Skip to main content
. 2019 Sep 12;23(3):457–473. doi: 10.1017/S1368980019002167

Table 3.

Measures of food environment, diet and body weight status in the studies included in the review

Study ID First author (year) Type of food environment measure Detailed measure of food environment Type of diet measure Detailed measure of diet Type of body weight status measure Detailed measure of body weight status
1 Ho(2010)(21) Self-report questionnaire The perceived presence of McDonald’s, KFC, Hong Kong-style fast-food shops, Chinese, Western and Hong Kong-style restaurants and 24-h convenience stores near home Self-report questionnaire Food consumption:
  • 1.

    high-fat foods

  • 2.

    junk food/soft drinks

  • 3.

    fruit

  • 4.

    vegetables

Self-report
  • 1.

    Height

  • 2.

    Weight

  • 3.

    BMI z-score

2 Li(2011)(25) School doctors report questionnaire Western fast food restaurants near school within 10-min walk Objectively measurement
  • 1.

    Height

  • 2.

    Body weight

  • 3.

    BMI

3 Zhang (2012)(33) Community heads and community accountants report questionnaire
  • 1.

    The number of food retailing businesses

  • 2.

    The penetration of supermarkets in each community

Objectively measurement
  • 1.

    Height

  • 2.

    Body weight

  • 3.

    BMI

4 Wang (2012)(17) Self-report questionnaire Neighbourhood densities of:
  • 1.

    wet markets

  • 2.

    supermarkets

  • 3.

    fast food restaurant

Self-report questionnaires Nutrition intake:
  • 1.

    total caloric intake

  • 2.

    total protein intake

  • 3.

    total fat intake

  • 4.

    total carbohydrate intake

5 Xu (2013)(29) Local officials report questionnaire The number of Western styles fast-food restaurants such as McDonald’s and Kentucky Fried Chicken in the community or within 1 km if outside the community Objectively measurement
  • 1.

    Weight

  • 2.

    Height

  • 3.

    Waist and hip circumferences

  • 4.

    Body mass index

  • 5.

    Waist-to-height ratio

  • 6.

    Waist-to-hip ratio

6 Du (2014)(26) Community leader report questionnaire
  • 1.

    Fast-food restaurants

  • 2.

    Indoor restaurants

  • 3.

    Fixed outdoor food stalls

Objectively measurement
  • 1.

    Height

  • 2.

    Weight

  • 3.

    Body mass index

7 Hua (2014)(27) Objective measure The existence and density of the food establishments Objectively measurement
  • 1.

    Height

  • 2.

    Weight

  • 3.

    Body mass index

8 Li (2014)(23) Parent report questionnaire Walking distance to a convenience store Parent-report questionnaire Food consumption:
  • 1.

    snacks

  • 2.

    fruit

  • 3.

    vegetables

Objectively measurement
  • 1.

    Height

  • 2.

    Weight

  • 3.

    Body mass index

9 Seto (2016)(22) Objective measure The number of food establishments Self-record by phone Food consumption:
  • 1.

    meal

  • 2.

    snack

10 Tian (2016)(20) Community leader report questionnaire
  • 1.

    Fast food restaurants

  • 2.

    Indoor restaurants

  • 3.

    Outdoor food stands

Self-report questionnaire
  • 1.

    Food consumption: the types, amounts, types of meals (breakfast, lunch, dinner, snack), location

  • 2.

    Eating away from home

Objectively measurement
  • 1.

    Height

  • 2.

    Weight

  • 3.

    Body mass index

11 Zhang (2016)(32) Objective measure: geographic information system The proximities to four main kinds of food establishments:
  • 1.

    Grocery store,

  • 2.

    Free market

  • 3.

    Restaurant

  • 4.

    Food stall

Objectively measurement
  • 1.

    Height

  • 2.

    Weight

  • 3.

    Body mass index

12 Jia (2017)(19) School administrators report questionnaire Food regulations in school vicinity food stalls Self-report questionnaire Food consumption:
  • 1.

    sugary beverage

  • 2.

    snack

  • 3.

    fast food

  • 3.

    street food consumption

Objective measurement
  • 1.

    Weightv

  • 2.

    Height

  • 3.

    Body mass index

  • 4.

    Waist circumference

13 Johar (2017)(31) The community representative report questionnaire The availability of Western fast-food restaurants Objective
measurement
  • 1.

    Body mass index

  • 2.

    Arm fat ratio

  • 3.

    Waist-to-hip ratio

14 Li (2017)(30) School administrators reported questionnaire Restaurants close to school Self-report
  • 1.

    Body weight

  • 2.

    Height

  • 3.

    Body mass index

15 Wang (2017)(18) Subjective measure Access to food markets Self-report questionnaire Diet diversity:
  • 1.

    food variety

  • 2.

    food items

  • 3.

    food group

16 Zhou (2017)(28) Objective measure
  • 1.

    Supermarket

  • 2.

    Fresh food market

  • 3.

    Fast food restaurant

  • 4.

    Convenience store

  • 5.

    Full service restaurants

Objective
measurement
  • 1.

    Weight

  • 2.

    Height

17 Zhong (2018)(24) Objective measure Proximity to wet markets and supermarkets Self-report questionnaire Diet diversity:
  • 1.

    food items

  • 2.

    food groups