Skip to main content
. 2023 May 13;9(5):e16290. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e16290
Equation Range Ideal value References
MAE=1Ni=1N|QiObsQiCal| 0 to ∞ 0 Tikhamarine et al. [117] (12)
MBE=1Ni=1N(QiObsQiCal) −∞ to +∞ 0 Valipour [118] (13)
RE=1Ni=1N(QiCalQiObs)1Ni=1N(QiObs) 0 to ∞ 0 Walther [119] (14)
RMSE=1Ni=1N(QiObsQiCal)2 0 to ∞ 0 Pandey et al. [120] (15)
R2=1i=1N(QiObsQiCal)2i=1N(QiObsQiCal)2 0 to 1 1 Nagelkerke [121] (16)
PCC=1i=1N(QiObsQiCal)2i=1N(QiObsQiCal)2 −1 to +1 1 Ozer [122] (17)
NSE=1i=1N(QiObsQiCal)2(QiObsQiObs)2 −∞ to 1 1 Nash and Sutcliffe [123,124] (18)
d=1i=1N(QiObsQiCal)2i=1N(|QiCalQiObs|+|QiObsQiObs|)2 0 to 1 1 Willmott [125,126] (19)
KGE=(PCC)2+(CDRD)2+(CMRM1)2 −∞ to 1 1 Gupta et al. [127] (20)

Note: QiCal = ith forecasted discharge data; QiObs = observed discharge data; N = number of observations; QiCal = mean value of observed discharge; QiCal = mean value of forecasted discharge; CC is the Pearson correlation coefficient value; RM is the average of observed values; CM is the average of forecast values; RD is the standard deviation of observation values; and CD is the standard deviation of forecast values. Following the maximum values of NSE, d, KGE, PCC(r), and R2; the minimum values of RMSE, MBE; MAE, and RE were near zero among the all-developed models, the most accurate models were chosen [77,78,128,129].