Skip to main content
. 2023 May 23;23:320. doi: 10.1186/s12903-023-02979-z

Table 2.

Evaluation of articles according to SURGE criteria: title, abstract, introduction, and methods

Section Description of the criterion Categories n
Title and abstract It states the word ‘questionnaire’ or ‘survey’ in the title and/or abstract. 1. In title and abstract 19
2. In title or abstract 78
3. No 2
Introduction There is an explanation of why the research is necessary. 1. Yes 99
2. No 0
It indicates the purpose or objective 1. Yes 99
2. No 0
Methods It describes the questionnaire/provides access to the items in the questionnaire 1. Questionnaire provided 45
Research instrument 2. Central questions provided 26
3. A complete question provided 0
4. Questions not provided 28
If an existing instrument was used, its psychometric properties were mentioned: confidence and validity 1. Yes 18
2. No 32
3. Not applicable 49
If an existing instrument was used, references to the original study are provided. 1. Yes 47
2. No 3
3. Not applicable 49
In a new instrument, the procedures used to develop it and/or the methods used for the pretest are mentioned. 1. Yes 26
2. No 23
3. Not applicable 50
In a new instrument, its validity and confidence were reported. 1. Both 4
2. Only confidence 7
3. Only validity 2
4. None 36
5. Not applicable 50
It describes the scoring procedures 1. Yes 77
2. No 6
3. Not applicable 16
Sample selection It describes the study population and sampling frame. 1. Both 46
2. Study population 28
3. Sampling frame 1
4. None 24
It describes the representativeness of the sample. 1. Yes 87
2. No 12
It presents a sample size calculation or justification of it. 1. Yes 81
2. No 18
Survey administration The mode of administration of the survey to participants is specified. 1. In person 75
2. Mail 6
3. Mixed 5
4. Not mentioned 13
Type and number of contacts 1. Type and number 33
2. Only type 53
3. No information 13
Financial or other incentives to study participants. 1. Yes 6
2. No 93
Description of who approached potential participants. 1. Yes 38
2. No 61
Analysis It describes the method of data analysis. 1. Adequate (complete) 91
2. Inadequate (incomplete) 4
3. Does not describe 4
It mentions the methods for nonresponse error analysis. 1. Yes 0
2. No 99
It mentions the method for calculating the response rate. 1. Yes 0
2. No 99
It mentions definitions for complete versus partial endings. 1. Yes 37
2. No 62
It mentions methods for handling missing item data. 1. Yes 5
2. No 94