Skip to main content
. 2023 May 22;2023(5):CD004128. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004128.pub5

Bernard 2002.

Study characteristics
Methods Study type: RCT
Aim of the study: efficacy
Participating sites: 4 university and community hospitals in Melbourne, Australia
Language: English
Start date, end date: September 1996 to June 1999
Participants Number randomised: 43 (intervention); 34 (control)
Inclusion criteria: an initial cardiac rhythm of VF at time of arrival of the ambulance, successful ROSC, persistent coma after the ROSC and transfer to 1 of 4 participating emergency departments
Exclusion criteria: non‐cardiac causes including trauma, drowning, hanging and intoxication; predicted death within 72 hours; contraindications to TTM including haemorrhage, fatal arrhythmia and sepsis; baseline CPC score 3; presence of an advanced directive to withhold or withdraw life‐sustaining treatment or lack of informed consent
Mean/median age: 66 years
Women: 33%
Cardiac arrest location: out‐of‐hospital
Cause of cardiac arrest: any
Primary cardiac rhythm: VF
Witnessed cardiac arrest: 95%
Bystander CPR: 59%
Timing cardiac arrest (out‐of‐hospital cardiac arrest) (minutes):
  • collapse to call: 2.1 (SD 1.9) (intervention); 2.7 (SD 3.0) (control)

  • call to arrival of EMS: 7.9 (SD 3.1) (intervention); 8.3 (SD 2.8) (control)

  • collapse to ROSC 26.5 (SD 12.9) (intervention); 25.0 (SD 8.9) (control)


Temperature on admission/at start of cooling: 35 °C (intervention); 35.5 °C (control)
Subgroups reported: none
Interventions Prehospital cooling: yes, 56%
Target temperature intervention: 33 °C
Duration of TTM: 12 hours
Was intervention initiated within 2 hours of ROSC? yes
Was target temperature reached within 4 hours of ROSC? yes
Co‐interventions? yes
Description of control group management: target core temperature 37 °C. Passive rewarming used in these participants if there was mild spontaneous hypothermia on arrival.
Cooling rates: n.i.
Was rewarming controlled? yes
Rewarming: passive after 12 hours, active after 18 hours
Outcomes Survival with good neurological function to be sent home or to a rehabilitation facility at discharge
In‐hospital death
Haemodynamic, biochemical and haematological effects of hypothermia
Best ever reached CPC during hospital stay and CPC discharge was provided by the investigators.
Control group treatment Target core temperature 37 °C. Passive rewarming used in these participants if there was mild spontaneous hypothermia on arrival.
Funding source  
Notes Randomisation: odd and even days