.2 iNO vs 2.9 control group (p = 0.005) |
Dobyns, 1999 [32] | iNO effect on oxygenation in HRF | Children (108) | iNO for minimum 3 d + MV | MV | 10 ppm | OI | OI ↓ 10.2 iNO vs 2.7 control group (p < 0.05) |
Troncy, 1998 [33] | iNO effect on lung function in ARDS | Adults (30) | iNO + conventional care | Conventional care | 0.5–40 ppm | P/F, alveolar dead space, lung compliance, venous admixture | P/F ↑ 59% in INO vs 9.3% control group (p = 0.02). Other endpoints: ns |
Michael, 1998 [34] | iNO effect on oxygenation in ARDS | Adults (40) | iNO + conventional care up to 3 d | Conventional care | 5–20 ppm | P/F | P/F t in the first 24 h in the iNO group. |
Dellinger, 1998 [35] | iNO effect on oxygenation in ARDS | Adults (117) | iNO | Placebo | 1.25–80 ppm | paO2 ↑ >20% | ~60% responders in iNO vs 24% control group in the first 4 h (p ≤ 0.021) |
The NINOS Group, 1997 [36] | iNO ↓ ECMO use and/ or death in HRF | near-term and term newborns (235) | iNO | 100% O2 | 20 ppm | ECMO use and/or death | 64% iNO vs 46% vs control group (p = 0.006) |
Wessel, 1997 [37] | iNO effect on mortality, ECMO use and oxygenation in PPHN | near-term and term Newborns (49) | iNO + conventional care | Conventional care | 5–80 ppm | Mortality, ECMO use, OI | OI ↓ 31% iNO vs control group.Other endpoints: ns |
Roberts Jr, 1997 [38] | iNO effect on oxygenation in PPHN | Term infants (58) | iNO + conventional care | Placebo + conventional care | 80 ppm | Doubling rate of oxygenation | 53% iNO vs 7% control group (p = 0.002) |
NCT00240487 | Determine iNO treatment timing in pediatric ARDS | Children (52) | iNO for the first 4 h, then no iNO for 4 h | No iNO for the first 4 h, then iNO for 4 h | 10 ppm | Changes in P/F ratio | ns |
Van Meurs, 2007 [39] | iNO ↓ BPD and/or death in HRF | Preterm infants (29) | iNO + conventional care up to 14 d | Conventional care | 5–10 ppm | BPD incidence and death | ns |
Field, 2007 [40] | Assess clinical and cost-effectiveness of iNO in HRF | Infants (60) | iNO + conventional care | Conventional care | 5–20 ppm | Death and severe disability | ns |
Kinsella, 2006 [41] | iNO ↓ BPD and/or death in HRF | Preterm infants (793) | iNO for 21 d or until extubation + conventional care | Conventional care | 5 ppm | BPD incidence and death | ns |
Meurs, 2005 [42] | iNO ↓ BPD and/or death in HRF | Preterm infants (420) | iNO | Conventional care | 5–10 ppm | BPD incidence and death | ns |
Hascoet, 2005 [43] | Safety and efficacy in infants w/HRF | Preterm infants (860) | iNO | Placebo | 5 ppm | Intact survival at 28 d | ns |
Taylor, 2004 [44] | Efficacy of iNO in ARDS | Adults (385) | iNO until 28 d or discontinuation of assisted breathing or death | Placebo until 28 d or discontinuation of assisted breathing or death | 5 ppm | Days alive and off assisted breathing | ns |
Konduri, 2004 [45] | iNO ↓ incidence of ECMO/death in HRF | near-term and term infants (299) | iNO | Placebo | 5–20 ppm | Incidence of ECMO/ death | ns |
Finer, 2001 [46] | No differences in oxygenation improvement between low and high dose of iNO in pts w/ HRF | near-term and term infants (36) | Low-dose iNO (LD) | High-dose iNO (HD) | LD: 1–2 ppm HD: 10–20 ppm | paO2, OI | ns |
Cornfield, 1999 [47] | iNO ↑ oxygenation in PPHN | near-term and term infants (38) | iNO 2 ppm, 20 ppm if worsening oxygenation | Placebo, 20 ppm if worsening oxygenation | 2–20 ppm | OI | ns |
Kinsella, 1999 [48] | iNO ↑ survival in HRF | Preterm infants (80) | iNO | Placebo | 5 ppm | Survival to discharge | ns |
Lundin, 1999 [49] | iNO ↑ reversal of ALI in pts previously responder to iNO | Adults (268) | iNO up to 30 days or endpoint reached | Conventional care | 1–40 ppm | Rate of ALI reversal | ns |
Davidson, 1998 [50] | Efficacy of iNO on PPHN | Term infants (155) | iNO + conventional care | Conventional care | 5–80 ppm | Major Sequelae Index (incidence of death, ECMO, neurologic | ns |
The NINOS Group, 1997 [51] | iNO ↓ ECMO use and/ or death in HRF and congenital diaphragmatic hernia | near-term and term infants (53) | iNO | 100% O2 | 20 ppm | injury, BPD) ECMO use/death | ns |
Barefield, 1996 [52] | iNO ↓ ECMO use in PPHN | near-term and term infants (17) | iNO + conventional MV | Conventional MV | 20–80 ppm | ECMO use | ns |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Pulmonary Arterial Hypertension | |||||||
| |||||||
Nathan, 2020 [53] | iNO ↑ physical activity in PAH + pulmonary fibrosis | Adults (41) | Pulsed iNO for 8w | Placebo | 30 μg/kg IBW/h | moderate/vigorous physical activity improvement | ↑ in the iNO vs control group |
Vonbank, 2003 [54] | iNO safety in pts w/ PAH due to COPD | Adults (40) | Pulsed iNO + O2 over 3 months | O2 | 20 ppm | Pulmonary and systemic hemodynamics. Arterial oxygenation. NO2 | ↑ in pulmonary hemodynamics. Other endpoints: ns |
Hasuda, 2000 [55] | iNO ↑ exercise capacity in precapillary PAH | Adults (14) | iNO + exercise on a cycle ergometer | Exercise on a cycle ergometer (Randomized cross-over) | 20 ppm | Peak exercise load, anaerobic threshold, VO2 | Only VO2 ↑ in the iNO vs control group |
Van Meurs, 1997 [56] | iNO effect on oxygenation HRF | Preterm (11) | iNO | Placebo, (Randomized, cross-over) | 1–20 ppm | P/F | P/F ↑ >25% in 10 out of 11 participants |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
AKI prevention after CPB | |||||||
| |||||||
Lei, 2018 [18] | NO ↓ AKI after CPB | Adults (244) | NO for 24 h | Placebo | 80 ppm | AKI occurrence | |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
50% NO vs 64% control group (p = 0.014) | |||||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
NO during CPB for CHD | |||||||
| |||||||
Elzein, 2020 [57] | NO ↓ ischemia/ reperfusion injury | Newborns (24) | NO | Placebo | 40 ppm | Multiple markers of organ injury | Only Tn lower in the iNO vs control group (p = 0.009) |
James, 2016 [58] | NO ↓ LCOS | Children (198) | NO | Placebo | 20 ppm | LCOS incidence | 15% iNO vs 31% control group (p = 0.007) |
Checchia, 2013 [59] | NO ↓ ischemia/ reperfusion injury | Children (16) | NO | Placebo | 20 ppm | Duration MV, ICU LOS, TnI and BNP levels | All endpoints better in the iNO group (p < 0.05) |
Miller, 2000 [60] | NO ↓ PAH crises | Infants (124) | NO | Placebo | 10 ppm | Number of PAH crises | 4 PAH crises NO vs 7 control group (p < 0.001) |
Day, 2000 [61] | NO ↓ PAH crises | Infants (40) | NO | Placebo | 20 ppm | Number of PAH crises | ns |
Niebler, 2021 [62] | NO ↓ activation and depletion of PLTs | Infants (40) | NO | Placebo | 20 ppm | PLTs count | ns |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Resuscitation | |||||||
| |||||||
Sekar, 2020 [63] | Prevention of O2 exposure during resuscitation | Preterm infants needing help with breathing (28) | iNO for 17 min | Placebo for 17 min | 20 ppm | Cumulative FiO2, time w/FiO2 >60%, pre/postductal saturation, heart rate, need for intubation | Cumulative FiO2 (p = 0.001) and time w/FiO2 >60% (p < 0.0001) lower in the iNO group |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Transfusions | |||||||
| |||||||
Berra, 2014 [16] | Blood transfusions older than 40 d ↑ PAP | Obese adults (14) | Transfusion with 3-d, 40-d, and 40-d old blood with iNO | Randomized cross-over | 80 ppm | PAP | 40 d old blood ↑ PAP. iNO prevents it |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Sickle cell disease | |||||||
| |||||||
Head, 2010 [64] | iNO ↓ intensity of painful crisis | Adults (23) | iNO for 4 h | Room air | 80 ppm | Mean change of pain score after 4 h of iNO | iNO ↓ pain scores (p = 0.02) |
Maitre, 2015 [65] | iNO ↓ treatment failure in pts with acute chest syndrome | Adults (100) | iNO for 3 d | Placebo | 80 ppm | Treatment failure rate at 3 d | ns |
Gladwin, 2011 [66] | iNO ↓ duration of painful crisis | >10 years old (150) | iNO up to 3 d | Placebo | 40–80 ppm | Time to resolution of painful crisis | ns |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Severe malaria | |||||||
| |||||||
Bangirana, 2018 [67] | Neuroprotective role of iNO | Children (130) | iNO up to 72 h | Room air | 80 ppm | Neurocognitive outcomes | ↓ fine motor impairment in iNO vs control group (RR, 95% CI: 0.36, 0.14–0.96) |
Conroy, 2016 [68] | Safety of iNO | Children (180) | iNO for 3 d | Room air | 80 ppm | MetHb levels >10% mandate treatment interruption | MetHb >10% in 5.7% patients in iNO group. Authors conclude iNO is safe if MetHb is measured during administration |
Hawkes, 2015 [69] | iNO ↑ severe malaria outcome | Children (180) | iNO up to 3 d | Room air | 80 ppm | Ang-2 levels in the first 3 d | ns |
Mwanga- Amumpaire, 2015 [70] | iNO ↑ Ang-1 | Children (92) | iNO for at least 2 d | Room air | 80 ppm | Ang-1 levels at 2 d | ns |
Legend:
decreases/decreased
increases/increased.
Abbreviations: aAPO2, alveolar-arterial oxygen tension difference; AKI, acute kidney injury; ALI, acute lung injury; Ang-1/Ang-2, angiotensin 1 and 2; ARDS, acute respiratory distress syndrome; BNP, B-type natriuretic peptide; BPD, bronchopulmonary dysplasia; CI, confidence interval; cmH2O, centimeters of water; COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; CPAP, continuous positive airway pressure; d, day(s); d, day(s); ECMO, extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; FiO2, fraction of inspired oxygen; h, hour(s); h, hour; HFOV, high frequency oscillatory ventilation; HRF, hypoxic respiratory failure; IBW, ideal body weight; iNO, inhaled nitric oxide; IVH, intraventricular hemorrhage; LCOS: low cardiac output syndrome; LOS, length of stay; MAP, mean arterial pressure; MetHb, methemoglobin; MV, mechanical ventilation; n.a., not available; NO, nitric oxide; NO2, nitrogen dioxide; ns, not significant; O2, oxygen; OI, oxygenation index; P/F, partial oxygen pressure-to-fraction of inspired oxygen ratio; PAH, pulmonary artery hypertension; paO2, partial pressure of oxygen; PAP, pulmonary artery pressure; PLTs, platelets; PPHN, persistent pulmonary hypertension of the newborn; ppm, part per million; PVRI, pulmonary vascular resistances index; RR, relative risk; Tn, troponin; VFD, ventilator- free days; VO2, oxygen consumption; w, week(s); w/, with.