Skip to main content
. 2023 Mar 20;14(3):500–515. doi: 10.1016/j.advnut.2023.03.007

TABLE 1.

Eligibility criteria for guidance documents included in this meta-epidemiologic study

Category Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria
Study design Any guidance documents with nutrition recommendations1
  • Clinical practice guidelines

  • Food-based dietary guidelines

  • Official position statements

  • Consensus statements

Latest version of any regularly updated guidance documents (final search date for updates was 11 February 2022)
Any clinical study or case study
Letters to the editor
Protocols
Background reading
Any reviews:
  • Meta-analyses

  • Systematic reviews

  • Narrative reviews


Date of publication January 2010–February 2022 Before 2010

Publication status Articles published in peer-reviewed journals
Guidance documents published on websites of major medical professional societies, governments, or large health stakeholder associations
Articles not published in peer-reviewed journals or on websites of major medical professional societies, governments, or large health stakeholder associations

Authors/publishers Major medical professional societies
Governments
Large health stakeholder associations
Individual authors
Small or niche organizations

Language of publication English language Non-English languages

Country No restriction NA

Population Free-living humans Non–free-living humans (for example, residential care)
Animals

Age of study participants Adults (18+ y) Infants/young children (0–3 y)
Children/adolescents (>3 to <18 y)

Health status of population Generally healthy (document focus is on general health promotion)
Chronic diseases or specific health conditions limited to the following:
  • CVD

  • Type 2 diabetes

  • Any cancer

  • Autoimmune diseases such as (but not limited to) type 1 diabetes, multiple sclerosis, Crohn disease, lupus, inflammatory bowel disease, rheumatoid arthritis, psoriasis, Graves disease, Guillain-Barré syndrome, and celiac disease

  • Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

  • Digestive diseases such as irritable bowel syndrome

  • Weight-related conditions or diseases including overweight, obesity, weight loss, or healthy weight maintenance

Pregnant or lactating women
Illness other than the specified chronic diseases
Other health conditions (for example, sepsis)
Accident victims

Intervention or exposure Guidance or recommendations (for example, increase, decrease, exclude, or include specific quantities) for the following:
  • Dietary patterns (for example, vegetarian, Mediterranean, and DASH)

  • Foods (for example, bread, juice, and milk)

  • Food groups (for example, meat, vegetables, and dairy)

  • Food components (for example, refined flours, confections, and sugar-sweetened beverages)

  • Ingredients (for example, vegetable oils and added sugars)

No real guidance or recommendation for diet
Only talks about micronutrients (for example, sodium and fiber) without any mention of the inclusion criteria
Only talks about macronutrients without any mention of the inclusion criteria
Only talks about supplements or enteral/parenteral nutrition
Primary focus is nutrients only (even if specific foods are mentioned)

1

Only the clinical practice guidelines found eligible for this meta-epidemiological study are within the scope of this report.