Skip to main content
. 2023 May 22;2023(5):CD004128. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004128.pub5

HACA 2002.

Study characteristics
Methods Study type: RCT
Aim of the study: efficacy
Participating sites: 9 university and community hospitals in 5 European countries
Language: English
Start date, end date: March 1996 to January 2001
Participants Number randomised: 275
Inclusion criteria: in‐hospital and out‐of‐hospital bystander‐witnessed cardiac arrest of presumed cardiac cause, VF or non‐perfusing VT as first cardiac rhythm, comatose after resuscitation
Exclusion criteria: a tympanic‐membrane temperature < 30 °C on admission, comatose state before the cardiac arrest due to the administration of drugs that depress the central nervous system, pregnancy, response to verbal commands after the ROSC and before randomisation, evidence of hypotension (mean arterial pressure, < 60 mmHg) for > 30 minutes after ROSC and before randomisation, evidence of hypoxaemia (arterial oxygen saturation, < 85%) for > 15 minutes after ROSC and before randomisation, terminal illness that preceded the arrest, factors that made participation in follow‐up unlikely, enrolment in another study, occurrence of cardiac arrest after arrival of emergency medical personnel, or a known pre‐existing coagulopathy
Mean age: 59 years
Women: 24%
Cardiac arrest location: in‐hospital and out‐of‐hospital
Cause of cardiac arrest: cardiac
Primary cardiac rhythm: VF or non‐perfusing VT
Witnessed cardiac arrest: 100%
Bystander CPR: 46%
Timing cardiac arrest (out‐of‐hospital cardiac arrest):
  • total collapse time (minutes, mean): 22.79 (IQR 17–32) (intervention); 21 (IQR 15–28) (control)


Temperature on admission/at start of cooling: 35.9 °C (intervention); 35.5 °C (control)
Subgroups reported: participants who died within 6 months after discharge from hospital
Interventions Number randomised: 137 (intervention); 138 (control)
Prehospital cooling: no
Target temperature intervention: 32–34 °C
Duration of intervention (median): 24 hours
Description of intervention: cooling blanket that covered the whole body and released cooled air
Was intervention started within 2 hours after ROSC: yes
Was target temperature reached within 4 hours of ROSC: no
Co‐interventions: no
Was rewarming controlled: no
Rewarming rate (per protocol): 0.37 °C/hour
Time from (minutes):
  • ROSC to start of TTM: 105

  • ROSC to target temperature: 480

Outcomes Best CPC of 1, 2 vs CPC of 3, 4, 5 for 6 months
Mortality at 6 months, rate of complication during first 7 days after cardiac arrest (bleeding of any severity)
Pneumonia, sepsis, pancreatitis, renal failure, pulmonary oedema, seizures, arrhythmias and pressure sores
Best ever reached CPC during hospital stay and CPC discharge provided
Control group treatment Participants randomly assigned to the normothermia group were placed on a conventional hospital bed, and normothermia was maintained.
Funding source Grants from the Fourth Research and Technological Development (RTD) Framework Programme 1994 to 1998 of the European Union (Fourth Framework Programme), the Austrian Ministry of Science and Transport and the Austrian Science Foundation (FWF).
Notes Randomisation: computer‐generated random sequence
Centre‐specific subsets of this study are also published as Tiainen 2003 (70 participants), Tiainen 2005 (60 participants) and Tiainen 2007 (70 participants) with more detailed investigations of neuropsychological and laboratory outcomes.